My Chew-Happy Dog Cannot Quit This Rubber Ball

By
My friend’s Shih Tzu first introduced it to us.

When we went to meet (and ultimately take home) our rescue mini-schnauzer mix Reggie a year and a half ago, we took four things with us: a collar and leash, a small plush hedgehog, and this weblike rubber ball. The plush hedgehog is now a flat hedgehog — like most dogs, Reggie takes great pride in disemboweling his stuffed toys — and the leash and collar are a little worse for wear, but the Hol-ee Roller rubber ball is still going strong. In fact, it looks pretty much new.

That’s not because Reggie doesn’t like it. It’s actually his favorite. I’ve spoiled our dog with more toys than I care to admit, but he regularly trots up to me with the Hol-ee Roller for a game of fetch. I’d learned about the ball from friends we’d dog-sat for; their two Shih Tzus were always dropped off with one apiece. Yes, two dogs, two toys. It was easy to see why the pups didn’t want to share: The Hol-ee Roller is a hybrid bouncy ball and chew toy, with big holes that make it easy for smaller mouths to catch and grip and fling about. The rubber is durable but not inflexibly hard, so errant tosses aren’t a breaking hazard, and the ball’s squishiness absorbs its own noise and shock, which is nice news for your downstairs neighbor.

I wouldn’t recommend the Hol-ee Roller for large, destructive chewers, but it’s pretty perfect for small and medium-ish dogs like the ones you’ll find in apartments all over the city. You can even fill it with treats as a fun puzzle for your pup, though Reggie’s perfectly happy chasing it in its empty state around our — sorry, his — home.

JW Pet Hol-ee Roller Dog Toy, Mini and Medium
From $6, Amazon
JW Pet Hol-ee Roller Dog Toy, Small
$6, Jet

Other toys my dog loves

Kong Wubba Friend Dog Toy
$16, Amazon

I read about this strange mammal-cephalopod hybrid toy during Fugly Week and immediately bought it to see if Reggie would also take to it like crazy. He did. The combination of plush animal head, ball-shaped body (with wake-the-dead squeaker inside) and dangly, flappy limbs is dog magic, and when he’s not flinging his foxtopus (and buntopus) about he’s using it as a pillow.

Outward Hound FireHose Squeak N’ Fetch Dog Toy
From $6, Amazon

I learned about this chew toy, made from real fire hose, through a friend with a Labradoodle. It’s not indestructible, but it is very tough — Reggie eventually managed to chew it open, but only after a year of working on it almost daily.

Kong Classic Dog Toy
From $8, Amazon

A classic. We fill these with peanut butter, freeze them, and give them to our dog as a snack or to keep him busy when we leave the apartment. I read somewhere that it’s good to size up so that your dog can fit his snout in the hole easier and doesn’t abandon the toy in frustration.

Otterly Pets Rope Toys
$10, Amazon

Cheap and good for doggy teeth — the fibers clean and floss their teeth as they chew.

Multipet Mr. Bill Plush Dog Toy
$7, Amazon

This one was more for me than Reggie, because I get a kick every time he chomps down on Mr. Bill and Mr. Bill exclaims “Oh Noooooooooo!” Given that there’s a battery inside, I wouldn’t leave this toy alone with a serious chewer, but otherwise it’s worth it to pretend that your dog is the star of his own classic SNL bit.

Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel and Puzzle Plush
From $20, Amazon

We got this as a gift from a friend who has her own (and their dog is nuts for it). I recently bought the “gigantic” version for him and it’s been 20 bucks very well spent — he spends hours pulling the squirrels from their tree and hiding them around the house for me to find like Easter eggs.

KONG Cozies Dog Squeaky Toy
$8, Amazon

Will this get torn apart? Probably. Is it also really soft, cuddly, and available in a bunch of charming color and animal combinations? Definitely.

Chuckit! Ultra Ball
From $8, Amazon

Every Labrador (or Labrador-sized dog) I know has a Chuckit and a collection of these durable rubber balls, and Reggie goes nuts for the petite version. Unlike tennis balls, there’s no felt for dogs to tear off and eat and you can easily rinse off dirt and slobber.

Chuckit! Indoor Ball
$3, Amazon

There’s also an indoor version of the Chuckit’s rubber balls that I’ve seen in the apartments of many of Reggie’s dog friends.

Chuckit! Launcher
From $10, Amazon

If you really want to let it fly, there’s the Chuckit ball launcher, which feels like a requisite for any dog that needs tiring out (all dogs).

StarMark Treat Dispensing Chew Ball
From $5, Amazon

My friend has this for his extremely food-motivated terrier mix. He instructs her to “go get the green ball,” and she brings it to him to be filled with treats. It keeps her busy for hours.

Outward Hound Hedgehogz Squeak and Grunt Plush Dog Toy
From $6, Amazon

I don’t know why but dogs especially seem to love plush hedgehogs — every dog I know (and I know a lot) seems to have a hedgehog toy. And if they don’t, you should gift them one. They’ll like it a lot, and even after they rip the stuffing out they’ll still want to play with it. We call ours Reggie’s hedgie.

HDP Kong Flyer
From $12, Amazon

Another great toy for a dog who likes to run and chase things, made of the same durable (but easy on gums and teeth) rubber as the Kong toy above. And unlike humans, dogs won’t judge you for your inability to correctly throw a Frisbee.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

My Chew-Happy Dog Cannot Quit This Rubber Ball