As days get shorter and temperatures cool, it’s also time (eek) to start thinking about going back to school. To help you get a jump on the best school (and school-related) supplies to buy for fall, we’re running a series called Cool School Stuff, in which we’ll sniff out the best backpacks, best dorm décor, and best bento boxes, among many, many other things.
When we wear our backpacks, we’re usually thinking about what looks good with our slubby T-shirts and thoughtfully considered jeans (this one, if you’re wondering). But students from elementary school through college are carrying their whole lives around, so to determine the best backpacks for students (and their backs), we turned to Dr. Scott Bautch of the American Chiropractic Association, who gave us a few things to look for.
What’s the first thing you’d say to parents buying backpacks?
Go for as small a backpack as you can, because the student will likely overpack it. For a younger student 12 years and under, any more than 10 percent of their body weight (so if they’re 100 pounds, that’s 10 pounds) is going to break down the posture and affect the gait, so if you can get a smaller backpack, do.
Anything to look for with shoulder straps?
It should be wide (at least three finger widths) and S-shaped, meaning it curves out away from the neck and then back along the chest in this comfortable S-shape. If it goes straight up and down, it can be very uncomfortable. A padded nylon material that won’t cause you to sweat is important, too.
What about the interior?
I like backpacks that help you intuitively pack, so the heavier items are closer to the body. So, for instance, the laptop sleeve should be right on the back of the bag, against the back. Lighter items should go in smaller compartments on the exterior. I’m not a fan of any backpack that is just a giant open compartment.
That “10 percent of weight” rule seems hard to follow. Any way to safely pack more?
You can get backpacks that distribute weight against the hips now, with hip pads and beltlike straps — almost like a hiking backpack — that will allow you to put far less strain on a child’s and even an adult’s shoulders. Look for those.
What’s the biggest mistake you can make when buying a backpack?
Don’t prioritize fashion over function. There are certainly backpacks that look great and feel great, so don’t create musculoskeletal problems by choosing a stylish but uncomfortable day pack. Also, children grow and change, so don’t be wedded to a backpack or, worse, buy a huge backpack for your child to grow into. Parents will always say they want a backpack that lasts for years, but that’s the worst thing you can do.
Dr. Bautch’s favorite backpacks
“I actually consulted on this backpack. You can see it has the ergonomic shoulder straps and hip loops on it to distribute weight more evenly. I also think it’s important that the North Face looked at every aspect of the environment to create a sustainable day pack.”
“These are from a new company called MoonRock (based in Hong Kong), and it’s specially designed for under-12 students. They’ve done a great job of everything we’ve talked about — thick and comfortable shoulder straps and hip padding. One of my favorite backpacks I’ve seen in a long time. Note that the prices on the site are in Hong Kong dollars (roughly $88).”
“Go to the higher-end athletic stores, and you can find great ergonomic backpacks with hip pads and padded shoulder straps for kids.”
“You can see the hip pads on this backpack, which will help distribute the weight onto the hip area, rather than burdening your shoulders with it the whole time. This would be great for college students.”
“From the more mainstream brands, you’ll have to look a little harder, but JanSport makes a backpack for older students with that S-strap and hip belt, too.”
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.