All Reader Reviews of...
194 Elizabeth St., New York, NY, 10012
nr. Spring St.
Fantastic Experience 100%
By SkyeKinkaid on 7/2/2009
To be brief: my friend and I dined at Peasant last night and the food was delicious, the service was attentive, polite, well-executed, and notable, and the atmosphere was impressive. There is nothing not to love about Peasant. The meal itself was perfectly prepared (we had the rabbit) and the dessert (bread pudding) left my dinner companion at a loss for words with its divine texture, taste, and visual appeal. The waitress knew her wines and what to recommend to accompany the meal. I can think of few places in the city that can compete with the overall dining experience I had last night. Excellent restaurant worthy of praise.
A wonderful experience
By ecbinthecity on 9/18/2007
Peasant gave my boyfriend and I one of the best restaurant experiences we have had, and the place now has a special spot in my heart. Our restaurant choices always involve a homey, local venue, and Peasant definitely fit the bill. We went for an anniversary dinner after an amazing time at Blue Hill a week before...and it was just as good but in a different way. The wait staff is attentive, quirky, down to earth and friendly, the scene is warm and young, the wine is DELICIOUS, and the menu was perfectly Pugliese. I had the best frutti di mare there that I have ever tasted, better than my own--which I can basically prepare blindfolded because I make it so much. The whipped ricotta served with crusty tuscan bread was also a lovely nuance of the meal. Peasant nailed the concept of authentic, unpretentious Italian food in a romantic yet metropolitan environment. I highly recommend it to anyone.
One of the BEST so far in NY
By TheMilkman on 1/31/2007
So, as a self professed "foodie" I like to try out as many restaurants as I can afford. The first time I went to Peasant was on a date, and it was perfect. Nice wine list, dimly lit, and the food was delicious. Everything was salted and incredibly flavorful. Yes, it's expensive, but it is well worth it. I have made a point to mention Peasant every time one of my friends is looking to try something new. I have gone 5 times now, and am just waiting for a reason to go back. I have heard people complain about the wait, however if you go at a reasonable time, show up on time, and chill out at the bar for a minute, it's nothing at all. There is only a wait because this place is jamming, and has been full to the brim every time i have gone. Again, some of the BEST FOOD I have eaten in New York.
By natm41 on 10/15/2004
This meal was INCREDIBLE. On a Friday night when places fill up quickly (but on the later side), we called at 5:45, were able to get a table for 7:00, and it was absolutely WONDERFUL! The atmosphere was warm and candlelit with the open kitchen right in plain view. We immediately received delicious Italian bread with fresh ricotta, and our waitress was a dream--incredibly helpful, patient, and friendly. From the razor clams to the baby chicken to the papardelle with fresh porcini, this meal was a bacchanalian experience that I would be lucky to come back for.
Love this place
By Marchie2003 on 10/3/2003
The best osso buco I've had in a long time. The decor is wonderful, rustic and romantic. Great place for a date. Only problem is you might have to scream across the table just to hear each other. Noisy atmosphere, but if your looking for a great meal, you don't mind the noise. Hey, it's an authentic Italian restaurant, it's not supposed to be quite. Great meal, one of the best. I'd recomend to anyone.
perfection in the kitchen and service,...
By claude on 6/19/2003
this food is the best i have had in a long time , since my years growing up in tuscany,also the staff is so curtious and helpfull i cant say enough about them, a true restaurant that cares about its customers...
thanks chef it was amazing...
By mikey on 5/31/2003
this guy cooks like i would at home,,minus the great wood burning ovens he has to cook in.I mean all our food was amazing especially the bistecca and the gnocci, sooooooo good..your my idol chef.........
by far best italian around these parts...
By jeff on 5/31/2003
you really have to understand food and design to get this place, the food is outstanding , a little unusual with a authentic feel, and the design is strikingly minimal with old world charm..love it much...
yum yum yum
By sahmad1203 on 2/20/2011
DELICIOUS pasta w rabbit. if possible snag a table by the kitchen
Good food. Good wine. Good service
By america52 on 10/29/2010
The food is dynamic and interesting. The wine list is fantastic (especially the Pelago wine from Umani Ronchi - worth the 190 bucks) The server I had was great. Wine savvy and friendly. Great place for a date, clients or friends. Beautiful restaurant.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.