All Reader Reviews of...
176 Perry St., New York, NY, 10014
nr. West St.
By klh on 12/28/2010
I think one other reviewer (ordering the price fix) had a similar experience to me. My boyfriend and I went to Perry Street during restaurant week and got the price fix menu. The waiter was so incredibly rude after we ordered the price fix, it was unbelievable. And then we never saw him again. We couldn't get him to stop by to order a second round of drinks or a coffee with desert. We finally had to ask someone to track him down just so we could get our check and get out. He stopped by our table, said nothing, and literally threw the check on the table. The food was fine, but the service was so terrible I would NEVER go back. In fact, I don't even know if I would consider trying another JG restaurant, even though I've heard so many good things.
wait staff VERY pushy about spending money, food OK
By olivia7261 on 11/12/2010
Had dinner here yesterday with 2 friends visiting from New Zealand. We were going to go to Spice Market but when I went to the Jean Georges website they were advertising a promotion at Perry Street--3 course meal for $38. Its a great price but the staff makes you feel humiliated for ordering it. You need to order the prix fixe before 6pm so we made sure to get to the restaurant in time. Problem is the prix fixe isnt on the menu. When I asked about it waiter said there was a $68 prix fixe--I had to ask a few times before they were willing to bring over the $38 menu. And then they hounded us to buy more drinks. My friend and I were only halfway through out first drink and the waiter already offered us a second. And then she brought the second round to our table when there was still about 1/3 left in our glasses. If the staff is going to treat me this way for ordering the lower priced menu I'd prefer that the menu not be offered at all. I wouldnt return to this restaurant.
Perry Street disappointment
By footom on 12/7/2011
People seated after us were served sooner. Our drinks sat on the side of the bar for ten minutes until I requested them. Our guestâs Martini was only 2/3 filled atop 1/3 glassfull of ice. The other Martinis were to the brim. We asked repeatedly for our 3 drinks which were served at 15 minute intervals after we begged. This plus continued requests for water refills. The waiter took our dinner order, stating the special, scallops. We each ordered appetizers, and our guest ordered the scallops as her main course. Unfortunately the waiter did not mention the scallops were an appetizer, and when the mains were served, she had a tiny strip of scallops, no vegetables. We complained to the waiter who did not acknowledge. We never had to beg for service at Perry Street before. I mentioned to our waiter that this was the most inattentive experience weâve ever had at this restaurant. To his credit, he sent the manager over. The manager apologized, and offered to comp us a round of drinks and desserts. When the bill arrived, our first round of drinks were comped, but we were charged for the desserts. The waiter removed one of our dessert plates while two of us were still eating. When I said I didnât expect him to do that in the middle of dessert, he snapped, âI wasnât going to take yours.â Earlier I'd asked a waiter to check my golf umbrella. As we were leaving, the umbrella was missing, stolen, no apology.
Over-rated, over-priced, and under-serviced
By jeffop on 9/21/2013
What else can I say? The food here is mediocre compared with 20 places in Manhattan alone. And the wine list is insulting. The service, when combined with this, is pretentious and poor. Eat here if you like; I'll be saving money and eating better food.
couple nice things on the menu
By larryW on 1/25/2009
manager here was amiable. food was ok, although one item stood out. the breaded eggs with caviar. probably the best brunch item i have put into my mouth. divine. outside of that though everything else was OK. the decor looks like belvue insane asylum. price was ok. alot of hype here but all thigns considered it was avergae to me
This is a Jean-Georges Restaurant?
By hungryjacq on 1/23/2007
The restaurant week menu offered the absurdly pedestrian chicken soup and roast chicken, so we used the standard menu. Even JG's chicken isn't worth $35. We started with the tuna and snapper appetizers. The snapper was adequate, but not JG good. The tuna seemed like a cruel joke. Raw tuna rolled heavily in broken pretzels next to a vat of broccoli-cheese baked potato topping from Wendy's? The server was gracious about bringing another appetizer (the oyster sashimi), which again was good, but not great. We both ordered short ribs as entrees. The portions were extremely generous considering I'd been told I'd leave hungry. Our server had a foodgasm when we asked what he thought of the ribs, so we felt confident in the order. In truth, they were just okay. The texture was right on, but the taste was nearly gamey. In all, not a good meal. But Martha Stewart was sitting right next to us, so that was pretty cool.
it didn't wow me
By deborah on 1/27/2007
I went with two friends for restaurant week and I was the only one who ordered from the $35 prix fixe menu. The mozzarella appetizer was good and I avoided the chicken as the entree as well, getting the skate, which was covered in a spicy sauce, served simply with greens. My friend also had the tuna appetizer which didn't really work with the rice cracker crust. The chili passionfruit cocktail was sweet and spicy and packed a punch, so I had two, but I don't think I'll be back again.
Great Lunch Special
By JCity on 2/2/2009
I had lunch reservations during the work week and although we arrived 5 minutes early we were told that our table was not ready yet - even though there were empty tables visible. We waited an additional 15 minutes to be seated. Although not being seated promptly was annoying, the $25 lunch special cannot be beat.
Great Location, Fantastic Appetizers, Main Course & Desserts...Not So Much
By uesla on 9/6/2010
Arrived and promptly seated - wonderful place to watch the sunset. Our waiter then hounded us to order - really too attentive to the point of being annoying. The appetizers were fantastic - crab dumpling, calamari and the tuna were beyond amazing....should have stopped there....the main courses - the lamb and artic char were just so-so. Ordered the artic char well done since I am pregnant and received it back on the rarer side - in fact, the dish was mixed up with my friend's dish. The staff did come back to let us know that the dishes were mixed up, but not before 5 minutes or so of dining...not a big deal, just a bit on the annoying side - especially for being soooo attentive in the beginning. Dessert was just ok - passion fruit tart way too fruity and sweet. Overall - great date spot, fun neighborhood...would come for cocktails and appetizers and perhaps split a main course.
By hoopster on 12/27/2011
Hmmm... first few reviews above complain about service. We had no problems on a Christmas Day dinner. I guess, not too busy on such a day. Got there early and were seated quickly and the service was fine. Food was very good. Enjoyed it a lot and service was attentive but not pushy.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Grub Street’s Restaurant Power Rankings: Dizengoff, Olmsted, GÃ¼nter Seeger, and More
- A Trailblazing Chef Arrives in NYC With This Ambitious New Restaurant
- Sauvage, From the Maison Premiere Team, Debuts in Greenpoint
- Australia Got Its Own Naked Restaurant
- Here’s What Bourdain Learned by Eating Noodles With President Obama