Here at the Strategist, we like to think of ourselves as crazy (in the good way) about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed (that’s four-to-five-star reviews and lots of ’em) products and single out the most convincing. While we’ve already written about the best rain jackets for women, rain boots for men and women, and umbrellas, here we’re singling out the most stylish and durable rain jackets for men on Amazon (note that reviews have been edited for length and clarity).
Best short front-zip rain jacket, overall
“I bought one of these eight years ago, I have gotten nothing but compliments on it. I wear it at work as an industrial electrician, and at home, on cool days, or wet days. I have worn this in misty rain and torrential downpours, it took eight years to get to the point of water penetrating the outer layer, which I why I bought another exactly like it. Hopefully in eight years, they’ll still be available.”
Best lightweight shell rain jacket
“I live in Kodiak Alaska, it rains here more than almost anywhere else in North America. It’s understood here among residents and fisherman alike that Grundéns is the only way to go, and the undisputed leader in rain gear. I have spent many days out on the river fishing in the rain in this jacket and stayed perfectly dry. I go to work right after fishing, so i actually shower first, and thanks to this jacket, and my chest waders, I have no need to dry up, or change the business casual attire I wear underneath.”
Best PVC-coated rain jacket
Best short rain jacket with a chin guard
“I love this jacket. The price is just right for something so light and packable. I expect low durability with a superlight jacket, so I don’t like to spend a fortune on it. When my last one tore, I got this as a replacement right away. This version of the Precip is incredibly breathable and incredibly effective at the same time. I overheat in other rain jackets, but not this one. And yet I’ve worn it in rain, snow, and at 13,000 feet in blizzard winds.”
Best short front-zip rain jacket under $100
“This is a very lightweight rain jacket. I like that it is very waterproof and the hood comes far enough forward to shield your face, and has an inner-hood type thing you can tighten, so even in the wind it won’t blow the hood off. There’s a soft layer of mesh for the lining, which feels nice — very good for a spring jacket, but in winter, you definitely need to layer.”
Best packable rain jacket under $100
Best breathable lightweight rain jacket under $50
Best cold-weather rain jacket under $50
Best rain poncho
“I ordered this to take to Pitchfork Festival last weekend and although it was bulkier than I expected and took up half my (small) backpack, I was so glad I brought it with me. It started absolutely pouring the second day and while I watched thousands of people frantically scrambling for cover or flimsy plastic ponchos that tore in the wind, I just popped this on and was comfortable until the storm blew over. It was breathable and I didn’t feel overheated or sweaty, plus it dried quickly when the rain ended.”
Best trench coat
“This trench coat is designed very well. The length covers most of my body from the elements. Walking through wind, rain, or snow is no longer a miserable experience. It features a removable liner and wool collar so it basically can function as a raincoat or winter coat. The trench coat is also a timeless classic. You will feel like a bad ass as you walk around wearing this coat.”
Best full-length oilskin raincoat
“I’ve owned mine for nearly two years and have never re-treated, or cleaned it for that matter. I just came in from 30 minutes in torrential rain and the only part of me that is wet is the gap between the bottom of the coat and the top of my muck boots. I work outside and have been very thankful for this coat. I’ve never used the cowl piece because I’m not big on looking like a cowboy all the time.”
Best high-visibility rain jacket
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.
Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.