All Reader Reviews of...
230 Ninth Ave., New York, NY, 10001
at 24th St.
I have no idea what the others reviewers are talking about!
By across on 5/31/2009
I live within a block of Co. and go there to eat at least twice a week, alone to grab a bite or with friends. Co. has the best bread in the city and more interesting and delicious offerings than any average pizza place I know. The Straticella is addictive and the Birds Nest (with truffles) particularly good. The salads are light and lovely. Everything is portioned for individuals or to share with two, so it's a question of quality over quantity. The wait staff have been unfailingly nice to me every time I've been there. My neighbor just went for her birthday and had a wonderful experience too. The negative reviews on this thread are baffling to me.
Great pizza deserves better wine!
By chr on 6/8/2009
The pizza here is outstanding -if you are a gourmet pizza enthusiast, this is well worth trying. The dough is amazing and the toppings are first quality. As good or better than in Italy! However, the wine list is terrible. Only screw top bottles and very few from Italy. Not that I have anything against screw top bottles, in fact they are very practical, but the wine choices are too limited. Both times we have gone to Co., our delicious pizza was negated by the mediocre wines by the glass (and it is a good thing we didn't buy an entire bottle). Even spoke to the manager about the poor wine list, to no avail. Oh well - but the pizza is truly outstanding.
Not your classic NY pizza
By foodieQ on 6/24/2009
The moment you bite into the pie, you'll notice that it's not your classic NY pizza. The crunchy yet chewy crust is enhanced with just enough amount of creative flavorful toppings. If you are looking for a crust with good backbone, your search is over. A great place to go with 4 or more people and try all pies on the menu.
best pizza in New York
By angienyc on 6/25/2009
Co. is by no means the best pizza in Manhattan today. i was born and raised in italy and believe me, the quality of Co. pizza is above average even by italian standards: the ingredients used are very fresh, the menu is incredibly interesting, for example the Stracciatella with very fresh stracciatella (a derivative of buffalo mozzarella only freshly available in some regions in the South of Italy), Popey with truffle and fresh spinach, Boscaiola...we tried seven different and they were all amazing. who doesnt like the pizza here is because got his/her palate ruined by fake pizza over the years! beside the food which is an A+, the place is loud, not children friendly and the waiting list is always too long. but its worth the wait!
Go to Co...
By skipmd on 1/1/2010
Having been to Di Fara, Keste and Motorino this is my #1 pizza in NYC, light flavorful but charred crusts, with the right chew, perfectly balanced between the sauce and the unique combination of toppings.
Get the Stracciatella!
By TravelingGirl on 3/10/2010
I don't know how they do it, but every time I go there the Stracciatella gets better. They have some great pies that they have all the time and constantly rotate in creative specials. The drink menu is a bit lacking and the family seating may come as a surprise if you're not expecting it, but overall a great addition to Chelsea. I've been here many times and plan to keep coming back. I have yet to try something I didn't like, let alone LOVE!
Bland and overpriced
By bartszyszka on 6/30/2010
My boyfriend and I asked the waiter how big the pies are and he very sternly said these are *individual* pies as in "I don't want you to share." While most places with individual pies tend to make them sound less sharable than they really are, this turned out to be a flat out lie at Co. We got two huge pizzas. The pizza itself was just OK. By the end of the meal it felt like I ate a lot of good bread. I was full, but not with a lot of flavors (and we started with a red cabbage / mushroom salad doused with balsamic vinegar). The ingredients were sparse and needed some salt (and this is coming from someone who loves bread and never adds extra salt to his food). Service was quick, but felt like a chain restaurant in Times Square with the servers eager for their 20% tips on overpriced food.
Early Reviews are bogus
By arose03 on 12/18/2010
Either this place got its act together late, which is possible, or the early reviews were from competitors disguised as readers. This place is a 10 all around. And uh pigiron, when you said on 4/8/2009 that they would be out of business in three months, did you mean they would still be packed every night almost 2 years later? I went for the first time last week with friends and literally went back the next night with my wife. Can't say "best" pizza in NY because there are so many classics that are great but this is for my money the most original and certainly delicious.
By FoodLoverAlways on 4/4/2011
Pizza is great but the hostess is nasty and condescending (like the caricatures of a stuck-up hostess on Sex and the City).
Terrible Service, Decent Food
By ClaireJ on 9/29/2011
Have been going to Co. for years, consider it to one of my neighborhood favorites, but on a most recent visit found the service to be down right awful. Our server was rude, inattentive and clearly did not care about our dining experience. Food was decent but not what it used to be.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Silicon Valley Start-Up Working to Create a World Where All Pizza Is Cooked by Robots
- Japanese Chain Debuts Predictably Bonkers Ghostbusters Burgers
- Brooklyn’s Take Root Will Host Its First Designer Pop-up This Weekend
- The Stonewall Inn Is Now a National Monument
- IHOP Staffers Turned Their Entire Restaurant Into an All-out Brawl