Showers 47°
You are not logged in

New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Shelly's Trattoria

All Reader Reviews of...

Shelly's Trattoria

41 W. 57th St., New York, NY, 10019
nr. Fifth Ave.
212-245-2422

8.5 "Highly Recommended"
Average Reader Rating
on a Scale of 10		 Write Your Own Review
83% Would you go back?
83% Would you take a date?
33% Would you take kids?
83% Would you go on business?
83% Would you go on a special occasion?
Food: 9.8
Service: 9.3
Décor: 9.2
Value: 8.7
  • Write a Review
  • Showing reviews 1 through 6 of 6

Valentine's Day meal

charlotte22 from WD4 8AD | Posted on 2/19/09

Overall Rating: 9 (Highly Recommended)
Would you go back? Yes
Would you take a date? Yes
Would you take kids? Yes
Would you go on business? Yes
Would you go on a special occasion? Yes
Food: 10
Service: 9
Décor: 9
Value: 9

We went on Valentine's day and it was great. There was a jazz band playing on the balcony above the bar which was a really nice touch. The food was amazing and everyone was really friendly. We would definately recommend Shelly's to couples.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Request Removal

1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

wifes birthday

michcook from 06483 | Posted on 10/21/06

Overall Rating: 3 (Not Recommended)
Would you go back? No
Would you take a date? No
Would you take kids? No
Would you go on business? No
Would you go on a special occasion? No
Food: 9
Service: 8
Décor: 7
Value: 3

Went there for my wifes birthday. The food was excellent. The big problem was I set-up with the host a surprise dessert for my wife before meal ended. He forgot to inform waiter and ruined what should have been a special evening. Dont go there if you are planning a special evening they will ruin it....Thanks Shellys

Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Request Removal

115 out of 293 people found this review helpful.

Warm Hospitality

jadelizabeth | Posted on 12/7/03

Overall Rating: 10 (Highly Recommended)
Would you go back? Yes
Would you take a date? Yes
Would you take kids? No
Would you go on business? Yes
Would you go on a special occasion? Yes
Food: 10
Service: 10
Décor: 10
Value: 10

The staff at Shelly's go above and beyond, to make the dining experience as pleasurable as can be. They go above and beyond! Kudos to Moheb!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Request Removal

149 out of 282 people found this review helpful.

UPSCALE & TOP NOTCH IN MANHATTAN

jkalemis | Posted on 7/29/03

Overall Rating: 10 (Highly Recommended)
Would you go back? Yes
Would you take a date? Yes
Would you take kids? No
Would you go on business? Yes
Would you go on a special occasion? Yes
Food: 10
Service: 10
Décor: 10
Value: 10

Shelly's on 57th Street is one of New York's most beautiful restaurants. No design feature has been left un-noticed by the Architects/designers. The food & preperation of food is excellent. The service is friendly and timely. The cuisine is expensive but not outrageous by New York standards. And the place is spotless from top to bottom including the kitchen. My compliments to Shelly. J.Kalemis St. Louis, Missouri

Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Request Removal

129 out of 260 people found this review helpful.

Shelly's delivers the goods!

beefeater | Posted on 3/19/03

Overall Rating: 9 (Highly Recommended)
Would you go back? Yes
Would you take a date? Yes
Would you take kids? No
Would you go on business? Yes
Would you go on a special occasion? Yes
Food: 10
Service: 9
Décor: 9
Value: 10

I was at first skeptical of a restaurant that offered reasonable prices in the tourist district.A price fixe dinner that includes an abundant Oyster and shellfish platter, 30 oz porterhouse, and gourmet desert for two is more than enough food. The porterhouse steak is grilled in butter to give a delicious crust and juicy meat. Service is attentive and not obtrusive. On two occasions, an apertif of muscatel was served gratis, ending a very pleasant and delicious meal. Caveat: Kids will find little to do while waiting and the environment is mature and sober.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Request Removal

134 out of 276 people found this review helpful.

third times the charm!

ripley | Posted on 2/6/03

Overall Rating: 10 (Highly Recommended)
Would you go back? Yes
Would you take a date? Yes
Would you take kids? Yes
Would you go on business? Yes
Would you go on a special occasion? Yes
Food: 10
Service: 10
Décor: 10
Value: 10

Was at shellys three times and all three times I left with my head spining. First for my father's birthday. the desserts all looked so good we each ordered somthing different and funniest thing we played musical chairs with them everyone was better then the last. Then we took my son for his birthday the raw bar combo platter was out of this world. My son was amased that ther was a gentlman in the bathroom to hand out towels when washing hands and bathrooms overall cleaness. Don't forget the peter max artwork around the walls. Third time we were there we had just finished a day biking around centeral park. We had our bikes and were,........ we felt underderssed, but where welcomed with open arms and sat in the front window so we could see our bikes , fish and chips out of this world-- don't forget the homemade tatar. Would I go back again...I think I already did twice now that says somthing.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes No Request Removal

166 out of 337 people found this review helpful.

  • 1
Advertising

Latest News Near

Advertising
Advertising