All Reader Reviews of...
43 E. 19th St., New York, NY, 10003
nr. Park Ave. South
Craft is the A-Rod of Restaurants
By nativenewyorker23 on 7/21/2013
Been here many times. Food and service were spot-on each time. And then tonight happened. Quality of service has evaporated. This place exists on Tom's name now but there is nothing to back it up. I am not going into the details. Trust me that Craft has fallen off. I won't be returning. There are many other places in NYC that are at the top of their game. Craft is most certainly not. It is like a professional baseball player trying to remain in the bigs for a few years longer than is prudent. Craft is the A-Rod of restaurants. I was embarrassed for making my family endure this crappy experience.
A simply unforgettable night at Craft
By gdirector on 9/8/2011
I went to Craft on Tuesday (incidentally the same night their new NY Times review came out) as part of a NY Supper Club event (www.tnysc.com). We experienced their tasting menu and it was just 3 hours of true eating pleasure. The first course was a specially made lobster dish made exclusively for our group and it was unbelievably tender and delicious with preserved lemon and fennel. The rest of the menu was incredible as well. The farm egg, which was slow poached, came with soppressata and sweetbreads and was incredibly tasty with the contrast of the soft egg and crispy meat. I wasn't surprised that The Times gave Craft 3 stars because the experience was absolutely top notch...perhaps they've raised their game again. Lastly, it made the night go over the top when we noticed Tom Colicchio hanging out at the bar and he was kind enough to sign a few menus and shake a few hands.
Craft lives up to my expectations!
By Mercy on 8/31/2010
Can't rave enough about the service, quality of food, and overall experience at Craft. My girlfriend's and I celebrated a birthday there one Monday evening. The staff, and there were plenty of them, were personable and efficient. Braised short ribs, monkfish, and scallops were all a hit at the table! As were the sides: baby carrots, polenta, heirloom tomato salad....the German potatoes were slightly over done, but good nonetheless. Try the sugar and spice donuts and even the coffee was exceptional! A lovely experience in a nicely run restaurant, worth every penny of the pricey tab!
Disappointing: Tom Colicchio - was he ever a good chef?
By JandE on 7/3/2010
We were very disappointed with the food. Our meals were bland, in some cases undercooked; it was by far our worst dining experience in nyc. The service was also terrible (our waiter could not recommend wine pairings, or even which side to pair with a main, etc.). Perhaps this was once a good restaurant, but it seems the only thing to recommend it now is the hype around Colicchio and Top Chef - not the food. We think Colicchio should revisit Craft - his criticism is needed at his restaurant far more than it is on TV. (If you are looking for a fresh, simple, yet sophisticated dining experience, we suggest going to blue hill at stone barns.)
It's just ok
By foodismylife84 on 12/23/2009
As always a lot of hype from a celebrity chef restaurant, I've ate here several times always with a problem. Cold food, bad service, etc..... Can't wait to see how the new restaurant does.....
By Jstlookather on 6/3/2009
Another restaurant we tried in NY & only because of the Chef. It was a wonderful dinner but nothing over the top. Although, we enjoyed it there are much better restaurants out there in NYC.
Table for 4?
By matthewf on 4/12/2009
I had called for a 6pm reservation for 4 people on a Tuesday night. I was told all they had was a table for 2. I had seen Top Chef(I know, sad) and thought well maybe its just that good so I wanted to try it. We walked into an empty restaurant and were seated at a table for 4. Odd, I thought there was only room for 2. Whatever. We decided that we'd order the tasting menu as this to me is the Chef's best food forward. Lets just say i think Tom C. needs to head back to the kitchen and take some of his own advice. The entire meal was uninspired. That said, the wine list was wonderful. Wont be going back anytime soon.
dear chef tom, i'm disappointed
By missoverrated on 3/12/2009
I went to craft with my boyfriend yesterday night. He and I both love top chef and were exciting to see what Tom was made of. PRO: The inside of the restaurant was a pleasure: classy without being pretentious, nice music, sofa chairs, nice bathroom and overall comfortable and trendy. My main course scallops with side of shitake mushrooms were amazing! My boyfriend's short ribs were nicely cooked. We got chocochip muffin treats on our way out. CONS: The hostess (there were three. why? i don't know.) They were quite disorganized. In this case, three was not the magic number. The first course we got the crispy bacon and arugula with lemon salad. Do not get the salad. It was extremely salty, so much so that you can physically see the salt on each arugula. The bacon was one word: interesting. It wasn't bad but it sure wasn't good. I still can't figure it out. I thought it was suppose to be crispy but it kept sticking onto our teeth, making it hard to chew. We also got the side of sauteed bokchoy which was too tangy and blah.
By angryserver on 2/12/2009
Very simple food American food w/ French techniques, i dont recommend the tasting menu just because you can create your own menu specially if you r dinning w/ 3 or more people its a better value, the steaks r amazing, service not bad at all but its a little overprice simple tasting food is not that expensive, but overall is a great meal overrated but good, drinks are not that great but they have a very nice wine list
Quite disappointing: terrible service trumps very good food
By floyd30 on 1/14/2009
The food was really, really good. It lived up to my expectations, which were high to begin with. Too bad the whole experience was overshadowed by how surprisingly poorly we were treated there. First we waited nearly an hour to be seated, although we arrived right on time for a reservation I had confirmed earlier in the day. The rest of the meal followed suit. The waiter was totally inattentive and the food took forever -- though it was good, it was clear that it had been sitting around a while before it made it to our table. There are many NY restaurants are just as good or better and actually treat you WELL. Which is what one should expect from a restaurant where you're paying $300-400 for dinner for two! Self-respecting diners, look elsewhere.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Pizzeria Debuts Trump Pizza, Sliced Small for People With Tiny Fingers
- Donald Trump Celebrates Cinco de Mayo With ‘the Best Taco Bowls’
- New York Times Getting Into the Business of Delivering Food to People’s Homes
- The Metrograph Movie House Serves Steak Tartare at Its Commissary
- Jewish Leader Accuses Michelin of Being Anti-Semitic