the best. really.

The 9 Best Under-Eye Concealers I’ve Found for Black Skin

If you’re a human, there’s a good chance that at one time or another dark circles have appeared under your eyes. Conventional makeup wisdom has it that you should use an under-eye concealer that’s a shade or two lighter than the rest of your skin, to cover and brighten those purplish-gray rings. But on black skin, this logic doesn’t apply: Lighter shades of concealer will just look ashy. “On dark skin, under-eye darkness reads blueish,” says Nick Barose, a makeup artist whose clients include Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Lupita Nyong’o. “So it’s about color-correcting, too, not just coverage.”

First, for brown skin, Barose recommends an orange-tone concealer to do the correcting on bluish circles. This leans on basic color theory: Shades opposite of each other on the color wheel — such as blue and orange — tend to cancel one another out. Then, for concealing, Barose says to choose a color close to your skin tone, and that liquids blend in best. (If you already have a good liquid foundation, that works as well.) Lastly, “never apply concealer with your finger because it makes the color blotchy,” Barose says. “Opt for a concealer brush and small BeautyBlender.” Everything you’ll need, below.

Under-eye color correctors for most black skin tones range from peach to red. The redder it is, the better it can correct on dark complexions. This Becca shade, called Backlight, looks saturated, but the balmy texture actually goes on translucent. Its red tint is just the right tone to cancel darkness in dark skin. The formula also has very subtle particles that brighten up the area by reflecting light.

(Becca’s Peach color is also great for lighter, golden black complexions.)

Around three years ago, it seemed, color correctors went from little-known pro tools to every woman’s secret weapon. I hopped on the bandwagon, and started with the Shara corrector in Apricot after I’d heard about the brand from a friend who really liked its primer. The color corrector has a salmonish hue that corrects perfectly for my medium-brown skin. And because it’s very lightweight, it sinks right in.

These correctors have two colors, for correcting and then concealing. The redder tone is great for under-eye circles and hyperpigmentation.

One of Nick Barose’s favorite color correctors for black skin has a creamy texture and delivers medium coverage. It doesn’t have any shimmer, so you can use it all over, like on hyperpigmentation left behind from pimples and darkness around the mouth (plus, shimmer draws too much attention when concealing blemishes). The red-orange coloring is midrange hue and covers a lot of different brown complexions.

Beauty Bakerie’s concealer is liquid and sets really fast, so dot it on first then quickly blend it with a barely moistened BeautyBlender. Once it sets, this concealer doesn’t melt off for at least the first several hours of the day. The range is limited to eight colors, but the darkest few really nail the colors for black skin, especially the cool tone of the darkest shade.

And a fresh BeautyBlender.

Also, M.A.C’s longwear concealer comes in a lot of great colors and really does last a long time. It’s best when you set it with a superlight dusting of translucent powder, to get the full effect.

For a finishing powder to pair with the M.A.C concealer, I like this one from Tarte. It helps to relax shine without coming off as too matte. You don’t look like a corpse with it on, you know?

I started using this stick solely as a concealer — the creamy texture has buildable, medium coverage and doesn’t sink into the creases under the eye. Lately, I’ve been using it as a foundation, too, blending it into uneven areas of my skin. The finish is a moist matte, so it’s not dry or cakey. And there are 20 colors in cool and warm tones, so it’s easy to find a close match for brown complexions.

According to testers that I know, this NARS formula gets the golden tones and yellow coloring of light-skinned black complexions right, which can be hard to find. It’s a full-coverage formula, so the applicator it comes with isn’t the best tool. I would apply with a concealer brush to make sure it goes on evenly.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

The 9 Best Under-Eye Concealers I’ve Found for Black Skin