The Best Gift Is a Vintage Kids’ Book
Of course, you can’t go wrong with Goodnight, Moon. But one of the greatest gifts the internet has given parents is that many of the out-of-print books of their youth are available to buy online — and if you’re lucky, with the 1987 library binding still intact. And even if they’re not necessarily out of print, rediscovering vintage titles is a delight — and also make an unexpected present. I asked 37 authors, illustrators, writers, booksellers, artists, and other bookish people to share their childhood favorites. Below are 76 vintage or otherwise hard-to-find treasures that make excellent gifts for every age. If you prefer to buy a new edition, many of the forgotten classics have been reissued for the modern reader. For even more children’s book ideas, here’s a roundup of 2026 releases.
Priyanka Mattoo, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I love the entire cute, bizarre oeuvre of Harry Whittier Frees. He illustrated a bunch of cats, but the illustrations are actually photographs (really). There’s Four Little Kittens and Whiskers, which is the best one, IMO, but impossible to find. Toodles and Her Friends, which features a rabbit and a dog, is great, too. He did not limit it to just cats!”
Rumaan Alam, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“This Richard Scarry set rules, and I don’t know why it’s not been reissued. It’s all real vehicles, as opposed to the fanciful oddities in his Busytown books. Both of my kids looked at this for hours and hours as small children. The books are kind of strangely shaped, these tall rectangles, in this way that is very pleasing. I think it’s a great baby shower gift, and I have given it more than once.”
Jon Klassen, author and illustrator
New! You can now save this product for later.
“It’s hard to pick just one Remy Charlip book but Fortunately is a great place to start. It is about a series of events that alternately go very well or very badly while a poor kid just tries to get to a party. Charlip was an incredible illustrator, designer, and all around creative guy and this book is one of his best.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“The Big Jump is a collection of three stories about a weird kingdom and some people who live there and have to deal with weird rules, riddles, and bad kings. It’s loose and funny and strange and it was my favorite when I was little.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Again, tough to pick a Steig. This has some of the most frightening moments of any picture book I’ve ever read, not for their fantastic or magic qualities, but for how weirdly real they seem. A young girl pig finds a talking bone in the woods right before a fox kidnaps her and brings her home to his house to eat. Steig never missed, and this is one of his most memorable books, I think.”
Lena Dunham, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I am embarrassed by how much I spent to get this out-of-print book by Leo Hartas from my childhood for my daughter, but it’s truly the most comforting, magical, engaging cross section of an old-fashioned apartment building. It teaches kids about everything from architectural details to plumbing to neighborly relations. An illustrated dollhouse with lessons!”
Sarah Blakley-Cartwright, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“The Marcel Marceau Counting Book was given to our daughter by the artist Lee Mary Manning, whose own work has something of the same playfulness and sensitivity to gesture. The great French mime Marcel Marceau counts from one to 20 by putting on a succession of hats. He is alternately a cowboy, a farmer, a swordsman, a jockey, and eventually his beloved character Bip. With every new hat, another character appears, and the discarded hats gradually accumulate into a kind of sculpture. I love that children learn to count almost incidentally, while watching someone become 20 different people simply by changing his hat.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Published as part of the beautiful little King Penguin series, A Book of Toys traces the history of toys through Gwen White’s illustrations, based on objects in British museum collections. There are ancient rattles, little bronze animals, a Roman wooden horse whose wheels have fallen off, and toys made of clay, string, paper, and tin. I love the idea that children have been playing with versions of the same things for thousands of years. Each object is given a personality, and the book feels like a miniature museum of childhood.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Bruno Munari was one of the great Italian artists and designers of the 20th century. I was introduced to his work by the gallery Kaufmann Repetto. Created as part of a series inspired by his young son Alberto, this book follows an eccentric animal seller offering increasingly improbable pets: a pipe-smoking flamingo, a slightly tipsy armadillo, a grumpy porcupine, even a centipede to take for a walk. The pages are cut to different sizes, with flaps and windows that reveal unexpected details as you turn them. The book itself becomes a kind of toy. It’s funny, surreal, and beautifully designed.”
