The rating scale of 0 to 100 reflects our editors’ appraisals of all the tangible and intangible factors that make a restaurant or bar great — or terrible — regardless of price.

Read more about the new ratings
82 Good

A posh old-school red-sauce joint for the monied, uptown set.

1621 Second Ave., New York, NY, 10028


Known For

The lowdown

That classic old-school restaurateur Elio Guaitolini passed from the scene a while back, but the clubby, boisterous, slightly maddening Second Avenue institution that he ran for so many years sails serenely on. Sure, the monied, “Page Six” clientele can seem pushy and entitled on crowded evenings, and the prices of the veal chops and platters of grilled calves’ liver and the many spaghettis on the menu (seven, at last count) border on madness, especially if you wander in off the street from another part of town. But if we had to choose one old standby joint in this red-sauce-mad part of town, a place where the room was always crowded and convivial in an old–New York uptown kind of way, where the food was reliable, and where the waiters barked out our name when we walked in the door and on occasion kept a regular table open in the corner of the room for special occasions, this would be the place.

Adam Platt

What you need to know

DrinksFull Bar

Noise LevelCivilized