All Reader Reviews of...
10 Columbus Cir., 4th fl., New York, NY, 10019
at 60th St.
CHIC RESTAURANT YOU GET A LOT MORE THAN GOOD FOOD
By angielsullivan on 12/22/2012
I loved this restaurant and I hope to be lucky enough to get a table next time. We went there without reservations, they were kind enough to make space for us in the lounge, the restaurant was full. I loved everything including the lobster was delicious and the raviolis out of this world, and their customers, oh lala!
DO NOT take your foodie friends from Europe here . . .
By scottpsolomon on 7/19/2010
Don't get me wrong, I do like this restaurant. Key word: Like. But if you've got someone in town who has eaten the langoustines at L'Ambroisie and orders the langoustines here, you may experience a few condescending looks over the course of the evening. Just to reiterate, though, I DO like the place, and the room is spectacular.
One in a Million
By cmhygrell on 5/31/2010
Our dining experience at the fabulous Per Se is the best you can find in the city of New York. It is a bit price though our final check came to a total of around $5000 including wine.
By lute on 5/26/2010
We were sorely disappointed. Standard well-prepared hotel fare. Most of the food was conservative, except for novelties like lox and cream cheese in a little cone. It was like what you'd expect at a wedding. I guess so that you feel like you get your money's worth, they lavish you with B string sweets at the meal's end.
Per Se Restaurant
By buckyboot on 10/23/2009
I had lunch at Per Se and was seated 'front row' at a table overlooking Columbus Circle with a terrific view of Central Park. The decor was elegant and understated, but also a bit boring. The staff is amply manned, and was informed and helpful, and not intrusive. Score of 9 for service. For lunch I had the 5 course sampler, and while interesting, was actually a bit lacking in taste. An odor of cooking oil escaped from the Kitchen and soiled my clothes - like one might expect in a cheap 'greasy-spoon' restaurant - and the food has a slight taste of cooking oil as well. To me, this was the 'kiss of death.' The Kitchen should be equippped with better ventilation and the food prepared with better ingrediants. The food, while served in small portions, was heavy and sat in my tummy 5 hours after my meal. I had a fantastic glass of red wine (a bit pricey at $36.00, but worth it). All in all, I recommend Per Se to others for special events, but personally will not return.
Love the new Salon menu
By hgray01 on 10/17/2009
We had the pleasure of trying Per Se's new Salon Menu (ie: a la carte menu)-phenomenal! We had a lovely dining experience and yet still walked out for only $75/pp incl glass of wine, shared cheese platter appetizer, entree and tip. WOW, def take advantage of this incredible value! They throw in all kinds of little amuse bouches and other extras on the house as well. We were a bit awe struck! The lounge seating is spacious and comfortable. Definitely go! and Enjoy! An all-time favorite restaurant. We will be back... Someday for the full tasting menu!
By FatBastard on 4/5/2008
Our evening at Per Se ended with an impromptu tour of the kitchen where a definition of "finesse" hangs above the gateway to the dining room, and I think that sums up the experience perfectly. Execution was flawless from start to finish, and courses varied in excitement but never disappointed. We opted for a white and then a red wine rather than the frenzy of the pairing and found the sommelier's recommendations to match nicely. Unlike virtually every other ultra high-end restauranteur, I appreciate Keller's decision to wrap everything into the hefty $275 per head price tag rather than nickel-and-diming for sparkling water, coffee, and the like.
Not on par with the greatest chef
By wierzbao on 4/9/2007
I expected the magic that you can get when you go to Marc veryrat, Pierre Gagnaire or Alain Ducasse. What a disappointment. Some of dishes were great (the quail egg, the veal, the oyster with caviar). But the tasting menu is too heavy and too long and all dishes are not at their best: the marlin is not interesting for example. Decor is nice and service is great - but it does balance the disappointment of the food.
The absolute best
By pasquala on 3/17/2007
We went with such high expectations which were met and surpassed at every stage. Some of the dishes were so good that we couldn't wipe the silly smiles off our faces - the langoustines with potato gnocchi and citrus fruit will stay with me forever! We took our young daughter who was treated to her own tasting menu - pancakes, plain pasta, ice-cream and chocolate sauce and more. Obviously the service, wines, decor etc were all fabulous. We both felt very lucky as we left. The bill whilst high was expected and we actually felt that the menu was incredibly good value.
Did I miss something?
By somersky on 10/4/2006
I have been to every other fabulous restaurant in New York, and I think I was expecting PerSe to be the penultimate realization of my fine food dreams....I found it to be just okay in the big scheme of things....the first 2 or 3 courses were sublime....then I started feeling full, after all 9 courses, at what is now $210 P.P. it became too many little meals spread out amongst 3 hours....ugh! I find it similar to the movie everyone reviews and say it's the funniest thing they have ever seen, and you go see it, and everyone supposedly gets the joke except for you. The lobster was tough, the veal was fatty, the duck was just okay....my tea was bitter and oversteeped....oh well, I guess there's always Aureole, Oceana, and Bouley to go to again and again, at half the price.......BTW I am writing this in bed after chewing 4 Tums....not worth the wait for my money....
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Scientists â€‹Pretty Sure Humans Could Eat Food Grown in Martian Soil
- Another Restaurant Bites the Dust on Clinton Street
- A Talented Pastry Chef Will Open a New Bakery in the Rockaways
- This 3-D Food Printer Actually Makes Pizza So You Don’t Have To
- Bergen Hill Relocates to Noho With a Seafood-Heavy Menu