Joana Avillez, illustrator
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I am obsessed with mazes and have been since my dad drew them on napkins to entertain me as a child during dinners out. I continue this practice today with my son. He and I love this book of mazes, which you solve by tracing your finger through the pages. O’er hill and dale and lava and bridge and castle steps and rope ladder and secret trapdoor you will go. Each segment is so detailed and wondrous, I sometimes don’t want to find the end.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Suzuki Beane is the beatnik Eloise. She lives with artists Hugh and Marcia in a pad on Bleecker Street. They are also, I might add, her parents. I got my copy 15 years ago at Powell’s Books in Portland, and the price has certainly gone up. The drawings are by Louise Fitzhugh, who wrote and illustrated Harriet the Spy, another essential NYC gal-about-town. My friend Anya is kind of the real-life Suzuki. This book is a treasure that makes me want to hit the pavement.”
Liana Finck, cartoonist and author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“A classic. Everyone should read it.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Punk. Perfect. I read it around when it was published, when I was about four. The reason I️ want to make kids’ books.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Just really, really funny. I️ think it’s all in the pictures but I’m biased.”
Andrew Kuo, artist
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I Am a Bunny is obvious, but I cannot read that book without getting teary-eyed because it’s about this hopeful/hopeless optimism before adulthood falls. I think it’s about depression, or at least melancholy: ‘I live in a hollow log.’ First editions aren’t going for big dollars, but they look beautiful. The illustrations are wonderful.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Poppy and Mozart and Poppy and Vivaldi are interactive books that play songs when you press on buttons. They’re charming, whimsical, and my son couldn’t get enough. They’re new-ish but fell out of print in the United States. They’re just not around.”
Merve Emre, New Yorker contributing writer and professor at Wesleyan
New! You can now save this product for later.
New! You can now save this product for later.
“When they were younger, my boys especially liked Dorothy Kunhardt’s Junket is Nice and Now Open the Box. They used to spend hours with Claude Ponti’s older books Blaze and the Castle Cake for Bertha Daye and Le doudou méchant, which I don’t believe has been translated into English, as well as Graeme Base’s The Eleventh Hour whichremains a favorite. We try to pick up some hardback Nancy Drews and Hardy Boys books whenever we’re in a used bookshop. They love comics — Nancy and Sluggo’s Guide to Life, all of Peanuts and Calvin and Hobbes, Mafalda, etc. — and all the MinaLima books, although I don’t know if you can get them in the U.S.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“As older readers, they’ve enjoyed this lushly illustrated edition of E. Nesbit’s The Enchanted Castle and Edward Eager’s Half Magic(although some of the dialogue at the end is racially insensitive). My older son’s class just finished reading The Westing Game, which was hugely enjoyable for him. In August, he read Lord of the Flies, which he liked much more than the treacly books his school assigns as summer reading. Last year, after we watched Lupin on Netflix, he read the Macmillan Collectors’ edition of Arsène Lupin, Gentleman Thief. My younger son has recently finished A Cricket in Times Square, which is wry and wonderful, and we read Maniac Magee together last spring.”
Mac Barnett, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Frank and Ernest, by Alexandra Day. Frank and Ernest are a manlike bear and a slightly less manlike —but still pretty manlike — elephant, who wear beautifully tailored suits and do temp work. They get jobs running a diner (for humans). But the most absurd thing in this book is the English language. Frank and Ernest revel in the strange argot of a restaurant kitchen — ‘Paint a bow-wow red, Frank, and I need a nervous pudding.’ It’s hilarious, and it has a very weird, very poignant last page.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Shortcut, by Donald Crews. What a thrill it is to read this story aloud, and to have it read to you! Donald Crews has one of the greatest bodies of work in all of children’s literature. Freight Train is his most famous book; Shortcut is my favorite. It brings together Crews’s genius for storytelling and book design to follow some kids who have a harrowing adventure on the railroad tracks. There’s not another picture book like it, not even close.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Caleb & Kate, William Steig. Again and again, William Steig wrote about characters who undergo a magical transformation, but each story wrings something new from the premise. Caleb & Kate is about an argument—the heat, the remorse, the isolation, the reconciliation. I grew up in a house where we argued a lot, and this book is dead-on, even though neither my mom nor I was ever transformed into a dog by a capricious witch.”
Edith Zimmerman, cartoonist and author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“The Sun Egg, by Elsa Beskow. It’s definitely still in print, but it’s an old book and has a few wacky turns of phrase that I think add to its appeal. My kids (5 and almost 3) love it and have for quite some time! It’s about a little elf who loves to dance and who one day comes across what she thinks is an egg that the sun has laid.”
