November Testing Report: Heirloom-Quality Wool Blankets and Cotton-Cashmere Tees
The Strategist staff are in constant research mode — weighing products for Best in Class inclusion, finding the newest releases in their respective beats, and reassessing old favorites. We thought we’d let you behind the curtain a bit and share what we’ve been testing this month.
Vintage-feeling utility jeans
New! You can now save this product for later.
After recently sifting through Sorbara’s vintage military fatigues, I left the boutique wanting a utility bottom: something with large pockets and a wide, straight fit through the leg. It wasn’t a day later that I spotted this Buck Mason launch, and now I’m wearing them more than my previous go-to, the Citizen of Humanity Aylas. The Dungarees (aptly named for their inspiration, 1940s naval dungarees) have patch pockets, a lived-in wash, contrast seams, and a black-button fly. They’re made of 100 percent Japanese cotton denim that loosens with wear. The 29-inch inseam hits the top of my foot and their mid-rise makes them comfortable to wear all day. I especially love the straight and wide (but not flare or barrel) drape through the legs. —Najwa Jamal, updates coordinator
Lands’ End tote, but different
New! You can now save this product for later.
Since I came out as a fan of Lands’ End over L.L.Bean, I’ve become increasingly interested in canvas totes more generally. Lately I’ve been carrying this two-toned one from Steele, which reminds me of the vintage colorways both brands have carried at different points. It’s incredibly sturdy and carries a lot, like my medium L.L.Bean totes. I’ve been asked about it at least a handful of times since I started carrying it around. Most recently, Erika Veurink stopped me after an event to snap a photo of it. She’s a bag fan, so it felt like a stamp of approval. —Tembe Denton-Hurst, writer
A cotton-cashmere tee
New! You can now save this product for later.
Just as I’ve busted out my Brooklinen cotton-cashmere sheets for the cooler weather, I also got a new white tee from Merz b. Schwanen in the same fabrication. It’s a blend of 70 percent cotton and 30 percent cashmere and is, predictably, very soft. The fit is also on the relaxed side of things, which I prefer these days over a structured tee. I’ve also grown extremely fond of the little swan on the logo sewn at the hem. When it comes to a basic white tee, it really is all about the little things. —Dominique Pariso, senior writer
The newest iPhone (Duo)
New! You can now save this product for later.
iPhone Duo
Am I an iPhone Duo guy? After two weeks with this thing, I’m still not sure. I’ve learned that I enjoy reading articles and powering through my inbox on the large, matte inner screen when fully opened. But it’s not quite enough to offset the annoyance I feel at its lack of Face ID and how heavy it feels in my pocket. On the other hand, I’ve become a lot more comfortable leaving the house without my heavy laptop because the bigger screen makes doing an emergency Google docs edit a lot more tolerable — even if the app isn’t optimized for the Duo screen and I’m still getting used to typing on the weirdly big keyboard. It’s simultaneously more useful and annoying than I thought it would be. I neither love nor hate it. But perhaps that balance will shift once more apps are optimized for the big screen. —Michael Zhao, senior writer
Peelproof phone case
New! You can now save this product for later.
Earlier this year, my silicone Apple iPhone case started to peel in the exact manner that my colleague Michael Zhao described. I was on the verge of getting an OtterBox on his recommendation but decided instead to test out a new-to-me brand, Rhinoshield. The brand promises a lifetime anti-yellowing guarantee on its ClearX cases, which was a problem I’d encountered previously with a cheap transparent case I’d bought on Etsy — it turned into an unsightly, discolored yellow after just a couple months. So far, so good: It’s been nearly six months with the Rhinoshield, and the case is just as clear as the day I put it on. Plus it’s sleek, slim, and very durable — I’ve dropped it a fair few times, and there’s barely any scratches on it and zero hint of peeling or cracking. —Kitty Guo, writer
Worth-it shearling boots
New! You can now save this product for later.
These feel like my favorite shearling-lined Diane B. boots on steroids. They are extremely comfortable and cozy, with a shaft that comes halfway up my knee (no small feat for someone who is five-eight and who often finds “tall” boots don’t hit as high as I’d like them to). The shearling is luxurious and toasty, and I love that you can fold the boot down if you want more of a Dr. Zhivago look. I also appreciate that the sole is thick and grippy, which I imagine will stand up well to icy sidewalks this winter. Yes, the price point is a bit steep, but the quality is absolutely there, and they would make an excellent gift for the person who already has too many shearling hats and fur collars. —Hilary Reid, senior editor
Portable chapped lip (and skin) solution
New! You can now save this product for later.
