All Reader Reviews of...
260 Sixth Ave., New York, NY, 10014
nr. Bleecker St.
You should experience it...only once
By NYCGirl219 on 2/17/2005
I can't complain about the food and service...both were excellent when I dined there. You know what the problem is with this place? It is overhyped...If you were to look at overall cost/quality of food and atmosphere it's really apparent that you can find better Italian food in NYC. This place is for bragging rights only...don't expect to be super impressed!
Tired and overrated!
By annahinnyc on 12/25/2004
Don't waste your time trying to spot celebrities at this much over-hyped Village Italian. The food came 1hr15min after we ordered. Service is deplorable. The veal wasn't cooked properly and when we asked to send it back to the kitchen, the waiter started to argue with us about it. Save your money for another Italian. There are too many good ones to bother with Da Silvano's nonsense.
Food is Mediocre at Best...
By Brandes on 10/18/2004
...and you can forget about the wine list. The steamed mussels appetizer came out 2 minutes after we ordered it (can you say "not fresh?"). The osso bucco was tender, but rather bland. It was not on top of rissotto - it was RICE. The lobster gnocchi was fishy. The wine list was small and WAY overpriced and very limited. Cross this one off of your list - it's nowhere near the hype it gets. Go to Lupa instead.
Great scene... Great food
By wierzbao on 11/3/2003
The opposite of what I expected: service is great and waiters are very helfpul and don't push for the appetizer/primi/secondi Food is very good: the specials are very fresh and reminds me of Italy. The scene is great as well! If you can afford it, one of the best trattoria in NY!
I'll pass on this one...
By jlockemy on 10/19/2003
The food was good. Waiter was slow, and unattentive. Two of us ordered iced tea, which came in a wine glass (with ice, about two sips). We were charged $14.00 for four glasses of iced tea. It wasn't even fresh brewed. Ridiculous.
The Shrimp Nazi
By kwolford on 10/19/2003
I ordered the grilled prawns for lunch, and when they arrived, the stench was so overpowering it nearly knocked me out. The people at the table next to us were commenting on how surprised they were I would even be willing to try one bite. After one taste it was inedible- the smell was so fishy and offensive that the odor hung in the air. I discreetly explained to the server (who had the personality of a wet mop) that I was unable to eat them because of the smell and he wordlessly marched off in a huff with my plate. Two minutes later, a man arrived at our table with the offending prawns in hand, informed me loudly that there was nothing wrong with the prawns (he tasted them, he pointed out) and that I would still have to pay for them and disappeared immediately without even identifying himself or giving me a chance to speak. When the bill arrived, I asked to see the manager. The same combative man appeared back at the table and again argued with me and told me I had to pay for the meal even though I'd had no lunch.
Da Silvano Bon Apetit!!
By Princiss on 8/18/2003
Excellent restaurant. Great service. Nice waiters. Great food!! Bon Apetit
Food was delicious
By rachel_gerber on 6/30/2003
My boyfriend and I love italian restaurants, we enjoyed the food at Da Silvano, as well as the service. We sat outside which was very nice, and didn't have a problem finding parking. I would recommend this restaurant and definately will go back to eat there again
Celebrity gazing outdoes the food
By zeecee on 3/30/2003
For some reason this restaurant started to attract celebrities, who probably come for the antipasto platters and perhaps to run into other celebrities. It's not cheap and the food isn't as good as other comparably priced restaurants. Dinner might be in the $60 range. Like most downtown restaurants, it's casual and I'd recommend it if you have out of town guests who like to star-gaze.
Get What You Pay For
By jsaf237 on 3/19/2003
The fuscilli with the spicy sausage and peas in a mildly creamy sauce was delicious. The braised Osso Bucco and my wife's white, flaky fish was one of the best entrees i've had since i raved about Fiamma. Absolutley delcious. Sitting outside in 40 degree weather with the heat lamps warming our backs and the wine and food warming our stomachs, mad for a pleasant dinner. Thus, you gotta expect that the bill would be ;arge- and it was. Once in a while, it's worth ckecking out superior Italian in a city that's filled with above avg Italian.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Scientists â€‹Pretty Sure Humans Could Eat Food Grown in Martian Soil
- Another Restaurant Bites the Dust on Clinton Street
- A Talented Pastry Chef Will Open a New Bakery in the Rockaways
- This 3-D Food Printer Actually Makes Pizza So You Don’t Have To
- Bergen Hill Relocates to Noho With a Seafood-Heavy Menu