Greta Caruso, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“This wonderful, funny book was the first in a series from the ‘80s by Barbara Samuels that is sadly, now largely out of print. Duncan and Dolores is about a rascally young girl named Dolores who has a somewhat bumpy journey to learning how to meet her new cat Duncan where he is (under the bed) and not where she wants him to be (in a brass band with her). Since I have always been a criminal over-snuggler of pets, this book appealed to me on a psychic level — plus, my mom’s work as a performer of this book at bedtime was particularly good (we still quote one of her “line readings” to each other). Now, 35 years later, I still love reading this book to my kids — it’s still my favorite kind of kids book: funny and deep without clobbering anyone over the head with a Very Important Life Lesson.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“My friend Fanny gave me Gennarino ‘for my kids,’ but it was really a present for me: the story of a young Italian boy who wishes for a bigger fishing boat with gorgeous 1960s illustrations? Couldn’t possibly be more up my alley. Luckily my daughters humor me on occasion and let me include it in our bedtime short stack, and we pretend that it appeals to us all equally.”
Grace Lin, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Ruth Chew books were some of my favorite books as a child; I’m always surprised that they aren’t better-known. They usually consist of an everyday child (many times in Brooklyn, I remember really wanting to see Prospect Park) finding or receiving a magical item and their subsequent adventures. They were all charming and delightful and to 7-year-old me, very exciting! This one features magic buttons, which has made me always look at any button with appreciation.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Natalie Babbit is known for her book Tuck Everlasting but my favorite of hers is The Search for Delicious. I particularly love the first edition where she illustrated the cover as well as the interiors. This book was one of my inspirations for Where the Mountain Meets the Moon; it made me want to write about a journey that was like a fairytale.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Carolyn Haywood books were also influential books of my childhood — they inspired my Year of the Dog books. I loved how they showed so much of my everyday life — school, friends, neighborhood, and this one in particular always feels like Christmas to me. Betsy’s Little Star features Betsy’s younger sister who was born on Christmas and is so named Star.”
Peter H. Reynolds, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“The Tall Book of Make Believe illustrated by Garth William is an anthology of stories and poems edited by Jane Werner. Its unusual tall and thin format made it standout from all my other books on my childhood shelf. I poured over my copy - over and over again - completely captivated by the many color and black and white illustrations by Garth Williams. It remains one of my all time favorite picture book treasures!”
New! You can now save this product for later.
‘Mr. Rabbit and the Lovely Present,’ by Charlotte Zolotow, illustrated by Maurice Sendak
“As a young boy, I was mesmerized by the art in this lovely picture book by Charlotte Zolotow and illustrated by Maurice Sendak. It had an ethereal and gentle quality that set it apart from most of the picture books at the time.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I remember being at my hometown library when I was in second grade and I was exploring the children’s room. The cover of Millions of Cats caught my eye. The book was so different than the typical picture book; it was dark and bold. The text was hand-lettered which was also quite different than most picture books. This probably influenced me to use my own handwriting for almost all my own picture books. The story was originally published in 1928 and won a Newbery Honor award in 1929. Millions of Cats is the oldest American picture book still in print.”
Sophie Blackall, author and illustrator
New! You can now save this product for later.
“One of my favorite books as a child was The Happy Lion. It was one of the few books that I saved and read with my own children, who loved it as much as I did. The story is about a beloved lion at a zoo in France who is visited by the townspeople each day who call out, ‘Bonjour, Happy Lion.’ One day, when his cage is left unlocked, he wanders out into the streets, intending to visit his friends, who, much to his surprise, greet him with shrieks of dismay. A lion in a cage is one thing, a lion loose on the streets is another. Only a small boy is sensible enough to know that the happy lion is the same happy lion, caged or loose, and together the two walk with dignified calm back to the zoo. There’s a whole lot to love about this genial lion and wise child, not least of all Duvoisin’s beautiful and endearing drawings. My 3-year-old child was obsessed with this book and greeted everyone with ‘Bonjour’ for quite some time. It was out of print but reissued on its 50th anniversary in 2004.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“The Agony in the Kindergarten is not really a book for children so much as it is a book about children, and the adults who misunderstand them. Hilarious and agonizing in equal measure, Steig pairs wildly inventive line drawings with acutely observant text — the things grown-ups say about their children when they don’t think they can hear. It is a work of genius, I’m sure it made me a better parent, and I buy copies whenever I see them pop up on eBay or in a secondhand bookstore.”
