All Reader Reviews of...
226 W. 23rd St., New York, NY, 10011
nr. Seventh Ave.
Absolutely Great !!!
By Scorp1956 on 12/28/2014
I always talked about this place to my daughter. Her father and I used to go there with our friends years ago. My daughter and I recently had dinner there. The food and service was great...as always. The breast of chicken and fried shrimp were absolutely delicious. The amount of food is amazing. Also, you won't believe how reasonable it is. You have to visit. You won't be sorry.
By mfareri on 10/21/2011
This has been a favorite of mine since the 90s. Recently read Patty Smith's "Just Kids" and was reminded of just how awesome this place is. Think late 60s Joplin, Mapplethorpe, and Blondie sipping sangria at the bar or having paella at a table. It is a well preserved time machine that holds its ground. Always a new favorite of any guest I take for a visit. Portions are huge. Really. Think 1 plate for 2 people. Bean soup is amazing.
Tasty AND Plenty!
By GirlPlease on 11/9/2009
I've known THIS place for over 25 years and will return AGAIN tomorrow Tues. 11/10 for lunch. Many a XMAS/New Year Eves have been spent here. The Lobster in Garlic Sauce is MY favorite-So Plentyiful and Absolutely Delicious. And of course, EVERYONE has a slightly Off day, even in MY Own kitchen-just tell your waiter and it WILL be corrected promptly and Without question. Yes, the Decor is 'Old World' Cheesy, YES it is Charmingly Tacky but that can be overlooked-the FOOD and SERVICE more then Compensates for 'The Look'. Lobster, Clams and Sangria-Here I come, AGAIN!
It's all about the lobster...
By sweetclafoutis on 8/28/2009
I disagree with the reviewer who said the crowd was all tourists. I'm a native New Yorker and I love El Quijote. My whole family loves it. Sure, the decor is cheesy and old; that's part of its charm. It's like taking a step back in time. Service is friendly and efficient. I've been going with my parents, and now my husband, for years. When my sisters visit from California, a family dinner at El Quijote is a must. Here's the trick: Forget paella. Order a 3-pound lobster, broiled: split in half, topped with breadcrumbs and butter. Make sure you eat the delicious green stuff (tomalley). Begin with the white bean and ham soup instead of salad (it's a bit salty, but delicious), then housemade potato chips on the side and an order of steamed broccoli. They have lobsters in many sizes, so you can go smaller or larger, but to me 3 pounds is perfect (I bring the claws home to make lobster salad the next day). You can also have your lobster boiled if that's your preference. Give me the buttery breadcrumbs every time...
Could be anywhere, USA
By ellen5181 on 8/10/2008
Sangria was very good (we had the red). Plenty of food and almost worth considering the sharing charge for 1 main course to be split. I had the paella with lobster and have enough food for another full meal. My friend had the 2 lobsters and it was just that. Had the white bean soup to start that was tasty but a little salty. The homemade potato chips are pretty good. Then again, the paella was salty, and I found myself thirsty most of the night. If you are looking for some place that has a NY feel to it, this isn't it. You could be in any Spanish themed restaurant anywhere. Even looking at the clientele, these weren't New Yorkers but rather tourists or suburbanites making their once a year trip into NYC. I think it is about time they updated the decor to something more modern.
Unbelievable portion size and good quality
By littleprince1977 on 5/23/2007
Everything tasted wonderful. Paella? One order is enough for two-three people. My grilled veal chops (normal, not thick ones) were 3/4 in. THICK. I wish the waiter had told us how much food we were actually ordering. Environment was Full of energy and people...NOT a "quiet, low-light, intimate" place for lovers...GREAT for groups. Order 1/2 of what you think you want and you'll have enough food for two meals. Great place to spend a long time for an extended dinner....Go EARLY (5-6pm) on Saturday or else you won't be able to get a table without an extended wait.
Very dissapointed in El Quijote
By Roxxybfh on 10/13/2005
First of all, after all the hype of the amazing Paella I was extremely dissapointed. It swims in this tasteless water and the sea food was as rubbery as plastic. I could tell immediately from the flashy orange color of the lobster. The service was one of the worst i have ever experienced in this city. Rude and disrespectful servers treated us very badly. I would never go back and I hope you dont either. Oh, the sangria was ok!
Make a reservation - but go!
By msNico on 1/28/2003
I have always loved this place... It's not the cheapest place, but four people ate well, drank hearty for under $200 - which included a couple of Pitchers of Sangria (famous) and lobster for all! We split two Paella and had tons left over. It was crowded... We had to wait... But the food came relatively quickly and the characters are perfect for people watchers and making merry!
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Scientists â€‹Pretty Sure Humans Could Eat Food Grown in Martian Soil
- Another Restaurant Bites the Dust on Clinton Street
- A Talented Pastry Chef Will Open a New Bakery in the Rockaways
- This 3-D Food Printer Actually Makes Pizza So You Don’t Have To
- Bergen Hill Relocates to Noho With a Seafood-Heavy Menu