people's choice

The Best Christmas Pajamas on Amazon, According to Hyperenthusiastic Reviewers

Photo: Courtesy of MGM

Here at the Strategist, we like to think of ourselves as crazy (in the good way) about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed products and single out the most convincing. We’ve covered the best artificial Christmas trees, Christmas tree toppers, Christmas lights, and wrapping paper, now we’re zeroing in on the best Christmas pajamas on Amazon. (Note that reviews have been edited for length and clarity.)

Best Christmas Pajamas for Women

$21

“So nice and soft! I was expecting it to be of cheap quality because it was so inexpensive, but it’s actually really nicely made. I bought a XXL because I’m a size 16 to 18, and I felt it would run small, but it’s huge. I could have easily gotten an XL. I’m going to keep it though; it’ll just be super roomy. Cute pattern, too. Highly recommend these pajamas.”

“These pj’s are SO comfortable! They are smooth, light, and breathable. I absolutely love them. The sizing is perfect. I’m five-foot-five and about 165 pounds, and I bought a size medium. They fit perfectly with just the right amount of roominess, so buy your true size. These are the most comfortable pj’s I’ve owned, and they are nicely constructed and well-made, so they look nice, too. These are a must-buy!”

“I am extremely happy with these pajamas, but unless you want them to shrink, wash them in cold water and dry on medium or low heat (or hang dry). I am only five-foot-two and intentionally dried the pajamas on ‘regular’ heat so they’d be a little shorter. When the sleeves and pant legs shrunk two inches (no kidding), I was delighted that I did not need to hem them! But if you are of average or tall height, take care in washing and drying. That being said, I am extremely happy with these cute and cozy pajamas and am thinking of buying a second pair!”

Best Christmas Pajamas for Men

$13

“I’m six feet tall, 198 pounds. The large fit perfectly, about one inch over the top of my foot. It was snug but not too tight. Lightweight flannel, not heavy like one would get in sweat pants. This is good for cool weather.”

“Great size description from the company. My boyfriend is six-foot-five, 275 pounds, and the 2 XL fits great. They are roomy enough that he’s comfortable laying around. His feet are size 12, and these have a lot of room left in the feet. They have deep pockets, zip back flap, and are SUPER soft. SO cute, such a great gift to get him! And now I can keep the house as cold as I want and he can stay warm.”

Alexander Del Rossa Mens Plaid Flannel Pajamas
From $37

“Great product, very comfortable. Nice and warm, great price, substantial material. Very happy with these. Can’t say enough good things about them. I’m not a connoisseur of flannel pajamas, but I’ve owned five sets over the past several years. These ones are substantial, not thin. They have some nice weight to them, and are very comfortable to walk and sleep and sit in. These wear beautifully well, no problems at all, they just float, do not twist, don’t bunch up, don’t crawl up your legs in your sleep.”

Best Christmas Pajamas for Boys

“They’re soft and stretchy; my son loved them! The material is nice and the design is super cute, better than I expected! He’s a size five, ordered a size five and thought they fit great.”

$15

“They are by far my absolute favorite pajamas I have gotten for my boys! They are true to size, the quality of the fabric is so soft, and all in all, ​these are so well-made!”