Skip to content, or skip to search.

Caterers Directory

Page 4 of 4

Seasons Distinctive Catering

2191 Third Ave., at 119th St.; 212-996-3160;

Chef-owners Marc Tessitore and Robert Zimmerman pride themselves on their attention to detail, and guarantee that one or both of them will attend every event-no matter the venue. Past menus have included roasted-vegetable-and-potato Napoleon with asparagus purée and candied-ginger crème brûlée. Passed hors d’oeuvre range from $14 to $20; buffet and plated dinners are $45 to $75.

Serena Bass

404 W. 13th St., nr. Ninth Ave.; 212-727-2257;

This downtown doyenne will tackle any recipe her clients request. For a Russian couple, Bass created a five-course feast including roasted-red-and-yellow-beet Napoleon, wild-mushroom tarts with rye pastry, ratatouille, and poached sturgeon with coriander seed. From $175.

Shiraz NYC

161 W. 22nd St., nr. Seventh Ave., second fl.; 212-255-7001;

For tastes that span the map, Shiraz offers an excellent global-fusion menu: Appetizers include honey-smoked filet mignon with grilled pineapple salsa, and drinks made with freshly squeezed juices and herbal infusions. Some clients skip the traditional wedding cake in favor of crème brûlée served with orange-apricot relish and mint. From $100.

Simply Divine

604 W. 46th St., nr. Eleventh Ave.; 212-541-7300;

Since 1988, Simply Divine has provided a boutique approach to kosher catering and event planning for selective brides who want an alternative to the typical kosher-wedding experience. Menus typically feature house-smoked fish; zucchini-basil crêpes with wild mushroom sauté; beef, chicken, and duck entrées with shiraz and chardonnay reduction sauces; and fish entrées with basil, chive, or ginger lime emulsion sauces. From $175 to $225.

Sonnier & Castle

532 W. 46th St., nr. Tenth Ave.; 212-957-6481;

A recent edition to the company, executive chef Cornelius Gallagher (formerly of restaurants Oceana, Bouley, and Daniel) caters events of all sizes with a flair for innovative cuisine. Hors d’oeuvre include peekytoe crab profiteroles with curry and crispy cumin panisse with sweet-onion coulis (from $150).

Special Attention - Ellen Gelb

325 E. Houston St., nr. Attorney St.; 212-477-4805;

Ellen Gelb is best known for her Asian-inspired concoctions, such as steamed lobster dumplings and Vietnamese summer rolls. But she’s up for offering other cuisines, too; a recent feast included thyme-roasted whole branzino (from $175).

Spoonbread, Inc.

364 Cathedral Pkwy., nr. Columbus Ave.; 212-865-0700;

Norma Jean Darden’s expertise lies in melding different cuisines-Asian-Quaker, say, or Japanese-Jewish. For TV newsman Maurice DuBois, who met his wife in Africa, Darden made Nigerian chicken in peanut sauce (from $32.50).

A Sterling Affair

575 Madison Ave., nr. 56th St., 212-686-4075; After working at high-end establishments like the Culinary Institute of America and the Waldorf-Astoria, Peter Fazio joined this French New American catering venture. A Sterling Affair is at its best with hors d’oeuvre, serving options like lobster bisque turnovers with crème fraîche or truffled macaroni-and-cheese bites. From $175.

Sylvia's Catering

328 Lenox Ave., nr. 126th St.; 212-996-0660;

Soul-food icon Sylvia Woods’ daughter Bedelia Woods is at the helm of Sylvia’s Catering. On the menu: Chilean sea bass with saffron butter sauce, sautéed collard greens with roasted garlic, braised barbecue short ribs of beef, ol’ Charleston shrimp with herb cheese grits, and sweet-potato cheesecake ($50 to $150).

Taste Caterers, Inc.

113 Horatio St., nr. Washington St.; 212-255-8571;

Taste Caterers’ seasonal menus emphasize fresh, local ingredients (from the Hudson Valley and Long Island). Choices include a wild-mushroom tasting plate, horseradish-crusted wild salmon, star-anise fillet of beef, and artisanal cheeses ($225 to $250).



Alexandra Payard’s tasty receptions feature hors d’oeuvre like porcini tartlets with endive fondue, followed by a tasting dinner with dishes like coffee-ancho-chili-braised short ribs with baked grits, or seared salmon with Chilean carica, cucumber rémoulade, and wasabi-buttermilk dressing ($85 to $250).

Thomas Preti

146 E. 37th St., nr. Third Ave.; 212-764-3188;

With more than twenty years in the catering business, Thomas Preti will help couples find the right location for their wedding. The innovative presentation includes tasting plates as part of the dinner menu, or a dessert sampler. Weddings (usually lasting six hours) start at $200.

Tip of the Tongue

11-32 49th Ave., nr. Jackson Ave., Long Island City; 718-786-4200;

When couples want a seasonal menu reflecting a diverse culinary heritage (e.g., Filipino-Polish or Italian-Puerto Rican), they call on Scott Fagan and Eric McIntyre for a customized menu, including five-spiced empanadas, sesame tuna on wasabi blinis, and chocolate passionfruit bombes. This team manages all aspects of a wedding, from venue selection, vendor logistics, rentals, staffing, and drinks with total budget transparency and a down-to-earth attitude. With service styles and strategies for almost every budget, receptions usually range from $120 to $170 per person (including alcohol).

Tom Orlando

212 W. 22nd St., nr. Seventh Ave.; 212-255-2846

Known for combining elegance and comfort, Orlando and his staff offer clever fare such as roasted Maine lobster with fresh figs and sautéed foie gras, duck à l’orange, and a veal chop stuffed with spinach and leeks ($95 to $225).

The Upper Crust

91 Horatio St., nr. Washington St.; 212-691-4570;

Since 1983 this West Village caterer, which also has its own event space, has been accommodating every kind of palate. For one wedding, they re-created the empanada recipe of the bride’s Ecuadorian grandmother. Not afraid of big numbers, the Upper Crust has served crowds of 3,000 guests. Prices for cocktail-only receptions start at $70; supper buffets and seated dinners start at $150 to $175 (including alcohol).


Spot an error in a listing or want to suggest an update? Contact us.

New York Weddings issue app ad
Order the Weddings Issue Today

Cover of New York Magazine's Spring 2017 Wedding issue

Order This Issue