All Reader Reviews of...
4 Park Ave., New York, NY, 10016
at 33rd St.
Rude and Hostile
By tommyb on 1/12/2006
Why bother making a reservation when they don't honor it and are hostile and aloof about it? This is place is joke.
By louisebell on 12/1/2005
I'm not sure which part of last night was the worst: the fact that we waited for an hour after our reservation to be seated; were then told to "get up, that's not your table;" finding out that the large party sat at the table that was not ours actually had a later reservation; or the total lack of apology for the ridiculous wait time or the rudeness of the maitre d'. My friend's birthday would have been ruined if Patrick and co. at Smith & Wollensky's hadn't taken such good care of the 11 of us. I used to work in the service industry, and was taught that when a guest chooses your restaurant for a special occasion, you go out of your way to make the evening perfect for them. I was appalled by Wolfgang's failure to even try, and don't care if the steaks are good enough to cause orgasm. I'll never go back.
By johnallen on 12/1/2005
Had to wait for an hour. Grey haired male hostess was awful
Our Reservation Wasn't Honored
By carnivorous on 12/1/2005
I, too, was made to wait recently for well over an hour past my reservation time. During that endless wait in the cramped entryway, I witnessed a succession of other angry customers engaged in heated discussions with the same awful silver-haired host, who offered nary an apology and instead chose to act rudely and dismissively towards his patrons. While gruff, curt service is a sort of staple of the New York Steakhouse dining experience, it's usually more of a pose than an actual attitude problem, and is much easier to swallow when practiced by the people who are going to bring the meat to the table. In any event, after our host had told us "just a few more minutes" for the upteenth time and it became clear that he had no intention of seating us in the foreseeable future, we gave up and left, angry, hungry and unsettled. It's really too bad, because I was really quite hungry for a nice juicy steak. Somebody should remind the host that he is not a bouncer at Bungalow. His job is to warmly welcome customers in, and graciously seat them down for dinner.
By luvpuf on 11/4/2005
This might be a little harsh, but I never had to deal with an unprofessional staff at a "good" restaurant. I just got off the phone with the manager, Arnie, who has no recollection of booking my party. Now the reason I had to speak to the manager in the first place is too long of a story, let’s just say the hosts are even less professional than the manager. For further reference I highly recommend that if you have an important event make a reservation elsewhere. Besides, the horrid service, I have had much better steak, in other restaurants of the comparable status in a superior atmosphere, with a lesser amount of noise and better accommodations.
My Dog Ate Better From The Can Tonight
By rwnelson on 8/24/2005
Perhaps the worst meal I've had in seven years of Manhattan living. Waited almost an hour for a table without so much as a "sorry". Food was overcooked. Service was rushed and we were stuffed in a back room . Never again.
Horrible service ruined evening..
By earteta on 5/30/2005
We are huge fans of Peter Lugar's, but are weary of the road trip. We were excited to try Wolfgang's. The food was good, but given how much we value service as part of the dining experience, it is highly unlikely we would ever go back. Our medium rare steaks came back at cooked more than medium. We were made to feel stupid for sending it back, and then the caustic servers proceeded to ignore us the rest of the evening. We were given the lowest level of basic service available. It was horrific. A complaint to the manager on the way out did little, and the only attention we got was the server complaining about his tip as we walked out. Spend you money at Mark Joseph or make the road trip to the real deal.
By rsw231 on 5/5/2005
Despite the hype, the steak did not live up to expectations. We had the steak for 3 and it was very good but without much flavor. Go to Sparks or the Strip House instead.
By efn on 4/29/2005
Granted a forty five minute wait on a confirmed reservation made two weeks, prior with all of my party on time did not put me in a good mood: the food was good but not uniquely spectacular like at his old work spot. I don't think I'll be back.
By shelle50 on 4/22/2005
took clients for an expensive dinner was rushed through all courses felt very uncomfortable no comparison to service at sparks del fresco mark joseph dont waster your "time" or money
- The best reviews give a clear sense of why you liked or disliked a restaurant, bar, or store. And that means details. Mention specifics dishes, type of crowd, pros and cons...
- If it's helpful to compare one place to another, go for it.
- Come up with clever, funny, pithy subject lines, and write in the first person.
- Don't forget to read the user rating guidelines and rules.
- 12 Session Beers That Are Perfect for Summer Guzzling
- Silicon Valley Start-Up Working to Create a World Where All Pizza Is Cooked by Robots
- Japanese Chain Debuts Predictably Bonkers Ghostbusters Burgers
- Brooklyn’s Take Root Will Host Its First Designer Pop-up This Weekend
- The Stonewall Inn Is Now a National Monument