Are Any of The Fancy New Boxed Mac and Cheeses Better Than Annie’s?

By , a senior kitchen and dining writer at the Strategist. Previously, she was an editor at Bon Appétit and has worked in food media for nine years.

Save this article to read it later.

Find this story in your account’s ‘Saved for Later’ section.

Photo: Emma Wartzman

Like jarred tomato sauce, boxed macaroni and cheese is a pantry staple. Whether you make it for your kids after a busy day at work or doctor it up with bacon and broccoli for a nostalgic, comforting dinner for yourself, it’s always there, and it’s always easy. But also like jarred tomato sauce, the market is pretty big, and many new options have come out in the last few years, soI was curious to find out if any in particular stood out as the best.

I wanted to start with a ubiquitous and time-tested brand in order to have a solid point of reference to compare some newer ones to. Kraft and Annie’s are both, in their own ways, that — and after polling my colleagues, it became clear allegiances are split. New York deputy editor Alexis Swerdloff put it well: “Kraft was probably the classic benchmark, but Annie’s has become that in the last decade or so.” As such, I decided to proceed with Annie’s and then call in a handful of others to taste-test alongside.

I went with a mix of orange cheddar and white cheddar versions, plus a couple made with Parmesan, and one more distinct outlier: the option closest to mac and cheese from Riff, a very new boxed pasta company by acclaimed chef Daniel Humm. It was a bit of a vibes-based curation, but I also put a few guardrails in place to keep things somewhat consistent. I didn’t test anything gluten-free (but that may be the subject of a future taste test); and despite the directions for some calling for low-fat milk and optional butter (presumably to keep the calorie count lower), I used whole milk and added butter for each (except one that specifically only has you use water and its powdered cheese mix).

I also called back senior editor Winnie Yang and senior writer Michael Zhao to taste with me. We considered real cheesiness level (or, on the other end of the spectrum, if it leaned processed-tasting), sauce texture, coating ability, pasta shape, and pasta texture. Below: our findings.

Our least favorites

Matheson Food Company Creamy Sharp Cheddar Macaroni and Cheese
Saved
View
Want to be emailed about sales and other updates to your saved products? Success! You'll get an email when something you've saved goes on sale.
Yes

New! You can now save this product for later.

Beyond his restaurants, cookbook writing, and acting, Matty Matheson also has a food company, which launched in 2023. It sells seasoning mixes, dressings, barbecue sauces, and boxed mac and cheeses. I was especially excited about this one, as it felt the coolest of the bunch (small thing, but I do love the packaging). We tried both the Sharp Cheddar and the cheddar-based Original (which isn’t available for purchase in the U.S. right now, so I’ll focus on the Sharp Cheddar). Unfortunately, to say it underdelivered is an understatement. (Wildly, I feel I must note up here that another flavor from the brand was one of our very favorites, but more on that below.) It was really the only macaroni and cheese that all three of us taste-testers had an immediate adverse response to — so much so that we could hardly go in for a second bite. To sum it up: Zhao noted that it tasted like plastic. (And in case the Original ever becomes available here, we also did not like that one — it had an overpowering mustard flavor.)

Photo: Emma Wartzman
Riff Creamy Parmesan Cavatappi
Saved
View
Want to be emailed about sales and other updates to your saved products? Success! You'll get an email when something you've saved goes on sale.
Yes

New! You can now save this product for later.

Riff is the aforementioned outlier. The company, founded by chef Daniel Humm, launched only a couple of months ago, and the lineup is boxed pastas more than boxed macaroni and cheeses. There’s Sesame Ginger Noodles, Coconut Curry Noodles, Spicy Tomato Rigatoni, Garlic Lemon Rotini, and this Creamy Parmesan Cavatappi — the closest to standard macaroni and cheese. In fact, it’s similar: dried pasta, to which you add a sauce made from milk, butter, and the included cheese-seasoning packet. (It does call for about three times as much milk as the other ones we tried, requiring more reduction once you marry all the ingredients together on the stovetop.) The major differences are that the pasta is full-size, and it comes with a small packet of breadcrumbs for sprinkling on top. The brand also explicitly encourages riffing — hence the name — by adding extra ingredients like mushrooms, lemon juice, and chopped parsley (though I would argue all boxed macaroni and cheeses are ripe for such additions).

We were a bit let down by this one. It was fine enough, which is to say not as immediately off-putting at the Matheson Company Sharp Cheddar (and we did all enjoy the provided breadcrumbs). But there were clearly dried alliums added to the seasoning mix, which tasted dominant, and took it into dehydrated soup mix territory. It lacked the bright, tangy cheesiness we were looking for.

Photo: Emma Wartzman

The ones we liked

Annie’s Organic Classic Cheddar Mac and Cheese
Saved
View
Want to be emailed about sales and other updates to your saved products? Success! You'll get an email when something you've saved goes on sale.
Yes

New! You can now save this product for later.

Annie’s Organic Shells & White Cheddar Mac and Cheese
Saved
View
Want to be emailed about sales and other updates to your saved products? Success! You'll get an email when something you've saved goes on sale.
Yes

New! You can now save this product for later.