After using tretinoin for the past four years, my lips and chin are especially prone to flaking and redness in cold months. I’m wearing Lip Grease as I write this, as I have been for the last three weeks. This clear, peppermint-y formula is indeed greasy, but in a good way, plush and buttery without being sticky like a gloss. It’s made with lanolin, moisturizing oils like jojoba and kukui, and vitamin C. I love the chubby stick application, and when the sheen has worn off, my lips still feel supple. The brand is Toronto-based, so I trust that they know cold. The formula was created by a mother-daughter duo, the latter of whom struggled with Accutane-related dryness, so I feel safe dabbing a bit on my own dry skin. They’re releasing new tinted ones soon, which I’m excited to try. —N.J.
The halter bra you can work out in
New! You can now save this product for later.
Up until now I’ve been skeptical about halters as workout tops, because they seem to sacrifice function for fashion. But this Splits59 one proved me wrong. I recently tested a set from the L.A.-based brand at a sweltering CorePower yoga class. The top fit snugly on my smaller chest (something difficult for me to find in the past), and I actually appreciated the comfortable cut (less tugging on my shoulders like with a normal sports bra). It didn’t move around or roll up either, even during sweat-drenched vinyasas. —Arielle Avila, writer
Eye-catching sherpa
New! You can now save this product for later.
The first time I noticed Splits59’s activewear was at the old Bandier store on Madison (RIP), but I’d never tried anything from the brand until this fleece, which I’ve been wearing at least three times a week since it arrived. It’s just so good! The “sherpa” has a nice heft to it that keeps me warm and gives the jacket a flattering shape, the brown-and-black color combo makes it easier to wear with my other fall clothes, and the quilting by the shoulders makes it look a little dressier than other fleeces I own. I even noticed a particularly chic doctor of mine eyeing it the last time I was at her office, which I took to be a good sign. —H.R.
A bevy of mesh maternity dresses …
My current maternity wardrobe is almost entirely these three dresses. Even pre-pregnancy, I was a huge fan of wearing mesh, so I’ve been adamant about incorporating it into my pregnancy to try to feel like myself and stay true to my style. It has been the absolute best fabric for staying comfortable and showing off my growing bump. Both the Ingrid & Isabel and Hatch styles are true maternity wear and have extra fabric in the waist. Since I’m four-foot-11, I was a little unsure about their lengths, but their midi lengths hit me perfectly at the ankle. I also tried this Banana Republic dress in petite, which fits true to size and stretches to fit my bump. Throw on an oversized sweater over either of them and voila, the perfect fall and winter outfit. —Ashley Wolfgang, newsletter editor
… and maternity activewear
New! You can now save this product for later.
I’m now 24 weeks pregnant and I’m trying to embrace my newfound energy by scheduling some regular workouts again. A lot of my pre-pregnancy athleisure were starting to feel a little tight, so I called some things in from Beyond Yoga’s maternity line to test. These leggings are extremely soft and the extra-long waist helped support my bump during the Soulcycle and prenatal Bar Method classes I took last weekend. I wore it with this maternity long-sleeve. Both were so comfortable I kept them on during my post-workout naps. —A.W.
A reading playkit …
New! You can now save this product for later.
As with so many of Lovevery’s sets, this is nicely designed and well made. The activities and games are eye-catching enough to get my 3.5-year-old’s attention and make him interested in playing. I do wish the instructions for each of the activities were easier to locate and parse in the very small window of time I have his attention, but the games are open-ended enough that you can use the booklet as a jumping-off point. I can definitely credit the activities with getting him to figure out how to break words up into syllables (great) and to speak now mostly in rhymes (initially great but increasingly tiresome over time). —Winnie Yang, senior editor
… screen-free, rechargeable children’s books …
New! You can now save this product for later.
Cali Reader
Cali Reader is a rechargeable read-aloud book that’s designed to encourage early reading skills. The reader comes with one story book insert and works with a host of other inserts, from The Jungle Book to Winnie the Pooh, that are sold separately. At the end of each story, the inserts have games and activities based what they just heard. And if you want, through the app you can read (and record) any of the stories aloud so that your kid can hear your voice instead of the included one. I still have a lot of playing around to do, but my son is already a big fan and loves pressing the play buttons on each page to keep the story going. I like that the stories have original illustrations that are different from the Disney ones, so he gets to experience the stories in a new way. —Liza Corsillo, senior writer
… and a snap-and-speak camera toy
New! You can now save this product for later.
