Alert Icon

russia investigation

Mueller Disputes BuzzFeed Report That Trump Ordered Cohen to Perjure Himself

An unexpected public statement from the special counsel. Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images

On Friday night, the special counsel issued a rare public statement, disputing the BuzzFeed News report that President Trump directed Michael Cohen to lie to Congress about plans to build a tower in Moscow. “BuzzFeed’s description of specific statements to the special counsel’s office, and characterization of documents and testimony obtained by this office, regarding Michael Cohen’s congressional testimony are not accurate,” said Peter Carr, spokesman for the Mueller investigation. It appears to be the first time the special counsel has publicly contested a news account, casting doubt on a major collusion break that had some Democrats talking potential obstruction of justice charges.

On Twitter, journalists weighed the details of the Mueller investigation’s decision to break radio silence and comment on the report — almost 24 hours after its initial publication in which they issued a “no comment.” Reporter Peter Sterne posed three possible options for the contention: There are minor inconsistencies in the report; it’s substantively incorrect; or it
correctly depicts what Cohen told federal prosecutors in a different office, like the Southern District of New York. Ronan Farrow, who broke the story of Trump’s alleged affair with Karen McDougal, tweeted that he “declined to run with parts of the narrative they conveyed based on a source central to the story repeatedly disputing the idea that Trump directly issued orders of that kind.” Additionally, the New York Times claims that a source “familiar with Mr. Cohen’s testimony to the special counsel’s prosecutors said that Mr. Cohen did not state that the president had pressured him to lie to Congress.” BuzzFeed editor-in-chief Ben Smith announced his confidence in his team’s reporting and requested that Mueller “make clear what he’s disputing.” On CNN, Smith also said that BuzzFeed was not “playing any games with the characterization” of their two federal law enforcement sources.

On Friday morning, House Intelligence chairman Adam Schiff announced that the committee was “already working to secure additional witness testimony and documents related to the Trump Tower Moscow deal and other investigative matters.” (As of publication, Schiff has not given a statement on the special counsel’s update.) Before the Mueller team’s surprise announcement, Democrats were discussing “impeachment” en masse for the first time in a while, with at least four members of Congress using the word on Thursday and Friday — talk that will likely die down pending further investigation of the BuzzFeed account.

When the special counsel published its comment, Trump began retweeting takedowns of of BuzzFeed News. As New York’s Olivia Nuzzi noted, “Whatever ends up being the case about the BuzzFeed story, it sure is interesting to see the president and all of his supporters so eager to accept as fact the statement put out by the special counsel’s office.” In this case of rare camaraderie, it appears that the enemy of the “enemy of the people” is his friend.

Mueller Disputes Report That Trump Had Cohen Perjure Himself
russia investigation

Mueller Disputes BuzzFeed Report That Trump Ordered Cohen to Perjure Himself

An unexpected public statement from the special counsel. Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images

On Friday night, the special counsel issued a rare public statement, disputing the BuzzFeed News report that President Trump directed Michael Cohen to lie to Congress about plans to build a tower in Moscow. “BuzzFeed’s description of specific statements to the special counsel’s office, and characterization of documents and testimony obtained by this office, regarding Michael Cohen’s congressional testimony are not accurate,” said Peter Carr, spokesman for the Mueller investigation. It appears to be the first time the special counsel has publicly contested a news account, casting doubt on a major collusion break that had some Democrats talking potential obstruction of justice charges.

On Twitter, journalists weighed the details of the Mueller investigation’s decision to break radio silence and comment on the report — almost 24 hours after its initial publication in which they issued a “no comment.” Reporter Peter Sterne posed three possible options for the contention: There are minor inconsistencies in the report; it’s substantively incorrect; or it
correctly depicts what Cohen told federal prosecutors in a different office, like the Southern District of New York. Ronan Farrow, who broke the story of Trump’s alleged affair with Karen McDougal, tweeted that he “declined to run with parts of the narrative they conveyed based on a source central to the story repeatedly disputing the idea that Trump directly issued orders of that kind.” Additionally, the New York Times claims that a source “familiar with Mr. Cohen’s testimony to the special counsel’s prosecutors said that Mr. Cohen did not state that the president had pressured him to lie to Congress.” BuzzFeed editor-in-chief Ben Smith announced his confidence in his team’s reporting and requested that Mueller “make clear what he’s disputing.” On CNN, Smith also said that BuzzFeed was not “playing any games with the characterization” of their two federal law enforcement sources.

On Friday morning, House Intelligence chairman Adam Schiff announced that the committee was “already working to secure additional witness testimony and documents related to the Trump Tower Moscow deal and other investigative matters.” (As of publication, Schiff has not given a statement on the special counsel’s update.) Before the Mueller team’s surprise announcement, Democrats were discussing “impeachment” en masse for the first time in a while, with at least four members of Congress using the word on Thursday and Friday — talk that will likely die down pending further investigation of the BuzzFeed account.

