All Reader Reviews of...
164 W. 75th St., New York, NY, 10023
nr. Amsterdam Ave.
By augenbraum on 4/2/2007
For a restaurant with these prices it is shocking that when I arrived a few minutes before my early evening reservation and before the other two members of my party had arrived they would not seat me, even though only two or three tables were full in the entire restaurant and I politely asked to be seated. The food is very good, but not for those prices when you are treated as if you had just entered a trattoria.
By kaka on 6/15/2005
avoid at all cost bad mannered service 10 minutes with only bread at the table a $12 mini mimosa with tropicana and cheap cava a 1 hour wait for entrees a mediocre meal a $130 bill an aftertaste of bread an olive oil, which was the high point a ruined 40th birthdate
incredible arrogance and rudeness
By alexisjon on 3/23/2005
We had finally gotten a reservation at the highly touted Cesca. Our reservation was for 7:30 and 3 of the 4 were there at 7:25. We told the hostess the 4th person would be delayed (he was at meeting that was scheduled to end at any minute). They refused to seat us even though we offered to order the 4th persons meal, and said we would be put on "a rolling list" since we were not all present at the appointed hour. We were treated with disdain, rudeness and arrogance. We decided to leave after being treated like pariahs. As we left (quietly, no raised voices)the manager said "we'll remember you". There were dozens of people on the waiting list so they were not going to have any trouble filling our table. The place is dripping with the worst of NYC snobbish attitude. Who needs it?? There are too many other wonderful NYC restaurants that are user friendly.
Worth the Extra Effort
By martin_chamois on 1/14/2005
'Cesca is an outstanding restaurant. Unfortunately many people know that fact, and therefore it is a difficult reservation to obtain. But either with advanced planning or willingness to sit in the open front section, it is worth the extra effort. The food captures Italy without trying to exactly duplicate what you would eat in Italy. The service at all levels is outstanding. The decor is comforting and promotes a relaxed and friendly dinning experience. If 'Cesca was in any city other than New York, it would be the best in town.
By Potsandpans on 1/11/2005
I have great respect for Tom Valenti as a person and as a restaurateur, and I think his Ouest is the best restaurant on the Upper West Side. But 'Cesca, though not the worst, falls so far short of its promise. I went three times just to be certain that I was not catching them on an off-night. The problem is this: There is a huge difference between using Italian ingredients and serving Italian cooking. For anyone who has experienced genuine Italian food in Italy, it is obvious that 'Cesca is interpretive, and unsuccessful. The food is too heavy, greasy, salty, aggressive. Real Italian food (not Italian-American) is much more subtle. The servers are a combination of arrogant and clueless, and treat customers as if they did not know anything about Italian food -- including a guest I brought from Milano! Back to the drawing board Tom....you may be filling tables, but it is damaging your reputation.
Please Don't Go
By fadasan on 12/7/2004
This was like an Italian Restaurant in a midwest city: awful decor, TV on at the bar and mediocre, uninspired food. Although, come to think of it, in the Midwest, you would at least get some attentive service and pay 1/2 the price (the service was terrible). The food was really boring with cloying sauces and "cooking school" technique. WORST OF ALL, you would pay no less at Babbo. I'm not kidding. I do not get the hype at all. I have even been twice, thinking I might have had a bad first time, and both times it was perfectly consistent: uninspired, unattentive and overpriced. This shoud not be a "Recommended" New York Restaurant.
By newyorkbrit on 6/29/2004
Wow! This rivals LUPA for possibly the best Gnocchi in New York. Valenti wisely steers clear of Batali's "simplicity rules" mentality providing a mouth-watering shitake-mushroom gnocchi primi. Other excellent choices from the pasta include the shrimp raviolini with baby tomatoes.
By Will on 1/2/2004
'Cesca has it all: beautiful decor, diverse clientele, daringly mixed entrees as well as the basics, very creative desserts (like marzipan cheese cake with bitter orange sauce), and a host of Italian digestifs that brought me back to Grandma's. It's a can't-miss hit.
A huge Tom Valenti Fan
By truly_sweet on 11/3/2003
I am a huge Tom Valenti fan from way back - before Ouest, Before Butterfield 81 (by the way - wee miss you there), back to the days of Cascabel. He's a great guy, a superb chef and a talented restauranteur. Best of luck with 'Cesca
Lovely Space, Excellent Service and Food
By colpo on 10/20/2003
One is first struck by the exterior entrance: dressy but inviting. The interior attitude is welcoming, with an attractive bar and smaller standing tables. In the dining area, the food reigns. Try the pitch-perfect vitello tonnato or speck/rucola/poached egg starters, sublime in every respect. The special dorade was beautifully grilled, while the stewed tripe means one never need make it again at home (che puzza!). Special propers to the friendly sommelier, who recommended an excellent Fruilian red (we didn't know such a thing existed). Looking forward to the next visit.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- You Can Feel Good About Eating This Inception Doughnut Because It’s Vegan
- Roberta’s Set to Take ‘Significant’ Investment From Tisch Family Member
- Watching a Machine From the 1800s Make Candy Is a Surprisingly Satisfying Way to End the Week
- NYC Can Start Fining Restaurants for Salt-Label Violations
- Broadway’s Megan Hilty Eats Her First Proper Dinner at Sardi’s