our shopping cart

Stuff We Buy Ourselves: The White T-Shirts Our Editors Love Most

A Lacausa white t-shirt, from a list of white t-shirts picked by The Strategist
Photo: Courtesy of the Retailer

If you follow our monthly Strategist haul, then you’re familiar with the idiosyncrasies of our editors’ and writers’ shopping habits. While we think of those as the highlights, there are plenty of other, less glamorous things that we buy — and love — on the regular, too. So whether you’ve wondered about the lip balm we hoard or the SPF moisturizers we slather on our faces, this is the Stuff We Buy Ourselves. In this edition: the white t-shirts we wear again and again.

Katy Schneider turned me onto this brand Liana (the designer is a friend of hers), and she really makes an excellent slightly cropped but not-too-boxy white tee that looks excellent with high-waisted pants.

I have a savage relationship with my T-shirts, and usually take a pair of scissors to the neck or the hem on most of them. My favorite of this bunch is probably the Lacausa Frank tee, which has the downy texture of angel food cake and (now, thanks to my own handiwork) the ideal crop.

That said, a couple of years ago Reformation branched out into more regular daytime-wear and started making these really soft, really reasonably priced ($28!) T-shirts. This cropped crew has all the right dimensions, with no at-home hack jobs required.

These are technically guys’ T-shirts, but I like the​​ basic white crewneck in XS.​ The rounded hem is nice, but ​I like to cut it so it hits right about above my mostly high-waisted jeans, which gives it a more boxy fit. I think the slub cotton feels so substantial, and it has held up quite nicely after tons of washes.

As of late, I’ve purchased two different brands of white T-shirt. The first is Hanes Comfort Blend, and if I’m going to be honest with everyone here I bought the Supreme version. I’m not super proud of that, but it was deep in my hypebeast days (I’ve since gone cold turkey on Supreme purchases) and, if I’m being honest again, they’re actually really comfortable. I like something a little loose-fitting, so a men’s small or medium fits the bill. I’m a crewneck-only kinda girl and the neckline on these scoops just below my collarbone in a way that I find attractive, and maybe slightly sexy (?), for wearing a men’s shirt at least. And the comfort blend is key because they’re way softer than a regular Hanes, kind of like if you spent some time wearing in a typical Hanes or just put it in the wash five to seven times.

For a more “business casual” white tee look I’m a big fan of Everybody World’s Tailored Trash Tee. This California basics brand makes three styles of basic, solid T-shirts, but I prefer the tailored version because I find it slimmer down the torso and I prefer that look to a boxier cut. It’s much stiffer and thicker than the Hanes, but that’s the point here, and it’s also the perfect weight to roll up the sleeves. I give them two rolls right along the seam and they actually, no lies, stay up like that all day by themselves. A small miracle.

I am extremely particular about my white T-shirts: I like them boxy, very (very) slightly cropped, and a bit short at the arm. My friend Lili has a company called Liana which makes a tee (see Alexis’s pick, above) that fits those criteria exactly, so I wear that in various colors almost every day. Re/Done does a brilliant little boxy white tee in collaboration with Hanes, and I’m a fan of Lacausa’s as well, because it’s extremely soft (see Margaret’s pick, also above).

I’m also a superfan of the pretty basics company Baserange, and am sure this little guy, which is on sale for $19 (?!?!) would fit like a glove.

The J.Crew slim perfect T-shirt really lives up to its name — for me, at least. It’s tight enough to my body that I can layer it comfortably under jumpsuits or dresses, but it has enough give that I don’t feel self-conscious, like I’m wearing a bodysuit, when I wear it with a pair of jeans. That’s partially because it’s 100 percent cotton, so the knit is thick, not accidentally see-through, and it’s soft and slightly stretchy without any spandex. I also have a longer torso, so I like the longer cut of this shirt, which doesn’t ride up when I raise my arms up over my head. The sleeves are also on the longer side, coming about halfway down my biceps. That means I can cuff my sleeves like I’m James Dean, and that’s the kind of casual, cool feel I want from my plain white T-shirt.

This has been my staple white T-shirt for years. It’s incredibly soft, drapes perfectly, and looks very cool with a pair of white denim shorts. I don’t like to spend a lot on T-shirts — especially white ones — because they tend to take a beating during the summer. Madewell often has sales, too, so it’s not uncommon to see it marked down to around $15. That way I don’t feel guilty buying a new one when mine inevitably gets stained or yellowed.

Me and white tees don’t really mix because Murphy’s law always has it that I ruin a white shirt within days of wearing it. I defied the gods recently though with this Mott & Bow crewneck shirt, which I found to be delightfully soft and comfortable. It’s a blend of modal and soft pima cotton (so it has a similar feel to these Tommy John briefs I raved about recently), is fitted enough that it won’t bunch up under a fabric skirt, and since it’s pre-shrunk, you won’t have to do any guesswork with sizing.

I love how far up this neckline goes, which gives the tee an old-school vibe. I also like that it’s not too long, since I have a short torso. Roll up the sleeves for a daintier look.

I’ve plopped a eye-bulging amount of money on all the white tee variations: the Fruit of the Loom multipacks, the “minimalist basics” start-ups that have sprouted all over Instagram, the three-figure designer tees with the embroidered insignias of conspicuous consumption. Pound for pound, my not-perfect-but-excellent white tee is the Uniqlo U short-sleeve tee. It’s made in a heavyweight cotton with a forgivingly loose silhouette. It fits well with jeans or wide-leg khakis. Plus — and this is the biggest plus of all — it’s not so spend-y that I need to drop another small fortune if coffee or BBQ sauce drips on it.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

The White T-Shirts Our Editors Love Most