Kate DiCamillo, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I grew up on this lavishly illustrated unabridged version of Collodi’s Pinocchio. The book is surreal, haunting and as unsettling as entering someone else’s dreams. I loved it as a kid and when I look through it now, I can see how deeply it impacted my imagination.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Mary Norton’s The Borrowers is over 60 years old now, but the magic of tiny people who live in the floorboards of our houses never grows old. I was enchanted with these books (there are five in the series) when I was a kid. They still enchant me as an adult.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“The Watsons Go to Birmingham – 1963 by Christopher Paul Curtis is (unbelievably) more than 30 years old. This funny, warm, wise book is one of the reasons I am a writer of books for children. It is a master class in looking at difficult things through a child’s eyes.”
Oliver Jeffers, author and illustrator
New! You can now save this product for later.
‘Dinotopia, A Land Apart from Time: 20th Anniversary Edition,’ by James Gurney
“These were the first figurative paintings I was ever really into. I remember winning the book is a raffle at my local bookstore the week that it came out. I wasn’t much of a reader then, but the style and ambition of this was mesmerising. Written in the style of a long forgotten journal, it is an incredible achievement.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“The power of mindset and perspective are the main tools at play here. Written in the old-timey style of the pioneering West, this is a book I discovered back in art school, around the time I was beginning to think about making a book of my own. It opened my eyes to the sheer variety of picture books out there, and to just how powerfully they could work at portraying real life morals seamlessly into very entertaining narratives.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“This is a book I remember from the early ‘80s, and I cite often as an influence. Less well known than Carle’s The Very Hungry Caterpillar, this grouchy ladybug (or bad tempered ladybird to use the British English translation), is in a bad mood and tries to pick fights with increasingly larger animals until she gets all the way up to a whale. The book seemed like a magic trick as the whale seemed so enormous in its gatefold spread, and it was with this spread at the tender age of, maybe 5, that I discovered the power of scale in art.”
Ed Park, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Carol Kendall’s The Gammage Cup is a gentle fantasy from 1959 so utterly charming it didn’t need to sprawl into a series. The Minnipins live in the Land Between the Mountains, on the banks of the Watercress River, and their folkways and eccentricities are given space to flower as the peaceful status quo is about to change. Like Dune, each chapter begins with a fictional epigraph — a scrap of poetry or philosophy, including one by an appealingly absent-minded Minnipin named Muggles. The Gammage Cup is worth all of Harry Potter put together.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I love that Scholastic put out an H.P. Lovecraft anthology. The Shadow Over Innsmouth and Other Stories of Horror (1971) is a perfect primer to the author’s brand of cosmic fright, complete with spectral cover art and introductions by Margaret Ronan. (’What kind of Christmas story would you expect H.P. Lovecraft to write?’ she asks before ‘The Festival,’ a story featuring The Necronomicon. ‘Uncozy? Unmerry? Certainly uncanny.’) ‘The Colour Out of Space’ and the title story bookend shorter fictions, including ‘The Outsider’ and a tale Lovecraft ghostwrote for Houdini.”
Pam Muñoz Ryan, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Song of the Swallows, by Leo Politi. This picture book about the return of the swallows to San Juan Capistrano might have been the first book I ever read featuring a Latino character. I still remember it.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“The Talking Eggs is one of my favorite picture books. A magical Creole folktale about kindness.”
Ping Zhu, illustrator
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Bullfrog Grows Up, by Rosamond Dauer, illustrated by Byron Barton. A short and sweet story about a mouse family who find and raise a tadpole into adulthood. Sometimes you have to embark on your own once you’ve outgrown something, in this case literally!”
New! You can now save this product for later.
‘Milk and Cookies,’ by Frank Asch
“Milk and Cookies, by Frank Asch. This book made me decide chocolate chip cookies were the best. Also a great story about imagination and fear alongside very satisfying illustrations.”
Molly Young, writer
New! You can now save this product for later.
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Joan Steiner constructed colorful scenes out of everyday objects deployed in surprising and clever ways in her Look-Alikes series. Look closely at the ‘microwave’ in a kitchen scene and you’ll find that it’s actually a wallet and two dominoes — and the dish rack is a hair clip! An outer-space scene features a ‘rocket’ made from a Thermos, a shuttlecock, a piece of rotini pasta and some erasers. The process of decoding is delightful and the scenes are lovingly tactile. Plus it’s a fun way to teach your kid words like thimble or protractor or dentures or harmonica.”
