A different writer judges each round. Click the winning shows to read their deliberations!
Real World San Francisco
Project Greenlight
Season 2
Flavor ofLove
Season 1
The BachelorSeason 13
The OsbournesSeason 1
SYTYCDSeason 3
The HillsSeason 1
ProjectRunway
Season 2
SurvivorSeason 1
RuPaul's Drag Race
Season 4
Amazing RaceSeason 5
RealHousewives
ATL: Season 2
Top ChefSeason 6
ANTMSeason 2
Jersey ShoreSeason 1
American Idol
Season 2
Real WorldThe BachelorThe OsbournesProject Runway
SurvivorRealHousewives
ANTMAmerican Idol
Real WorldProject Runway
SurvivorAMNTMProject
Runway
Runway
Survivor