Alert Icon

Double Right Chevrons
russia investigation

Mueller Disputes BuzzFeed Report That Trump Ordered Cohen to Perjure Himself

An unexpected public statement from the special counsel. Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images

On Friday night, the special counsel issued a rare public statement, disputing the BuzzFeed News report that President Trump directed Michael Cohen to lie to Congress about plans to build a tower in Moscow. “BuzzFeed’s description of specific statements to the special counsel’s office, and characterization of documents and testimony obtained by this office, regarding Michael Cohen’s congressional testimony are not accurate,” said Peter Carr, spokesman for the Mueller investigation. It appears to be the first time the special counsel has publicly contested a news account, casting doubt on a major collusion break that had some Democrats talking potential obstruction of justice charges.

On Twitter, journalists weighed the details of the Mueller investigation’s decision to break radio silence and comment on the report — almost 24 hours after its initial publication in which they issued a “no comment.” Reporter Peter Sterne posed three possible options for the contention: There are minor inconsistencies in the report; it’s substantively incorrect; or it
correctly depicts what Cohen told federal prosecutors in a different office, like the Southern District of New York. Ronan Farrow, who broke the story of Trump’s alleged affair with Karen McDougal, tweeted that he “declined to run with parts of the narrative they conveyed based on a source central to the story repeatedly disputing the idea that Trump directly issued orders of that kind.” Additionally, the New York Times claims that a source “familiar with Mr. Cohen’s testimony to the special counsel’s prosecutors said that Mr. Cohen did not state that the president had pressured him to lie to Congress.” BuzzFeed editor-in-chief Ben Smith announced his confidence in his team’s reporting and requested that Mueller “make clear what he’s disputing.” On CNN, Smith also said that BuzzFeed was not “playing any games with the characterization” of their two federal law enforcement sources.

On Friday morning, House Intelligence chairman Adam Schiff announced that the committee was “already working to secure additional witness testimony and documents related to the Trump Tower Moscow deal and other investigative matters.” (As of publication, Schiff has not given a statement on the special counsel’s update.) Before the Mueller team’s surprise announcement, Democrats were discussing “impeachment” en masse for the first time in a while, with at least four members of Congress using the word on Thursday and Friday — talk that will likely die down pending further investigation of the BuzzFeed account.

When the special counsel published its comment, Trump began retweeting takedowns of of BuzzFeed News. As New York’s Olivia Nuzzi noted, “Whatever ends up being the case about the BuzzFeed story, it sure is interesting to see the president and all of his supporters so eager to accept as fact the statement put out by the special counsel’s office.” In this case of rare camaraderie, it appears that the enemy of the “enemy of the people” is his friend.

Mueller Disputes Report That Trump Had Cohen Perjure Himself
russia investigation

Mueller Disputes BuzzFeed Report That Trump Ordered Cohen to Perjure Himself

An unexpected public statement from the special counsel. Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images

On Friday night, the special counsel issued a rare public statement, disputing the BuzzFeed News report that President Trump directed Michael Cohen to lie to Congress about plans to build a tower in Moscow. “BuzzFeed’s description of specific statements to the special counsel’s office, and characterization of documents and testimony obtained by this office, regarding Michael Cohen’s congressional testimony are not accurate,” said Peter Carr, spokesman for the Mueller investigation. It appears to be the first time the special counsel has publicly contested a news account, casting doubt on a major collusion break that had some Democrats talking potential obstruction of justice charges.

On Twitter, journalists weighed the details of the Mueller investigation’s decision to break radio silence and comment on the report — almost 24 hours after its initial publication in which they issued a “no comment.” Reporter Peter Sterne posed three possible options for the contention: There are minor inconsistencies in the report; it’s substantively incorrect; or it
correctly depicts what Cohen told federal prosecutors in a different office, like the Southern District of New York. Ronan Farrow, who broke the story of Trump’s alleged affair with Karen McDougal, tweeted that he “declined to run with parts of the narrative they conveyed based on a source central to the story repeatedly disputing the idea that Trump directly issued orders of that kind.” Additionally, the New York Times claims that a source “familiar with Mr. Cohen’s testimony to the special counsel’s prosecutors said that Mr. Cohen did not state that the president had pressured him to lie to Congress.” BuzzFeed editor-in-chief Ben Smith announced his confidence in his team’s reporting and requested that Mueller “make clear what he’s disputing.” On CNN, Smith also said that BuzzFeed was not “playing any games with the characterization” of their two federal law enforcement sources.

On Friday morning, House Intelligence chairman Adam Schiff announced that the committee was “already working to secure additional witness testimony and documents related to the Trump Tower Moscow deal and other investigative matters.” (As of publication, Schiff has not given a statement on the special counsel’s update.) Before the Mueller team’s surprise announcement, Democrats were discussing “impeachment” en masse for the first time in a while, with at least four members of Congress using the word on Thursday and Friday — talk that will likely die down pending further investigation of the BuzzFeed account.

