4 Ways I’d Organize Sentimental Clutter
What do you do with the gifted tchotchkes, the ticket stubs, the old journals from elementary school, the years and years of kid art? Sentimental clutter is a type of mess that is “radioactive, delightful, too immersive to approach,” as one respondent describes it — it symbolizes something you love, so you can’t just throw it away. Attempt to organize it and you’ll get sucked into a nostalgia vortex, and it’s immune to the pragmatic calculus of clearing out a junk drawer or medicine cabinet.
The first step with sentimental clutter is to acknowledge what it means to you. If these objects are sacred, treat them as such. These are items in your archive; if there were a museum exhibition about your life, they’d be on display. Keep anything in circulation that can still be useful — use that art-class pinch pot to store your keys! — but if the function is purely sentimental, find a place to store them that is safe and accessible. Below are my solutions for four different sentimental-clutter puzzles.
Kid ceramics taking over the dining room
Primary complaint: “My 8-year-old has been taking a weekly pottery class for three years and has amassed more kiln-fired work than I can handle. This is the top of the buffet in our dining room, and there’s also a big storage tub of things wrapped in newspaper and labeled with the year she made it. We need some sort of display situation that I have not hit on yet.”
Sprawl up, not out.
What a fantastic collection. The first thing I‘d say is to find a purpose for anything functional — use the trays and coil pots to store jewelry, hairpins, salt in the kitchen, et cetera. Then reclaim some buffet real estate by arranging things vertically. One quick way to do this is to prop up anything flat on a display stand. I’ve linked three options below, ranging from less to more robust — acrylic for smaller pieces, wood and metal wire for the heavier stuff.
You can also build upward with a tiered tray. I’m assuming a kid curator might be making adjustments to the display, so I’d recommend something with a lip to avoid ceramics tumbling off. Cupcake stands are about the right dimensions and usually have a shallow lip.
If there’s space for it, a corner shelf could serve as an extra display area for larger pieces. I love the spindle detail on this one; it could hold a few prized items that rotate in and out and looks adult enough to adapt to changing uses.
New! You can now save this product for later.
Childhood journals getting musty in the basement
Primary complaint: “I have two bins of childhood journals that have been stressing me out for years. They definitely smell a little musty; I have a finished basement, but turns out it’s still a basement. I’d like them to be properly stored, but I don’t need them organized because I’d rather not have to go through everything.”
Use these bins from the Container Store.
I have the exact solution to this problem — weathertight storage bins from the Container Store. Before testing them myself, they were recommended by a professional organizer who described them as “by far one of the most durable on the market.” The lid has a foam seal that keeps air and moisture out. While working on this article, I walked up to the attic and cracked open my weathertight bin full of mementos for the first time in years to give it a sniff. No mustiness at all.
New! You can now save this product for later.
When storing things that feel too emotionally charged to open in the moment, labeling helps — it lowers the psychological barrier when you do finally feel like diving in. An unlabeled storage bin is a jack-in-the-box where something can pop out and surprise you; the label gives you some degree of control over what you’re getting into.
New! You can now save this product for later.
New! You can now save this product for later.
Sentimental T-shirts that never get worn
Primary complaint: “I have several boxes and folders of crap; I can never throw a letter or card away. The worst, though, is the T-shirts. The right side is what I call my ‘couldn’t possibly’ pile where I don’t even wear them to sleep but they have sentimental value. A book would be cool; I don’t want a quilt, and I don’t really want them on my wall.”
Use an archival box to make a T-shirt book.
I really puzzled over this one — how can you get T-shirts into a book without requiring a ton of work to mount each one individually? I was on a wild goose chase looking at XXL scrapbooks when I stumbled on the archival boxes below, which have the thick spine of a three-ring binder and the closed sides of a box. If you fold up the T-shirts and use binder clips to connect them to the metal spine, you end up with a booklike storage solution with the T-shirts as the “pages.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
New! You can now save this product for later.
Here’s a pack of binder clips to attach the T-shirts to the central rings (you only need to use one side of the clip; pinch the other to remove it). If you want to get really crafty, you can use a corrugated board to stiffen each T-shirt. I’ve linked an archival one below, but an old cardboard box would work as well.
New! You can now save this product for later.
New! You can now save this product for later.
Talas Heritage Archival Corrugated Board
A collection of “clutterboxes”
One respondent sent in an account of her collections across a range of “clutterboxes,” which contain earrings, Arctic fox teeth, worry dolls, “random chunks of amber,” and owl feathers. To me, this is a perfect solution: giving each tiny collection a special home.
“Can you call them jewelry boxes if they are not for any active jewelry closet and mostly earrings you got as a teen that you can’t bear to part with? A solution I wish I had time for: Bode Lorde Met Gala dress where I sew all the tiny things to a garment to jingle-jangle.”
The containers are “mainly inherited from my tchotchke-loving mother,” but they also recommended Etsy as a good source. Below are some clutterboxes to house your collections; try searching for “pewter box,” “Bakelite box,” and “trinket box.”
More tools for organizing sentimental clutter
New! You can now save this product for later.
The archival document storage bins I use to organize old journals.
New! You can now save this product for later.
Sturdy ornament organizers that could be repurposed for other small knickknacks.
New! You can now save this product for later.
Sticky gel to anchor delicate items.
More From The Strategist
- Every Holiday Gift Guide From the Strategist (So Far)
- The Best Advent Calendars This Year (So Far)
- The Best Things Strategist Editors Have Bought This Year (So Far)
- 63 Things You Should Never Buy Full Price
The Strategist is designed to surface useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Every product is independently selected by our team of editors, whom you can read about here. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.