All Reader Reviews of...
166 S. 4th St., Brooklyn, NY, 11211
at Driggs Ave.
Incredible food & catering
By mckendrick2000 on 2/14/2013
My wife and I chose Pies n' Thighs to cater our wedding last summer and our experience with them was terrific. They were professional and accomodating, and they knew all the right questions to ask to make sure we got exactly what we wanted. The catering staff was friendly and easy to work with and the catering manager Anne Marie was great at staying in contact with me as the big day approached. Their hospitality was really above and beyond. As for the food itself - if you haven't had a chicken biscuit from Pies n' Thighs you're really missing out. The buscuit is rich and flaky, the chicken is crispy and flavorful, and the honey butter and hot sauce bring it all together for one of the best "sandwiches" in Brooklyn. As for the pies, go for the bourbon pecan - but it's my personal opinion that the donuts are the best way to end a meal here. Favorite sides would have to be the mac n' cheese with a dab of hot sauce or the baked beans. Pies n' Thighs isn't white linen dining. It's not breaking new ground in the field of molecular gastronomy. Save all that for some other time. Pies n' Thighs will fill you up and send you home happy - and they'll do it without breaking the bank!
By mmcneeley on 11/7/2012
Pies-N-Thighs catered our wedding in September. We knew we wanted delicious hearty food and that PNT would have great fried chicken. But they surpassed our expectations by miles. From our first exchange until the day after our wedding (they provided delicious and amazing looking donuts the morning after) they were so professional, warm and generous. The food at our wedding was presented beautifully and was sublime. I can't tell you how many times I heard "best food at any wedding ever!" from our guests. They also offered a perfect variety and a nice balance between yummy fried fish and chicken to tasty, healthy and colorful vegetables and salads. And people are still talking about the pies and how great they were. As for the service: Anne Marie is the events coordinator that we worked with and she truly went above and beyond. She took such interest and care in how our day played out and was an absolute delight to work with. The chefs also showed so much care and it was clear that everyone wanted our day to be great and for us to be happy. The servers that helped at our wedding were so kind, so professional and did a perfect job. Honestly, I could go on and on about what a special and wonderful experience we had with Pies-N-Thighs. I will continue to dine in their restaurant and use their catering services and wish we could do the wedding all over again exactly the same way!
Great chicken and biscuits; everything else was good; terrible service.
By rmaldonado on 8/4/2012
The fried chicken box makes a visit to Pies-N-Thighs well worth the trip, but you will have to put up with some pretty horrendous service. On the positive side, PNT uses a great salty, peppery batter for their chicken that make the skin so good you'd want to eat that on it's own. The dark meat is moist and delicious, so dig into those drumsticks first while they're still piping hot! The white meat can be a bit dry, but that incredible batter makes up for most of it. The biscuit is fantastic, and the spicy collard greens make a great accompaniment. The pie at the end of the meal (we tried key lime and sour pear/cherry crumble) was very good, but not outstanding (and leagues behind the chicken). On the negative side, we waited forever and they did not really check in to see how we were doing. Once we were seated, it took a waiter quite a while to ask what we wanted. Once he did, he completely forgot to bring one of our drinks until we asked him again, and even then we had to wait another 10 minutes for it (a sweet tea; how hard is that to make and bring over?). He brought my friend who ordered the (only decent; not great at all) burger rare and with cheese a medium cheeseless burger. And the servers were generally unapologetic for delays/mistakes and pretty disinterested in us. Again, the chicken, biscuits and greens make up for all of this; but be warned.
Saturday night visit
By sschoneman on 11/5/2011
Wait for a table not too bad, about 10 minutes. Good service, food came quickly. Chicken was hot and juicy. Fries were too too. Deep fried apple pie was not good. Would go back for the chicken again!
Choose the Chicken, Blow Off the Brisket
By thewiseking on 2/15/2011
Typical Brooklyn cutesy place catering to the post-collegiate upper middle class white kid crowd who now populate the borough; ironic furnishings, decent rear courtyard etc.. Somewhat surly vs confused, slow moving waitstaff. Decide to skip the fried options so ordered a brisket sandwich. Big mistake. An absolutly worst cut fatty piece of gamy meat, best left as trimming in the kitchen. Sent it back to a waiter who tried to explain it away but I wasn't having it and opted for the fried chicken instead which was pretty damned good; fresh out the fryer, crisp, and satisfying served in a box with a decent biscuit. Not well seasoned but a lil salt, pepper and hot sauce didn't hurt. Wouldn't go out of my way to hit this place and does not rank near the top but ok for a snack if in S Williamsburg and not looking to fork over big bucks for a casual meal.
chicken biscuit + sides
By amandak_bk on 9/19/2010
i went to pies-n-thighs late (around 11pm) on saturday night with 3 friends. took about 15 minutes to get a table, chicken biscuit plus 4 shared sides, beer and tip came to $15. great, cheap and simple. i probably wouldn't seek it out if i wasn't in williamsburg, or wait more than half an hour for a table though.
Great grits, unmemorable chicken; still need to try the pies...
By Carolyn Murnick (NY MAG) on 6/2/2010
The fried chicken was indeed juicy, but I'm still partial to Momofuku's. The grits, however, were a sleeper hit: velvety, flavorful, and the perfect foil to the other, more acidic vegetable sides.
Very Disappointed (twice).
By PoNY4444 on 6/1/2010
Live down the block from here and was really excited to try it because of the name and the crowds of people outside. Had Chicken on a Biscuit, which cost $5 and tasted exactly the same had I used a frozen chicken patty, put it on a Pilsbury biscuit, and dumped Frank's Red Hot sauce all over it. I have and can again re-create this exact same thing at home with less disappointment. Decided to give it a second try when someone from my office ordered delivery. We requested that the Frank's Red Hot be left off of the chicken. The food arrived, with chicken that had been smeared/wiped of the hot sauce, now mushed and soggy with residual Frank's, with now broken/mushed/soggy bicuits stuck back on the accosted chicken patty. The mac & cheese was BLAND. Seriously... if I wanted to douse my food in Frank's Red Hot sauce to give it character, I am able to do that on my own time.
I don't get the hype about this place
By foodwriter on 3/27/2010
When I saw the long lines, the crowds, and the blogosphere buzz, I thought this place must be awesome. Sadly, I was very mistaken. After waiting in line forever, I could barely hear my date, kept getting bumped by the crowds still waiting for a table, and felt the waitstaff's stress at the crowd. Chicken totally lacked seasoning or depth of flavor and the Mac n' cheese was weird. But perhaps the worst sins lie in the pies. That pie crust is LEADEN. And the fillings were weird. You'd think a place that has "pies" in their name would put more work into perfecting them.
Terrible Service and pretty good food
By klegs on 3/19/2010
I have to say I was underwhelmed by the experience at Pies N Thighs the other night. Having been hyped up, the reality did not live up the hype. Service was slow, waitresses/waiters had not a clue about the diners needs or even what they ordered (they came into the room and asked "who ordered XX?". I had the pulled pork box, with mac 'n cheese-- hearty, spicy and cheap it was a tasty dinner. They tried to make it up by not charging for beer and gave us a cookie... from speaking with others, most people have this same experience.
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- Supreme Court Won’t Stand in the Way of Seattle’s $15 Minimum Wage
- Congress Introduced a Bill to Keep Journalists From Snooping Around Big Food
- A Farming Cartoonist Was Fired for Joking About Big Agriculture
- Why This Leading London Chef Feels Energized by New York Kitchens
- Oxford Student Refuses to Tip Server Because She’s White