Alert Icon

Double Right Chevrons
russia investigation

Mueller Disputes BuzzFeed Report That Trump Ordered Cohen to Perjure Himself

An unexpected public statement from the special counsel. Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images

On Friday night, the special counsel issued a rare public statement, disputing the BuzzFeed News report that President Trump directed Michael Cohen to lie to Congress about plans to build a tower in Moscow. “BuzzFeed’s description of specific statements to the special counsel’s office, and characterization of documents and testimony obtained by this office, regarding Michael Cohen’s congressional testimony are not accurate,” said Peter Carr, spokesman for the Mueller investigation. It appears to be the first time the special counsel has publicly contested a news account, casting doubt on a major collusion break that had some Democrats talking potential obstruction of justice charges.

On Twitter, journalists weighed the details of the Mueller investigation’s decision to break radio silence and comment on the report — almost 24 hours after its initial publication in which they issued a “no comment.” Reporter Peter Sterne posed three possible options for the contention: There are minor inconsistencies in the report; it’s substantively incorrect; or it
correctly depicts what Cohen told federal prosecutors in a different office, like the Southern District of New York. Ronan Farrow, who broke the story of Trump’s alleged affair with Karen McDougal, tweeted that he “declined to run with parts of the narrative they conveyed based on a source central to the story repeatedly disputing the idea that Trump directly issued orders of that kind.” Additionally, the New York Times claims that a source “familiar with Mr. Cohen’s testimony to the special counsel’s prosecutors said that Mr. Cohen did not state that the president had pressured him to lie to Congress.” BuzzFeed editor-in-chief Ben Smith announced his confidence in his team’s reporting and requested that Mueller “make clear what he’s disputing.” On CNN, Smith also said that BuzzFeed was not “playing any games with the characterization” of their two federal law enforcement sources.

On Friday morning, House Intelligence chairman Adam Schiff announced that the committee was “already working to secure additional witness testimony and documents related to the Trump Tower Moscow deal and other investigative matters.” (As of publication, Schiff has not given a statement on the special counsel’s update.) Before the Mueller team’s surprise announcement, Democrats were discussing “impeachment” en masse for the first time in a while, with at least four members of Congress using the word on Thursday and Friday — talk that will likely die down pending further investigation of the BuzzFeed account.

When the special counsel published its comment, Trump began retweeting takedowns of of BuzzFeed News. As New York’s Olivia Nuzzi noted, “Whatever ends up being the case about the BuzzFeed story, it sure is interesting to see the president and all of his supporters so eager to accept as fact the statement put out by the special counsel’s office.” In this case of rare camaraderie, it appears that the enemy of the “enemy of the people” is his friend.

Mueller Disputes Report That Trump Had Cohen Perjure Himself
russia investigation

Mueller Disputes BuzzFeed Report That Trump Ordered Cohen to Perjure Himself

An unexpected public statement from the special counsel. Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images

On Friday night, the special counsel issued a rare public statement, disputing the BuzzFeed News report that President Trump directed Michael Cohen to lie to Congress about plans to build a tower in Moscow. “BuzzFeed’s description of specific statements to the special counsel’s office, and characterization of documents and testimony obtained by this office, regarding Michael Cohen’s congressional testimony are not accurate,” said Peter Carr, spokesman for the Mueller investigation. It appears to be the first time the special counsel has publicly contested a news account, casting doubt on a major collusion break that had some Democrats talking potential obstruction of justice charges.

On Twitter, journalists weighed the details of the Mueller investigation’s decision to break radio silence and comment on the report — almost 24 hours after its initial publication in which they issued a “no comment.” Reporter Peter Sterne posed three possible options for the contention: There are minor inconsistencies in the report; it’s substantively incorrect; or it
correctly depicts what Cohen told federal prosecutors in a different office, like the Southern District of New York. Ronan Farrow, who broke the story of Trump’s alleged affair with Karen McDougal, tweeted that he “declined to run with parts of the narrative they conveyed based on a source central to the story repeatedly disputing the idea that Trump directly issued orders of that kind.” Additionally, the New York Times claims that a source “familiar with Mr. Cohen’s testimony to the special counsel’s prosecutors said that Mr. Cohen did not state that the president had pressured him to lie to Congress.” BuzzFeed editor-in-chief Ben Smith announced his confidence in his team’s reporting and requested that Mueller “make clear what he’s disputing.” On CNN, Smith also said that BuzzFeed was not “playing any games with the characterization” of their two federal law enforcement sources.

On Friday morning, House Intelligence chairman Adam Schiff announced that the committee was “already working to secure additional witness testimony and documents related to the Trump Tower Moscow deal and other investigative matters.” (As of publication, Schiff has not given a statement on the special counsel’s update.) Before the Mueller team’s surprise announcement, Democrats were discussing “impeachment” en masse for the first time in a while, with at least four members of Congress using the word on Thursday and Friday — talk that will likely die down pending further investigation of the BuzzFeed account.