When the special counsel published its comment, Trump began retweeting takedowns of of BuzzFeed News. As New York’s Olivia Nuzzi noted, “Whatever ends up being the case about the BuzzFeed story, it sure is interesting to see the president and all of his supporters so eager to accept as fact the statement put out by the special counsel’s office.” In this case of rare camaraderie, it appears that the enemy of the “enemy of the people” is his friend.

Mueller Disputes Report That Trump Had Cohen Perjure Himself

Things you buy through our links may earn Vox Media a commission.

THE FEED
politics
politics
What Happens After George Santos Gets Forced Out of Congress?
The fabulist freshman congressman is probably on the way out this week, and a special election looms.
the talented mr. santos
the talented mr. santos
Here’s Every Single Lie Told by George Santos
Navigating the many exaggerations and falsehoods the New York congressman, who is now facing 23 federal criminal charges.
early and often
early and often
Melania Trump Adds Awkward Touch to Rosalynn Carter Funeral
She didn’t do anything offensive, but the mere presence of a Trump was controversial.
early and often
early and often
Iowa Kingmaker Vander Plaats Thinks State Will ‘Rise Up’ Against Trump
Bob Vander Plaats has a solid record of picking Iowa Caucus winners. But DeSantis isn’t going to beat Trump on January 15.
dreaming of a white christmas
dreaming of a white christmas
It Hasn’t Really Snowed in NYC for Almost Two Years
When will this unacceptable drought end?
early and often
early and often
Conservative Christian Affection for Fascists Predates Trump
Anyone shocked by Christian Trump voters’ tolerance for his increasingly authoritarian rhetoric and policies should look to European history.
the money game
the money game
Elon Musk’s Cybertruck Is Striking — and Poorly Timed
Tesla is expected to deliver the electric pickups this week, but the EV market is in dire shape.
foreign interests
foreign interests
In Bibi’s Israel, Musk’s Brand of Antisemitism Is Kosher
How a plutocrat can post antisemitic tweets one day and shake hands with the Israeli prime minister the next.
screen time
screen time
What If Amazon Delivered Everything You Order From Anywhere?
The company’s massive logistics operation may soon allow it to remake yet another sector of the economy however it wants.
tremendous content
tremendous content
Trump Insists He’s Not Old and Confused, We Just Don’t Get Sarcasm
He claims he repeatedly mixed up Barack Obama and Joe Biden “sarcastically.”
what we know
what we know
What We Know About the Shooting of 3 Palestinians in Burlington, Vermont
A suspect has pleaded not guilty to attempted murder charges in the shooting, which is being investigated as a potential hate crime.
early and often
early and often
Christie Vows to Continue Doomed Campaign to the Bitter End
The former New Jersey governor could maintain a zombie candidacy right up until the convention. What does he have to lose?
israel-hamas war
israel-hamas war
What We Know About the Hostages Released During the Israel-Hamas Truce
The temporary cease-fire is set to be extended to six days following a fourth exchange of hostages and prisoners on Monday night.
the national interest
the national interest
Why a Second Trump Presidency Might Try Again to Repeal Obamacare
A Republican Congress might do it.
the city politic
the city politic
10 New York Charities Worth Supporting on Giving Tuesday
From aiding recently arrived migrants to fighting hunger to treating victims of the Israel-Hamas war, these organizations are making a difference.
israel-hamas war
israel-hamas war
Why Jewish Voice for Peace Says ‘Not in Our Name’
Jewish Voice for Peace doesn’t just oppose the war in Gaza; it challenges the link between Jewish identity and support for Israel.
the national interest
the national interest
Just Stop Making Official Statements About the News
A simple answer for every CEO, school president, and City Council.
games
games
Michigan Won At All Costs and Your Team Would Too
Scandals be damned; just by defeating Ohio State on Saturday, the team prevailed over its critics.
early and often
early and often
Do Young Voters Actually Prefer Trump to Biden?
Democrats worried that disenchanted 18-to-34-year-old voters would stay home in 2024. Polls show they may have a bigger problem.
early and often
early and often
Trump Has a Plan for Massively Increasing Inflation
The GOP candidate is benefiting from outrage over high prices, even though his policies would raise them further.
just asking questions
just asking questions
How Long Could the Israel-Hamas Ceasefire Last?
Gershon Baskin, a veteran Israeli hostage negotiator, on what both sides stand to gain and lose.
technology
technology
OpenAI Was Never Going to Save Us From the Robot Apocalypse
The idea that a single nonprofit could ensure that AI was developed at a “safe” speed never made any sense.
tremendous content
tremendous content
Trump Posted 19 Videos at Once on Truth Social in a Cry for Help
Is it a sign of desperation or laziness?
what we know
what we know
Niagara Falls Rainbow Bridge Explosion: What We Know
Traffic was halted at the border crossing between the U.S. and Canada owing to what the FBI says was a vehicle exploding.
the money game
the money game
Behold the Utter Destruction of Crypto’s Biggest Names
Can crypto survive when so few of its founding fathers have?