All Reader Reviews of...
23 Grand St., New York, NY, 10013
at Sixth Ave.
Decent food; terrible service -- I will never return to any David Burke restaurant
By flyingtaco on 6/15/2012
I dined at David Burke with 3 friends in April 2012. The food was pretty good, but the service was terrible. A waitress accidentally spilled red wine all over a brand new leather purse instantly ruining it. Despite the manager's promises to restore it to its original pristine condition or reimburse me for it, David Burke refuses to pay for the loss (and, they never returned the bag!) They do not return phone calls or emails and have done their best to push me off with the hope that I will get frustrated and give up. In addition, they only reduced the bill by $18 -- the price of a cheeseburger (which I had to beg for b/c they accidentally brought me the wrong menu listing the burger. The burger was being served in the bar upstairs.) Let's just say that $18 was a very small percentage of the total bill. Needless to say, after the way I have been treated, my friends, family and I will never dine at a David Burke establishment again. I would not expect such a poor level of service from a high quality established brand such as this. Food quality is clearly important, but so is the full customer experience. Just remember that if you choose to dine at David Burke Kitchen, the corporate mantra appears to be that the customer is unimportant.
i really liked this place!
By barbi on 11/28/2011
i met my sister and brother-in-law there for dinner tonite, who were in from out of town..i had never heard of this place..but my sister had been told good things about it from a friend of hers..so we went there and i must say i REALLY LIKED it..the service was excellent [friendly and attentive..i WISH i knew the waiter's name] and what we ordered was great..my sister and i had the wedge to start..and she had the sea bass..which she loved..and my brother-in-law and myself each had the rib steak..which was DELISH!!!.. i would DEFINATELY go there again!!!
By brewstream on 9/6/2011
Went for breakfast on a Sunday. Not very busy yet the staff struggled to care for their customers. Instead, they talked among themselves. Food was what you'd expect from a midtown diner -- poor.
Will NEVER go back!!!!!
By teledo1 on 7/25/2011
Given the reviews of this place, we felt like we visited a wrong restaurant. Just went there on Saturday, one of the hotter days, July 23, 2011. Had reservations for a group prior to. The restaurant had no AC working!!!!! They failed to notify the people who made reservations ahead of time about this "inconvenience" even though had trouble with it for days. What is even worse is that not once did they apologize for the fact that AC was not working. Not even a complimentary cold soda was offered, forget appetizer or coffee. None of the servers knew the menu well enough to explain it before the orders were made. They failed to inform us that the porterhouse steak special on the menu has.... finished. The waiters were very unprofessional taking the food away before everyone on the table had a chance to taste it. We literally had to scream at one to leave the food alone. Oh yes, and they also ran out of skim milk...and forgot to notify the guest who ordered it. Very Very disappointing experience!!!! Will never come back and will not recommend to anyone! There are tons of high end restaurants in the city that would have handled this situation in a gratifying professional manner. And oh yes, the manager himself, never came out... even though we asked for him.
By Nicholaskk on 7/3/2011
We love this guy. We have visited his restaurants many times. Kitchen was fantastic. Davis Burke was actually there. The decor is pretty cool but the food was incredible. Everything from the inventive drinks to the bone marrow appetizer to the lamb and then to the do it yourself donuts was absolutely amazing. Also, the staff was perfect. Knowledgeable and personable. We can't wait to go back and we recommend it to all of our friends.
Great service, great food
By gossiplibbles on 3/24/2011
The food was delicious and the service very attentive. At first I thought the decor might be a little too stark and cold from the pictures I had seen, but it was actually very bright and welcoming. Definitely go before getting a res. becomes impossible.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Congress Introduced a Bill to Keep Journalists From Snooping Around Big Food
- A Farming Cartoonist Was Fired for Joking About Big Agriculture
- Why This Leading London Chef Feels Energized by New York Kitchens
- Oxford Student Refuses to Tip Server Because She’s White
- Girl Finds Razor Blade in Her Soda at Wendy’s