All Reader Reviews of...
89 E. 42nd St., lower level, New York, NY, 10017
at Vanderbilt Ave.
It's a Classic. It's also Loud.
By amsterdam9 on 12/4/2002
It's an institution and the oysters, other seafood dishes, and wine list -- the menu is huge -- make it a worthy one. If you can handle the noise, grab a table and soak up the atmosphere.
By PIXEE22 on 1/8/2003
The service was great! And our server did not make us feel like idiots when we asked about the vast oyster selection. Definitely a spot to simply enjoy a variety of oysters and a cocktail. Lots of non-oyster options too!
By Poptarts on 2/18/2003
Hadn't been to the Oyster Bar in many years and had fond memories so when friends from CT were meeting us we decided it would be convenient and fun to go back. We were all terribly disappointed with the dispassionate service and mediocre food. Sole and salmon were overcooked and tasteless and mussels gave one of us a bad night. Value was no way commensurate with cost. Would never ever go back.
By marieviljoen on 4/10/2003
Eat the oysters. Lots of them. The house-smoked tenderloin of salmon on the deep blue plate with the black bread is remarkably fine. Sit at the bar and watch the oystermen work. They are grumpy and unfazed by whoever you are and if they smile at you your whole day flips over and grins. Try the clam chowder, but you may be sorry. The fish, in general, is OK, but not at those prices. The bouillabaisse is a disgrace. It's great place to bring a tourist-friend, a crew of friends, or to sit in quite alone - because there is so much to watch. The wine list is extensive, over-priced, and pretty good. If you eat wisely you leave happy, and aware that you live in New Yawk.
GO FISHING IN GRAND CENTRAL
By adsong on 5/29/2003
Touted as one of the more famous seafood places in New York, This large,indeed cavernous restaurant with its vaulted ceilings, has withstood the test of time(Except of a couple of years, when it closed due to a fire) with its very,very large menu (One page...but its a BIG One page) with daily specials, and a vast listing of wines. Sit at the bar, or at a table, and order their wonderful chowders,($4.50) or from their selections such as :Jumbo Gulf Shrimp Greek Salad - Served Chilled with Feta Cheese- $29.95 Grilled Ecuadorian Bigeye Tuna Steak - With Jalepeno Cilantro Cream - $24.95 Broiled Hawaiin Pompano Filet - With Chimichurri Sauce and Grilled Balsamic Summer Vegetables - $25.95 Saute'ed Imported Turbot Filet - With Plum Tomato and Herb Fondue, Black Truffles and Oil - $26.95 Maryland Crab Cakes with Baltimore Hot Sauce - $27.95 among the many choices (You can even order wonderful Florida Stone Crabs, when in season.) This place is not cheap, and it is a bit noisy due to its tiled decor,but this gives you a chance to whisper "Sweet Nothings" into your loved one's ears.The Oyster Bar MUST be experienced by New Yorker's as well as (Oh,No!!)Tourists as well.!!!
Shuck it...could ya?
By hey_hon on 9/29/2003
OK, you are THE OYSTER BAR - shuck the oyster all the way, prying it open is only half the job, I HATE digging attached oyster off the shell, it ruins the appeal! The oysters are tasty enough but small - even when 3 X-Large Malpeques were ordered, 2 were not X-Large and one was. They are also incredibly expensive but then again this is a tourist trap. A bowl of steamers were topped with minced onions too bitter to consume. The server at the raw bar never said 2 words and banged everything we ordered on the counter. Nice.
Grand Central Classic
By martin_chamois on 5/7/2005
Oyster Bar is a classic. After nearly 100 years in Grand Central it continues to shine bright. The seafood is classic American seafood. Not much has changed - all the better. Service is surprisingly good. The decor while not very modern fits the Grand Central environment and classic menu.
classic but not always worth it
By melissafield on 5/11/2005
I loved this place... eating the raw oysters and pan roasts. Then I brought some out of town guests and had a surprisingly dissappointing experience. There is no kids menu. We ordered fish and chips for the kids at 18$ we expected a great dish but were disappointed, any pub would have given us the same dish for half the price. The smoked fish (salmon, trout and sturgeon) plate is under "main dishes" but comes with nothing more than a couple thin slices of bland smoked fish. No accompanying salad, side veg.. nothing, and for 23$! We were waited on by 5 different people and no one came to our table to ask how the food was after we were served. The creamed spinach was heavily over spiced with nutmeg, all at the table agreed. It's a classic place, but I'd stick to a couple raw oysters and a panroast, spend the rest of your money somewhere else.
In two parts...
By LM600 on 1/12/2007
Whilst on my 3rd trip to NY, my wife and I decided to go here...Boy, what a mistake. Charlie our waiter was superb, very friendly and very professional. The rest weren't. I ordered 6 'fresh' oysters from the menu, what turned up were grey, sorry looking things with some sort of live worm attached, about 3/4" in length, with 'frills' running down each side and a four sided mouth...I know this because it was the only thing that moved when I squeezed the little bit of lemon on them. Charlie was busy, so I tried to catch the eye of another waiter, didn't work. After about 5 minutes I got up and asked for my starter to be removed and was met with abuse from two waiters...Charlie came over and sorted it. The combination pan roast turned up as some sort of stew, and by stew I mean tomato soup with a couple of watery (pre-frozen?) scallops, some (uncleaned?), gritty shellfish and some sad looking, overcooked shrimp (2 & small)
By LM600 on 1/12/2007
My wife faired better, her cooked oysters were 'OK' and her (also pre-frozen?) crab cakes were 'Alright...' Add to this, dirty floors, rammed in tables, a 'What the f*ck do you expect?' mentality and you won't be dissapointed. If like me, you'd seen pictures of this venerable restaurant growing up in England and wondering how good the food, service and memory will be then you will feel cheated, robbed, and a fool. To sum up, the place is a complete touist trap (although when we went there were a lot of business lunches going on), poor service apart from Charlie and a complete hole. $100 + tip, for tomato soup, and pre frozen 'food'. Look in, have a gawp at the tiling, maybe even go in and take it all in then leave and go somewhere else.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Silicon Valley Start-Up Working to Create a World Where All Pizza Is Cooked by Robots
- Japanese Chain Debuts Predictably Bonkers Ghostbusters Burgers
- Brooklyn’s Take Root Will Host Its First Designer Pop-up This Weekend
- The Stonewall Inn Is Now a National Monument
- IHOP Staffers Turned Their Entire Restaurant Into an All-out Brawl