- READER REVIEWS
All Reader Reviews of...
142 W. 65th St., New York, NY, 10023
Eat here before a show at your peril!
By cltaylor22 on 7/19/2015
This might have been one of the worst dining experiences we have had since we arrived in new york three years ago. We arrived at Lincoln Restaurante with about an hour and a quarter to spare before a matinee, we told the waitress we wanted to be out about 10-15 minutes before the performance started. She said this was no problem at all - of course this is exactly what the restaurant is used to dealing with - or so you would expect. I have no idea what went wrong with our order but we waited for an age to get our first course (we had the set two course menu). With only minutes to spare and still waiting for our second course we were incredibly nervous about missing our show so I suggested we come back at five and eat then so that we could actually enjoy the food. The manager was pushy about us eating immediately as the dishes were being plated up. We had a minute or two to gulp down our meals but my husband's was too hot to eat properly so he had to leave half of it, we got to the theater with no time to spare to even visit the bathroom, not a pleasant experience at all! I have to say that in terms of our food we both enjoyed our starters but we paid a supplement of $15 so I could have the black truffle pasta as my main course and it was utterly tasteless, I'm sure the truffle wasn't fresh enough, something the kitchen should be checking. In short I wouldn't recommend the food and I certainly would avoid this restaurant like the plague if you are going to the theater.
I agree with NY Mag reviewer: Overpriced
By nikitwocheese on 2/20/2012
We should have suspected something right away when we easily scored a same-day reservation on a Sunday. I think we paid $12 for a large bowl of decent brussels sprouts with a sprinkling of pancetta. They would've been much better had they been sauteed *with* the pancetta. The verdi bolognese pasta my husband ordered was fine---loved the curly homemade pasta---but not amazing like the price suggested. My entree of two nicely seared scallops on lentils was the best thing we ordered, but again, not amazing. The blood sausage hockey puck sitting next to the scallops didn't add much and was chewy. Apple tart dessert reminded me of a breakfast bar you'd buy at a supermarket. The good news is that our waitress (seemed to be in her high 40s) was knowledgeable and professional. We spent the most we've ever spent on dinner for us two, but sadly it was not worth it and we won't be back.
By ArleneAcquavvella on 9/30/2011
My husband and I just spent the most wonderful evening at Lincoln it was everthing and more than we expected. It was elegant in decor, excellent in service, and the staff was extremely knowledgable of the menu. The Procecco Bar was delightful. The food was excellent and as we left we were already planning when to go back. Arlene & Joseph Acquavella
Worth Every Penny
By oscarjgarza on 12/13/2010
After seeing this gorgeous restaurant and reading up about it, I was very apprehensive about my reservations. From the chili-flake reed-thin breadsticks to the finishing moscato, I was not at all disappointed and in fact highly impressed. It seems the ship has been righted with superb service, providing a meal that was perfect from beginning to end and basically no bumps in the middle. I went for a romantic, celebratory dinner but will gladly find any excuse to return again and again!
By LadyLou on 12/5/2010
If you are looking for a new place with the promise of fine food - don't come to Lincoln. Maybe they are still in training, but the staff were the most inexperienced, nervous and clumsy waitstaff I have seen in some time - definitely B-Team Sunday. The food is also poorly conceived - a set three course meal that calls itself brunch where you are given the choice of a tiny bowl of fairly average pasta or a frittata the size of a small planet that could easily feed 8. The above was recoverable, but then there was the water spilled in the bowl of pasta which they were not intending to correct until we said they should do so. Unfortunately the 'fix' was to remove what was left, put it in on a cold plate with no addition of heat or sauce and return it. I would expect this from a neighborhood dinner not an upscale restaurant. Lincoln would surely be turning in his grave.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Scientists â€‹Pretty Sure Humans Could Eat Food Grown in Martian Soil
- Another Restaurant Bites the Dust on Clinton Street
- A Talented Pastry Chef Will Open a New Bakery in the Rockaways
- This 3-D Food Printer Actually Makes Pizza So You Don’t Have To
- Bergen Hill Relocates to Noho With a Seafood-Heavy Menu