ask a cool person

What Are the Best Men’s Crewneck Sweatshirts?

Photo-Illustration: retailers

The humble crewneck sweatshirt has come a long way from its reputation as a shvitz-soaked garment for working out. Today, crewneck sweatshirts are as much a wardrobe staple for work (both at home and in offices), as they are for working out or even dining out. Their rounded necks make them especially practical for layering, whether in winter (for obvious reasons) or in warmer months, when it’s not quite cold enough to put on your heaviest turtleneck, but you still want something to throw on over a T-shirt or Oxford shirt. To find the best crewneck sweatshirts, we talked to 17 guys about their favorites. Given that all look more or less the same (save for variations in color or pattern or fabric), we’ve sorted their recommendations by price, given that some folks may prefer to stick to budget friendly basics, while others may want to invest in a sweatshirt made with finer materials. Each category below is also organized to lead with the styles that got the most recommendations.

Best under-$50 men’s crewneck sweatshirts

As we did when reporting on cool men’s favorite underwear, socks, and T-shirts, in putting this story together, we learned that Uniqlo makes a solid crewneck sweatshirt, too. (And we should note we are not just asking the same people over and over again, either.) Andrew Favorito, who works in public relations for skin-care brand Tatcha, says the brand’s basic long-sleeve sweatshirt combines “Japanese simplicity and design, high-quality fabrics, a towel-soft terry cloth interior, and a dye that can withstand 19571209043 washes without fading, all for $30.” It’s for this reason he simply calls it “the “G.O.A.T of sweatshirts.” If this salmon-y pink isn’t for you, it comes in eight other colors (of which Favorito owns three).

Those looking for a similarly priced crewneck sweatshirt that is made more sustainably should consider this one from Alternative Apparel, according to Dejon Mullings, a product-communications manager at Pinterest. “It’s made with organic and recycled materials, but it’s still extremely affordable,” he says, adding that he likes to style it “with jeans or chinos, and because it’s a little bit on the slimmer side, I’ll wear it as a layering piece under jackets all the time.” Shown in blue, the sweatshirt comes in four more colors, including black and a cheery red.

Photo: Retailer

If, like our former deputy editor Jason Chen, you have shopped for crewneck sweatshirts only to find “they were always just a bit baggy or low in the armholes, or most often, too long,” then this Gap style may be the you’ve always been searching for, too. “I read (of all things) Derek Blasberg talking about his search for a good crewneck sweatshirt, which ended up coming from the Gap,” writes Chen, who says this Vintage Soft Sweatshirt fits just right — not too baggy, nor too long — and that he’s gotten a few since finding it. “Gap’s changed the material from a lightweight cotton to something a bit heavier, but the fit is always spot-on,” he says.

No crewneck sweatshirt on this list is more affordable than this straightforward style from Hanes, which is a favorite of fitness instructor Patrick McGrath, who first told us about it when we asked him about the best men’s loungewear. According to him, it has “a good fit that accentuates your body” and, because it is so inexpensive, he suggests pairing it with some Hanes sweatpants “for a same-set vibe that reminds me of Aimé Leon Dore.” (We think the simple style would go just as well with jeans or ch