When the special counsel published its comment, Trump began retweeting takedowns of of BuzzFeed News. As New York’s Olivia Nuzzi noted, “Whatever ends up being the case about the BuzzFeed story, it sure is interesting to see the president and all of his supporters so eager to accept as fact the statement put out by the special counsel’s office.” In this case of rare camaraderie, it appears that the enemy of the “enemy of the people” is his friend.

Mueller Disputes Report That Trump Had Cohen Perjure Himself

Things you buy through our links may earn New York a commission.

THE FEED
covid-19
covid-19
What We Do and Don’t Know About the Omicron Variant
Five cases have been confirmed in New York City and Long Island.
andrew cuomo
andrew cuomo
The Feds Are Also Investigating Sexual Misconduct Claims Against Andrew Cuomo
The inquiry is reportedly focused on potential violations of federal civil rights and labor laws.
covid testing
covid testing
Reimbursements for At-Home Tests Are Coming in January
President Biden announced a plan to provide cash back for COVID tests for insured Americans, among other initiatives for the second pandemic winter.
crime
crime
Everything to Know About Jussie Smollett’s Trial
The actor was accused of staging his own hate-crime attack in 2019. Things only got more complicated from there.
sports
sports
Men’s Tennis Offers a Weak Response to Peng Shuai’s Plight
So far, women’s tennis stands alone in the sports world with its bold stance toward China.
this endless pandemic
this endless pandemic
Waiting for Omicron
The new variant comes to a country that still does not have the pandemic under control.
2022 midterms
2022 midterms
Trump Frets About Ads Attacking J.D. Vance for Attacking Him
The former president’s involvement in 2022 midterm campaigns isn’t about his party — it’s strictly about him.
abortion
abortion
The Betrayal of Roe
Decades of neglect and cowardice have brought this country to the precipice.
court appearances
court appearances
What We Learned From the First Ghislaine Maxwell Accuser to Testify
“Jane” said she was instructed by Maxwell on how to give Jeffrey Epstein a massage.
politics
politics
Eric Adams Celebrates Hanukkah at a Chabad House in Ghana
This is like Mad Libs.
the national interest
the national interest
Republican Senator Tom Cotton Admits Trump, Not Biden, Caused Inflation
Oops.
the national interest
the national interest
If Trump Voters Lived in Germany, They’d Be in the Fascist Party
No, not that one.
the media
the media
BuzzFeed Is About to Go Public — and Its Employees Are Walking Out in Protest
The small but high-profile BuzzFeed News unit is using the occasion to register dissatisfaction with management.
abortion
abortion
Anti-Abortion Movement Nears Victory 29 Years After a Betrayal
After a surprise defeat in the Supreme Court in 1992, Roe v. Wade opponents demanded more from Republicans, and Trump kept his promises to them.
peng shuai
peng shuai
Women’s Tennis Suspends Tournaments in China Over Treatment of Peng Shuai
The WTA president said he doubted that doubles star Peng Shuai was “safe and not subject to censorship” following her sexual-assault allegation.
2022 midterms
2022 midterms
Stacey Abrams Announces 2022 Run for Governor of Georgia
Abrams will have a united Democratic Party facing Trump-divided Republicans, and perhaps a grudge rematch with voter suppressor Brian Kemp.
politics
politics
Will the Body Become a Prison?
If conservative justices side with Mississippi’s abortion ban, many women will not escape.
the fallout
the fallout
CNN Suspends Chris Cuomo Indefinitely
The cable-news host is out after a transcript from the NY attorney general showed he had tried to dig up info on his brother Andrew Cuomo’s accusers.
the money game
the money game
Anyone Want to Buy a Yacht for $115 Million in Crypto?
That was just one of the deals on offer as crypto-mania swept over Art Basel in Miami.
politics
politics
This Is How Roe Ends
Hope for a compromise that preserves abortion rights looks lost after conservative justices spoke about Mississippi’s 15-week ban.
omicron variant
omicron variant
A Variant Hunter on Omicron’s ‘Tectonic Shift’
While no one is certain how the new form of the virus will shape up, a virologist explains why the mutant has freaked out so many scientists.
politics
politics
‘The Mayor Knew’
Eric Garcetti’s top aide was a serial harasser, according to multiple accusers. The mayor, they say, ignored it.
government shutdown
government shutdown
Will Republicans Force a Government Shutdown to Fight Biden’s Vaccine Mandates?
A small group of conservatives can gum up the works and force at least a brief shutdown. But with Omicron looming, the timing is strange.
court appearances
court appearances
The Ghislaine Maxwell Trial, Explained
The close Jeffrey Epstein associate faces sex-trafficking and conspiracy charges. Who is she?
covid-19
covid-19
Trump Tested Positive for COVID Before Debate, Meadows Says
A new book claims the former president didn’t bother to inform Joe Biden, the media, or almost anyone else.