Emma Wartzman.
Emma Wartzman.

Both Annie’s cheddar elbows and white cheddar shells were totally solid, and we had a slight preference towards the latter. Turns out, there’s a reason we used these as a benchmark. They’re both mild, if a little flat — but certainly completely inoffensive, and — in a good way — nostalgic-tasting. The sauce on these is on the looser side.

Goodles Cheddy Mac Creamy Cheddar and Macaroni
Saved
View
Want to be emailed about sales and other updates to your saved products? Success! You'll get an email when something you've saved goes on sale.
Yes

New! You can now save this product for later.

Goodles emerged on the scene in 2021 and has become pretty ubiquitous, given how new it is (while I wouldn’t say it’s as much so as Annie’s or Kraft, the reach is far). Its noodles have some added protein from ingredients like chickpeas (though with the exception of a few designated gluten-free varieties, they include wheat flour), and added nutrients extracted from foods like kale, sunflower seeds, and mushrooms. Surprisingly, you truly can’t tell. I was impressed with the taste and texture, which were comparable to regular noodles. (In the case of the elbows, they were a bit bigger in size than Annie’s, but nothing noticeable when taking bites.)

The cheddar elbows in particular are another unobjectionable pick that also tasted somewhat nostalgic, despite it being a newer brand. This one leans slightly tangier and a bit saltier than the Annie’s version, and the sauce is a bit thicker, too. While Yang had a slight preference for Annie’s (“though I honestly can’t quite figure out why,” she noted), both Zhao and I found them pretty interchangeable. We’d be happy to eat either, if a bit uninspired.

Photo: Emma Wartzman
Boss Cow Cheddar & Elbow Mac & Cheese
Saved
View
Want to be emailed about sales and other updates to your saved products? Success! You'll get an email when something you've saved goes on sale.
Yes

New! You can now save this product for later.

Boss Cow stands out in a couple of ways. The company touts their ingredients: unenriched organic durum wheat semolina past from Italy, dairy from regenerative family farms, and no preservatives. It’s also the only boxed macaroni and cheese we tried that has you make a sauce from just their cheese seasoning and water — no added milk or butter. I’m impressed by the better-for-you ingredients, and that the sauce method turned out truly creamy results. The sauce has a distinct tang — more so than any of the others we tried. Unfortunately, Yang and I both found that the initial hit of sauce slid off, such that we were left with distinct plain boiled noodle taste, bite after bite. Zhao, however, was more impressed: “You could sprinkle a crumb topping on it, throw it in the oven for 10 minutes, and no one would know it was coming from a box,” he said.

Photo: Emma Wartzman

The ones we loved

Goodles Shella Good Aged White Cheddar and Shells
Saved
View
Want to be emailed about sales and other updates to your saved products? Success! You'll get an email when something you've saved goes on sale.
Yes

New! You can now save this product for later.

Goodles’ white cheddar version stood out for a few reasons. We liked the shell pasta shape better than traditional elbows, thanks to their sauce-holding ability. This was true across the board, but the Goodles sauce also had a distinct cheese pull — I could see it in the pot as I stirred — that helped coat the noodles especially well. And crucially, the cheese taste here was especially clean, sharp, and savory, rather than being more vaguely dairy-like, as was the case with the milder Annie’s. Indeed, Yang said: “It tastes like a more elevated Annie’s.”

Photo: Emma Wartzman
Matheson Food Company Creamy Sharp Cheddar Macaroni and Cheese
Saved
View
Want to be emailed about sales and other updates to your saved products? Success! You'll get an email when something you've saved goes on sale.
Yes

New! You can now save this product for later.

We’ve come full circle with this one. Despite our overtly negative feelings about the Matheson Food Company sharp cheddar flavor, the Pep Pep Macaroni — basically a version of cacio e pepe — was distinctly delicious. Really, it was the very favorite of the bunch. Again, the real cheese flavor here played a big role. It actually tasted like Parmesan balanced by a subtle, warm background kick of black pepper. It kept us going in, bite after bite — not too spicy or overwhelming, but still distinct. I also liked the pasta shape (something I didn’t even have the pleasure of noticing with the other one): small and ditalini-like, a real pleasure to shovel into your mouth.

Photo: Emma Wartzman

Ingredients to enhance your macaroni and cheese

Burlap & Barrel Black Urfa Chili
Saved
View

New! You can now save this product for later.

$10

Carla Lalli’s favorite chili for a hit of subtle heat.

Fermín Iberico Chorizo
Saved
View

New! You can now save this product for later.

$26

Olivia Tiedemann blends this into breadcrumbs for a mac and cheese topping.

La Boîte Penja White Pepper
Saved
View

New! You can now save this product for later.

$16

Finish with Dan Barber’s white pepper.

More From The Strategist

See All

The Strategist is designed to surface useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Every product is independently selected by our team of editors, whom you can read about here. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Tags:

Are Any New Boxed Mac and Cheeses Better Than Annie’s? Your product is saved! You’ll receive emails when your saved products go on sale. Manage preferences.