Here at the Strategist, we like to think of ourselves as crazy (in the good way) about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed products and single out the most convincing ones. (You can learn more about our rating system and how we pick each item here.)
And while we’ve written about lots of sweaters before — including giftable cashmere sweaters, office cardigans, and sweaters for women — here i hwe’ve rounded up the best sweaters for men, as praised by the most enthusiastic reviewers on Amazon.
Best-rated (and least expensive) sweater for men
Trust the significant others. One woman bought this sweater as a “love gift” for her beau, who loved it, she says. “And your special man will too.” Another guy’s wife says it “fits perfectly on my husband,” hiding problem areas some men have: “The higher neckline on all sides conceals any droopy necklines and makes the guy look very SHARPLY dressed, while still being able to zip it down in front so as not to bother his throat.” Not that you have to have a spouse to buy this sweater. One “single old guy,” who says he has to “get by without anyone’s advice or expertise,” bought it for himself. He wanted a sweater that didn’t make him “look like Mr. Rogers or somebody’s granddad.” This sweater did not. “It is warm but lightweight,” he says. “It looks classy when I need to be dressed up, and relaxed and comfortable when that is appropriate.”
And now for some micro-picks for every type of sweater for men you might be looking for.
Best cotton crewneck sweater for men
Some readers don’t want you to know about this sweater. Like the one who said this: “I’m almost hesitant to post how great these are because they keep going out of stock and I’m trying to get them in several colors.” He loves the “light, soft cotton,” which is light enough for the teacher who says he “sweats while [he] work[s]” but not in this sweater, which he says is breathable and comfortable. According to another review, the “quality is unexpectedly good. The cotton thread is thick and the size fits me very well with my shirt inside.”
Best cashmere crewneck sweater for men
Many reviews say this cashmere is much thinner than what you’d typically find at a department store. But that’s not necessarily a bad thing. In this sweater, “one will not overheat,” says a reviewer who owns four of them. That number seems impressive, until you get to a guy who, after “looking for something like these sweaters for years,” bought them in all 34 colors. Not surprisingly, he wears them “constantly.” Another man says this “is the most amazing sweater I own: it’s very, very soft, breathes very easily, and is very versatile.”
Best wool crewneck sweater for men
Customers describe this sweater as “good quality and very affordable,” including one who was particularly taken with it. She teaches something called “fiber arts” and seems to know a lot about wool. Proof: “I have worked with Shetland … Wool naturally wicks away moisture, stays clean longer, is naturally fire resistant and will regulate your body temp because it’s breathable, but holds in your own heat.” She bought one for her husband, who “is not a huge sweater guy,” for their trip to Ireland. He might not be a huge gratitude guy, because he initially told her that she’d “wasted money.” But then he tried it on and wore it for two days straight, presumably while apologizing. “It elongates his torso and it really makes him look 10 or 15 pounds thinner,” she says.
Best heavyweight crewneck sweater for men
“Talk about quality,” says one reviewer who bought this sweater for her boyfriend. It “is a thick, luscious material that is so nice and cozy.” One man called it his “favorite sweater” because “it kept [him] warm and [he] thought [he] looked really good in it.” He’s confident that the sweaters “are going to make great additions to my winter wardrobe for years to come.”
Best V-neck sweater for men
Reviewers love the size of V, which isn’t too deep. According to one, “It fits well, the material feels good, and best of all, the V-neck opening is a good size.” Another perk of this sweater is the material. One customer must have pulled out the thesaurus before writing: “It’s not soft-soft, but it is soft.” He praises its versatility, too: “Looks pretty good over a simple tee for the casual and pretty good over a dress shirt as well.”
Best slim-fit V-neck sweater for men
The size and shape of this V were also important to reviewers. But what really convinced them was the fit. “Most sweaters you find in stores are loose fitting and look oversized on me,” one man says. “But these were slim fitting and look professional in the office.” Another calls this “the best fitting sweater I’ve ever owned,” and he owns “some fairly high end brands.” As he explains, “It’s definitely more of a fashionable sweater than a warm sweater, more on the thin side material wise, but that’s how I prefer my sweaters. It’s basically a sweater that fits like a nice T-shirt.” In case you don’t trust him, another reviewer bought it to impress his wife. “I got an emphatic ‘yes yes yes,’” he says.
Best quarter-zip sweater for men
Remember Ken Bone, who asked a question during a 2016 presidential debate while wearing a red quarter-zip sweater and quickly became a meme? An overwhelming amount of reviewers who bought this sweater do. “I love everything he stands for and that includes beautiful quarter zip red sweaters,” says one. But there were plenty of other people who liked it for different reasons. One woman who bought one for her husband likes that it “has more of a slim fit, not relaxed or boxy in any way.” Another reviewer says, “This was a nice looking lightweight sweater, with a nice shape and pattern.” One man points out that Izod “has always been a reliable, consistent brand for well-made, affordable men’s apparel.” This sweater in particular, he says, “has a cotton weight just enough for mild winter temps in the South, and with a cable knit to perfection.”
Best full-zipper cardigan for men
Many reviewers highlight this cardigan’s full zipper. “It’s well-made and heavy so it keeps me warm especially since the zipper goes all the way up to the turtleneck,” says one man. Another, who finds traditional cardigans that “leave the top open” to be annoying, has “worn it almost every day since receiving it about a month ago.” A third reviewer bought this for her husband, who is “not an easygoing man of simple taste. He is as high maintenance as they come.” He approved. “He loves this,” she says. “It’s a good-looking sweater.”
Best cardigan for men
It’s the classic cardigan, which for some reviewers has proved hard to find. One man who “always loved cardigan sweaters” describes them as “thick and warm. The weave reminds me of my old letterman’s sweater from high school.” Another wanted to replace his father’s “favorite cardigan that he has been wearing for decades. Yes, decades.” This was perfect. “These must be made on looms dating back to the 1960s,” he says, which we can’t guarantee. What he can confirm, however, is that his father “was thrilled. The quality is outstanding, and they are definitely made to last.” A third reviewer bought the cardigan for himself and found it to have the perfect balance of features: “Just the right weight; not too heavy yet warm and soft. Fits well and looks classy.”
Best heavyweight cardigan for men
“Nice and heavy, and fits well,” says one reviewer. Another thinks “they are perfect to lounge in, throw on to run out, or wear over a dress shirt.” One wife purchased this for her unstylish husband, writing, “My husband loved his ‘old man sweater.’ Very handsome (yay for me) and comfy (yay for him). Now to just stop him from wearing it with sweatpants out of the house.”
Best sweater-vest for men
While a good portion of reviewers seem to have bought this for a costume, many serious customers question why sweater-vests are not more accessible. They say a good-quality sweater-vest can be quite difficult to track down, and that this one is great. One reviewer writes, “These are great looking sweaters that have the possibility of adding some vibrancy to your wardrobe. They are not too thick, which has allowed me to wear them well into the spring.” Another owns 15 of these sweater-vests and plans to buy the remaining four colors he doesn’t have. “The fit is unbelievably classic and true to size,” he says. “The material is not that hard, woolly feel, but a smooth silky feel and look. I get compliments every time I wear one with jeans or with a shirt and tie.”
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.