This is maybe the first use of AI in a toy that I’ve found compelling. Dex is billed as a language-discovery camera ages 3 and up, and we’ve mainly been using it that way. With its onboard camera app, when you take a picture of an object, it’ll say the name of the object in one of the 16 languages you’ve designated in the accompanying app, and then Dex has you repeat the name before you can take your next picture. Both my almost-11-year-old and 3.5-year-old have been enjoying running around the apartment taking pictures and then saying words in Mandarin and Spanish, respectively (the scavenger-hunt mode helps by giving them a prompt, like “Look for something green”). You can set the proficiency level, from single word to full sentences in the second language, but I wish there were a way to create multiple profiles (you can manually switch between users, which requires reentering all the settings). There are other apps built in too, like a storytelling one that uses information you provide (child’s name, interests to make a custom narrative tailored to what they’re into). In our limited testing, the creators have done a pretty good job with guardrails; when the fifth-grader took a picture of underwear, Dex said something along the lines of, “This looks like something for grown-ups.” As for privacy, the device does not retain any photos or audio recordings. As a supplement for language learning, it’s pretty effective, and it’s well-designed also and fits perfectly in a little hand. —W.Y.
How our dining writer caffeinates
New! You can now save this product for later.
Breville introduced this coffee maker last month and came by the office to do a demo. The handful of Strategist staffers in attendance were impressed with the functionality and the taste of the coffee. Since then, they sent me one to try out in my own house. It is — at least as far as I can tell — a pretty one-of-a-kind appliance, an automatic machine that doses and grinds your coffee beans, and then makes pour over. There’s a little spout that mimics the motion of a hand moving around and around while dispensing water from a gooseneck kettle. I’ve only used it a couple of times so far, but it’s quite intuitive (with the option to really dial in your coffee preferences if you’re someone who likes to nerd out, versus someone who likes to set it for good, press one button, and be done). —Emma Wartzman, senior writer
A sleepy teatime boost
New! You can now save this product for later.
Elix Yin Time
Because I work East Coast hours on the West Coast, I’m usually up by 5 a.m. Over the summer, my bedtime got later and later, and I’m doing everything I can to get it back to baseline (before 11 p.m.). Melatonin and a lot of other sleep aids make me groggy the morning after, but I finally found something that’s effective without those side effects. I’ve been enjoying a cup of chamomile tea with a dropper of this herbal blend to end my night. It winds me down, and within an hour I’m blissfully passed out without any next-day drowsy side effects. —A.A.
Noise-canceling wired headphones
New! You can now save this product for later.
While testing what I like to call “fashion earbuds,” a.k.a. colorful and chrome-wired headphones, I found myself missing the noise cancellation I’d come to take for granted in my AirPods. It’s the feature that often allowed me to transcend to the magical state of “deep focus,” and without it, the sirens and honks that go along with city life often pulled my attention away from my laptop. Bose’s new noise-canceling headphones solve that problem without compromising on the nostalgic wired-headphones aesthetic. They have some of the most impressive sound quality of the wired buds I tested (no tinniness or muddy choruses in my favorite song, “the lakes” by Taylor Swift). The noise cancellation is impressive — I’m oblivious to all city noises while wearing them — and there’s also an “aware” setting for moments that don’t require focus. As someone who regularly worries about headphones falling out, I also appreciate that these come with multiple ear-tip sizes and “stability wings,” which keep the buds in place. —Bella Druckman, writer
A luxe hosting poof
New! You can now save this product for later.
Hati Home is a California-based furniture company. I went to their fall preview a few weeks ago to see some of their larger pieces, like dining tables and chairs and counter stools, all of which is really gorgeous if you happen to be in the market for such items. They also sent me this pouf, which I set up in my living room. I’m constantly trying to maximize how many people can comfortably hang out in there while still keeping things tidy and intentional, and this is a real winner in that regard. It’s pricey, but the wood and velvet are both top-quality, and it looks extremely nice. —E.W.
Living-room stool for your cat
New! You can now save this product for later.
I love the idea of furniture pieces that can double as something functional for both me and my cats, so I was very intrigued by this little stool/nook when I saw it while browsing TheMeowPicks website (a fantastic place to look for fun and stylish cat stuff, if you’re in the market). I’ve been using it for a few weeks and I quite like it. I have a mid-century wingback chair that I felt could benefit from a leg rest, but I don’t have a ton of space in my 1920s-era living room, so this little stool is perfect to tuck away when it’s not in use. And I love that when I’m not using it as a stool, it can be a little hidey-hole for a cat. One of my cats in particular loves to find a little hiding spot, and I’ve loved seeing him curl up inside this stool. I also love that it shipped fully assembled, so all I had to do was take it out of the box and place it in my living room. —Amelia Jerden, writer
A new oral-care routine
New! You can now save this product for later.
