All Reader Reviews of...
89 E. 42nd St., lower level, New York, NY, 10017
at Vanderbilt Ave.
Worst experience ever
By Coachian on 11/19/2008
I was visiting New York and decided to dine at the oyster bar for my 50th birthday, what a terrible mistake. The service was appalling the waiter was a miserable jerk, the food was less than second rate and they gave my wife the wrong dish. They were unable to get it right so I complained and asked for the bill. I was given no less than three separate bills before they could get that right and was overcharged on each of them. I refused to tip the pathetic waiter and was made to feel like I was breaking the law. Without any doubt the VERY WORST restaurant experience I have had anywhere in the world. In one word Atrocious, DO NOT GO THERE!
Worst experience in New York
By HalNic on 9/11/2009
Canteen quality, horrible service, nonsense prices. Waste of money and time!
By lc11231 on 2/15/2010
Half our party got severe food poisoning from eating the oysters. The lobster bisque and clam chowder were inedible. Do not go here. Overrated, overpriced, unsafe and generally disgusting.
Terrible Service, Dissappointing Meal
By echung0 on 5/20/2012
I had high hopes for this restaurant. Despite the oysters, the food was either bland or dry. The rice that came with the red snapper tasted like the rice airlines serve during a flight. I'm not exaggerating, it was rubbery and dry. The fish dishes all seemed overcooked. The one heartbreaking piece of the meal was the new england clam chowder, which at a supposedly top seafood restaurant, wouldnt be overly salty and lukewarm. I had dreams that were dashed when I thought this could be a place I could regularly go to for a good bowl of chowder. However, I think there is a reason for the food being lukewarm. The service was slow. And when we needed someone to get pick up our check, no one would come. In fact, one waiter briefly looked at us waiving our hands and then went on to serve another table without even acknowledging our presence or even helping us find our waiter. So, my boyfriend had to get up and hand the check over to that waitier who dismissively told us to go up to the hosts' desk. And, the host had tried to charge us the 18% gratuity tip. Luckily we told him we were actually under the minimum party of 6. I do not recommend this place. It has nice historic value. But you would be better off going to city island in the Bronx for seafood, which is closer to the fish market that had been relocated from downtown Manhattan anyway.
Horrible service in my life
By myskylab on 5/11/2009
I would say that visiting this oyster bar was one of the most horrible expericence in my life. I read the other reviews, and apparently, My friends and I are not the only people who are appalled by their horrible service. After asking two or three questions on their menu, my friend told our server that we need more time to decide the order, and the server literally told my friend 'Don't make her to come to the table twice to get your order because she is busy person'. After that, the service got worse and went to the worst-Snaching our plate that we are still eating, and the server kept insisting she did nothing wrong....horrible, horrible! Food? It was not bad but not good either. Would I go back to this restaurant? Hell, NO. Why would I? There are so many good restaurants out there that have awesome food and are friendly at the same time, so why would I waste my money and time here?
Shuck it...could ya?
By hey_hon on 9/29/2003
OK, you are THE OYSTER BAR - shuck the oyster all the way, prying it open is only half the job, I HATE digging attached oyster off the shell, it ruins the appeal! The oysters are tasty enough but small - even when 3 X-Large Malpeques were ordered, 2 were not X-Large and one was. They are also incredibly expensive but then again this is a tourist trap. A bowl of steamers were topped with minced onions too bitter to consume. The server at the raw bar never said 2 words and banged everything we ordered on the counter. Nice.
Fallen landmark, now second-rate tourist trap
By FL123 on 7/9/2012
Took my son for his 24th birthday and he noticed that this NYC landmark had a kitchen so evidently dirty it only scored a B on its Health Dept. inspection. The banquette section where was sat was fine but w/virtually no A/C. I don't believe an underground restaurant in a modern city should let patrons sweat through their shirts because of inadequate A/C or lack of a fan if they knew A/C was spotty. I became ill afterward, possibly from heat exhaustion walking outside later on a sweltering evening, but perhaps partly because of 3 raw clams I ill-advisedly (given the B rating) ate. Finally the waiter deliberately padded our bill with an extra appetizer and a 3rd drink when we had 2. He didn't blink or even LOOK at the bill or ask any question; he knew we'd caught him. As we were leaving, I noticed one or two diners wearing basketball tank tops. I'm not advocating, by any means, a return to the days when one was turned away for not having a jacket (as recently as the mid-1980s, which was hardly a time of "Mad Men" suit-and-tie attire). But tank tops in a purportedly fine-dining restaurant with $30+ entrees? Or is it no longer that? The only other kind of restaurant with those types of prices who welcome tank tops is "tourist trap" -- which the once-great now second-rate Oyster Bar has become.
We walked out
By bookseller on 11/29/2012
The restaurant was so noisy that it was almost physically unpleasant. My friend and I decided to leave, but after waiting close to 15 minutes for a waiter to come and ask if we wanted to order, we just put some cash on the table and walked out. THAT's when a waiter got interested in us. I used to love this place, but I don't think I'll be back.
classic but not always worth it
By melissafield on 5/11/2005
I loved this place... eating the raw oysters and pan roasts. Then I brought some out of town guests and had a surprisingly dissappointing experience. There is no kids menu. We ordered fish and chips for the kids at 18$ we expected a great dish but were disappointed, any pub would have given us the same dish for half the price. The smoked fish (salmon, trout and sturgeon) plate is under "main dishes" but comes with nothing more than a couple thin slices of bland smoked fish. No accompanying salad, side veg.. nothing, and for 23$! We were waited on by 5 different people and no one came to our table to ask how the food was after we were served. The creamed spinach was heavily over spiced with nutmeg, all at the table agreed. It's a classic place, but I'd stick to a couple raw oysters and a panroast, spend the rest of your money somewhere else.
Terrible service and SLOW!
By Nicole673 on 9/13/2009
Took 4 out of town guests here last night. Arrived at 7:15 and by 8pm we didn't even have our appetizers. Our waiter was so rude. He would walk away while we were trying to order and go attend to another table. After we finally got our apps, he came back with a LONG printed listed of all the things they were out of. It was about half their menu (no lobsters, broiled scallops, grouper, sole, trout, bass, etc.). The waiter then said "well you know we are closed tomorrow so it is the end of our week". I'm sorry but isn't this Saturday night in Manhattan? We spoke to a manager mid-meal to try and sort out the slow service and how they mixed up about everything we ordered. Although he talked to us, nothing was offered in the way compensation. Also, they tacked on an automatic grat of 18% and there were only 5 of us. The only good thing I can say is my food tasted good, but I thought it was expensive for what I got.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- NYC Can Start Fining Restaurants for Salt-Label Violations
- Broadway’s Megan Hilty Eats Her First Proper Dinner at Sardi’s
- Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Dizengoff, Olmsted, GÃ¼nter Seeger, and More
- A Trailblazing Chef Arrives in NYC With This Ambitious New Restaurant
- Sauvage, From the Maison Premiere Team, Debuts in Greenpoint