When the special counsel published its comment, Trump began retweeting takedowns of of BuzzFeed News. As New York’s Olivia Nuzzi noted, “Whatever ends up being the case about the BuzzFeed story, it sure is interesting to see the president and all of his supporters so eager to accept as fact the statement put out by the special counsel’s office.” In this case of rare camaraderie, it appears that the enemy of the “enemy of the people” is his friend.

Mueller Disputes Report That Trump Had Cohen Perjure Himself

Things you buy through our links may earn New York a commission.

THE FEED
early and often
early and often
Letitia James’s Office Is Facing Its Own Sexual-Harassment Scandal
The New York attorney general has been accused of handling sexual-harassment claims against her chief of staff differently than those against Cuomo.
tremendous content
tremendous content
Trump Is Paying His Diet Coke Valet’s Legal Fees
The Feds see Walt Nauta as a key witness against Trump in the Mar-a-Lago classified-documents case. But it turns out their bond is the real thing.
early and often
early and often
It Looks Like the Supreme Court Will Not Blow Up Our Democracy (for Now)
A theory that would make state legislatures the ultimate decider of elections and overturn the Constitution as we know it gets its day in court.
early and often
early and often
Guess Where More of Trump’s Stolen Classified Documents Turned Up
Hint: they were located among “suits and swords and wrestling belts and all sorts of things.”
early and often
early and often
Will Biden’s Primary-Calendar Power Play Actually Work?
There are some obstacles in the road already, and the real implications of the new calendar may not be realized until 2028.
the far right
the far right
German QAnon Spinoff Plotted Coup to Put Fake Prince in Charge
Police arrested 25 people involved in an alleged plan to overthrow the government and install a disgraced aristocrat as head of state.
the sports section
the sports section
The Yankees Averted Disaster by Signing Aaron Judge
Baseball is entertainment, and Judge is an entertainer. The Yankees simply had to keep him.
early and often
early and often
Raphael Warnock Is the Exception in Georgia, Not the Rule
The pastor turned politician defied the odds again, but Georgia is still barely a purple state.
the city politic
the city politic
Meet New York’s New Republican Voters
Crime and schools are causing a political realignment in the city, led by communities of recent immigrants.
2022 midterms
2022 midterms
Herschel Walker Didn’t Just Lose; Raphael Warnock Won
Walker was indeed a bad Trump-recruited candidate. But Warnock ran a very impressive campaign once again.
tremendous content
tremendous content
Rudy Giuliani’s 5 Worst Excuses From His Attorney-Misconduct Hearing
The former mayor has offered several bold arguments for why his efforts to overturn the 2020 election shouldn’t cost him his D.C. law license.
exhibit a
exhibit a
The Trump Organization Was Convicted After a Truly Embarrassing Defense
Any lawyer would have a hard time convincing a jury of the company’s innocence, but these lawyers acted like buffoons.
the money game
the money game
5 Takeaways From Three Arrows Capital’s New York Bankruptcy Hearing
Su Zhu and Kyle Davies are surfing and painting in exile. Also dodging creditors and the law.
politics
politics
Brian Sicknick’s Family Snubs Mitch McConnell and Kevin McCarthy
Family members of a police officer who died following the attack on the Capitol refused to shake hands with Republican leaders at a medal ceremony .
poll position
poll position
What the Polls Say Today: It’s Warnock’s Race to Lose
Even polls that showed Herschel Walker leading in November now show Raphael Warnock slightly ahead.
whodunnit
whodunnit
Somebody Shot Up a Power Station in North Carolina
The identity and motives of the culprits remain a mystery as thousands struggle without electricity.
just asking questions
just asking questions
How Frighteningly Strong Meth Has Supercharged Homelessness
Journalist Sam Quinones on the radically transformed picture of drug addiction in America.
conservatism
conservatism
Why the GOP Will Lose Its War on ‘Woke Wall Street’
Republicans can’t accept that they dislike modern capitalism, so they’re blaming “ESG” instead.
volcanoes
volcanoes
Volcanoes Are So Hot Right Now
There have been some stunning eruptions at volcanoes on multiple continents in the past few days. No, the world isn’t ending.
early and often
early and often
Yes, Republicans Still Pose a Threat to Democracy
The 2022 results do not show that the GOP has given up on ruling without majority support whenever it can or must.
the future is now
the future is now
That AI Chatbot Wrote a Pretty Decent New York Article
Is this the end of journalism as we know it?
tremendous content
tremendous content
Donald Trump Cost Lara Trump Her Fox News Gig
Nepotism giveth, and nepotism taketh away.
the money game
the money game
Could Caroline Ellison Be Cutting a Deal With the Justice Department?
The former CEO of Alameda Research and Sam Bankman-Fried’s ex-girlfriend might have been spotted in Manhattan.
early and often
early and often
Pandemic Politics Hold Up Gazillion-Dollar Defense Bill
For 61 years, the two parties have agreed on an annual defense-policy bill. It could fail this year as Republicans bend to their anti-vaxx base.
tremendous content
tremendous content
The Donald Trump–Elon Musk Feud: A Complete History
After reinstating Trump’s Twitter account, Musk sided with the U.S. Constitution over the ex-president. Here’s the latest on their chaotic saga.