New! You can now save this product for later.
I received a gift bag with wellness and beauty products from a bunch of different brands during New York Fashion Week, and Boka’s oral care is one of the few things I’m still using two months later. The toothpaste’s mint flavor is subtle and sophisticated (nothing like the big-brand mint toothpastes that punch you in the mouth), and the nano-hydroxyapatite-enriched formula leaves my teeth feeling slick. And yes, I know that I’m very late to the tongue-scraping trend — I didn’t actually think I’d make it a habit, but the feeling of metal scraping my mouth gunk away is oddly satisfying. —Laura Gurfein, managing editor
Nice-looking washable rug
New! You can now save this product for later.
Revival Rugs Mori - 8' x 10'
This is the first test subject in my hunt for a washable rug that doesn’t look like a washable rug. My hope is that I will find something I can throw in the washing machine that isn’t made of 100 percent synthetic materials and that looks plush and feels luxurious underfoot. I have owned other Revival rugs in the past and been very happy with them. So far, this rug has been great. It’s very soft, and the colors are nice and calming to look at. I haven’t washed it yet, but I did spot-clean it after my son drew on it with a dry-erase marker. I used my favorite Sonnet bar soap, and the marker totally came out. I vacuum it every other day or so and so far, it’s holding up well. —L.C.
Heirloom wool blanket
New! You can now save this product for later.
I’m obsessed with this pink blanket that’s made from 100 percent wool – the real-deal, old-school, slightly scratchy kind (but definitely still soft and not at all itchy). I’ve been layering it on top of my down comforter for the past month and a half and haven’t overheated at all, which I attribute to the breathability of the blanket’s natural fibers. Made in the USA in one of the country’s oldest mills, it reminds me of the wool blankets I used growing up that were inherited from my grandparents. And I can totally see myself handing it down to the next generation. —Katherine Gillespie, writer
Orange-light floor lamp
New! You can now save this product for later.
I’ve long been searching for an arching lamp that would brighten up the darkest corner of my living room. I’ve almost purchased Ikea’s Skottorp lamp several times, but it just never quite felt right for my space. This warm lamp from up-and-coming lighting brand Lucy’s Lamps was exactly what I was looking for, though: It’s warm in that orange way that’s so popular in the city right now, and fits perfectly in a dark corner. The lamp head itself can rotate left, right, up, and down, so I can point it wherever I please. It adds such a pleasant glow to my apartment that a delivery man complimented it the other day. —B.D.
[Editor’s note: This lamp is currently on preorder, with shipping set to start on November 23.]
Gua sha that does it all (but shouldn’t)
New! You can now save this product for later.
I do both gua sha and red light as part of my skin-care routine, but I recently was gifted this Mount Lai LED gua sha device that combines the two. There’s also some sculpting rollers attached and a heated element that does admittedly feel nicer than cold stone on your face. Still, it just seems a bit over-engineered, a classic case where stuffing a bunch of functionalities into one product isn’t necessarily better than a product that just does one thing very well. I’ll probably be sticking with my normal jade gua sha and red-light mask, but I could see it being a nice, luxe gift for a skin-care lover. —K.G.
Ultralight carry-on
New! You can now save this product for later.
Peak Design’s slimmed-down hard-shell rollerboard carry-on is indeed lightweight and compact, as the name suggests. I took it on a recent four-day trip to Naples, Italy, and while it doesn’t look as big as our other carry-ons, it had plenty of room for all the clothes I needed plus an extra pair of shoes, with some space left over for souvenirs. It’s also well-compartmentalized, and easy to keep your things organized and in place. The cobblestones in Naples would be annoying to traverse with any rolling luggage, but this bag’s wheels handled them fine — and when I couldn’t handle all the noise and juddering anymore, the Roller Lite was light enough for me to just pick up by the handle and carry. A big plus: Many of its parts, including the handles and casters, are replaceable. —W.Y.
More From The Strategist
- Every Holiday Gift Guide From the Strategist (So Far)
- The Best Advent Calendars This Year (So Far)
- The Best Things Strategist Editors Have Bought This Year (So Far)
- 63 Things You Should Never Buy Full Price
The Strategist is designed to surface useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Every product is independently selected by our team of editors, whom you can read about here. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.