Emily Gould, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I just bought this for my kids. Crucially, it has to be spiral-bound, with the measuring spoons, and with the bears on the cover. This book taught me how to cook as a kid, and I hope it will do the same for my increasingly cooking-curious kids (8 and 11) who I still don’t totally trust with a sharp knife, though Raffi has been making himself ramen a lot recently. The recipes are a) GOOD and b) both easy enough and challenging enough to motivate kids to be more independent in the kitchen. I’m hoping to outsource making dinner eventually.”
Durga Chew-Bose, author and director
New! You can now save this product for later.
“We love the Meg and Mog books by Helen Nicoll and Jan Pienkowksi. This series is from my own childhood; we actually have a copy that belonged to me. My older son loves witches and stories where things don’t go as planned. Personally, I find the illustrations so pleasing and bold.
New! You can now save this product for later.
“We also like Almond Cookies and Dragon Well Tea by Cynthia Chin-Lee. I only recently discovered it, maybe in the last year or so. We love books about families, generational homes, and traditions that get passed down.”
Dayna Tortorici, co-editor of N+1
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Take Time to Relax: If there were an N+1 Bookmatch just for kids, this would be my top rec. A family of Beavers are burnt out on their schedule of extremely ‘90s extracurriculars (karate, aerobics, computer class) when they unexpectedly get snowed in. Now they have no choice but to chill! A precious relic from the pre-Zoom era, when a day off really was a day off.”
Mallory Neidich, Spiral Books
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Tomi Ungerer was a superb storyteller, and he never sentimentalized children. His stories are delightfully bizarre and captivating. Phaidon has reissued several beautiful editions of his work, but this one is still out of print for now.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I love this lesser-known story by Margaret Wise Brown. A group of children find a dead bird in the woods. They wrap it in leaves, bury it, and sing to it every day, until they forget. The story was reissued in 2016 with new illustrations, but the original, with Remy Charlip’s muted blues and greens, is the one to find. Like the writers I admire most, Brown doesn’t explain or console; she just lets children do what children do.”
Ruth Madievsky, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Mr. Postmouse Takes a Trip, about a mouse mail carrier traveling the world with his family, has a Wes Anderson–meets–Richard Scarry sort of appeal. There are little easter eggs on every page that keep rereads interesting. I appreciate the message behind the mouse family making friends everywhere they go, from mountaintop marmots to a dragon living inside a volcano.”
Shawn Harris, author and illustrator
New! You can now save this product for later.
“This book is part of a set in which the author reports almost prosaic events from the voice of a preschool-age narrator, each managing, with the sparest of text, to reveal something profound about the experience of being a child.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“MauriceSendak spoke about the relationship between picture books and music, and this one really exemplifies how a book can be a song and dance unto itself, from two of the best to ever do it.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Kids prank the teachers, teachers prank the kids, and the reader wins in this quintessential picture book set at school.”
Kelsey Keith, MillerKnoll creative director
New! You can now save this product for later.
“What I respect most about old children’s books is that they aren’t pandering to the adults in the room who feel like every story should teach a lesson. The narratives are discursive, they are abstract, they are weird, they are dissonant … as in, they are actually written for children’s minds. (If the Rands sound familiar to you, Paul, Ann’s spouse, was a graphic designer in the mid-century.)”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“This book is the ultimate nostalgia: It’s a book for kids from the perspective of grown-up kids remembering their own childhoods playing in an imaginary village they built out of rocks, in the desert. It’s funny and sweet — and totally meta for a parent remembering their own adolescence while reading to their child!”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Every night when I was growing up, my dad would read a couple of chapters of some long book to us (ahem, The Hobbit). He introduced my two daughters to this series about two toad brothers, Warton and Morton, and reads it to them in daily installments whenever he comes to stay with us from across the country.”
Clare Malone, New Yorker writer
New! You can now save this product for later.
“A House is a House for Me is rhyming, which always brings the kids along, but the whole concept is thinking of increasingly abstract things that can be houses for other things — like a jar is a house for a pickle, things like that. It’s a kind of jolly weirdness that I think kids books really used to have a lot more.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“On Market Street is an ABC book but has the most amazing outlandish illustrations— every letter is represented by a person made up of things that start with that letter. A ribbon lady for the letter R, a zipper man for Z. I also read it as a kid and those images stayed with me. And I love that idea of having a shared visual history with my kids. It makes me feel like we are connecting on some epigenetic level of imagination!”
Roxanne Behr, New York creative director, photography
New! You can now save this product for later.
“50 Watts Books specializes in reissues of international picture books. Some of my favorites: Animal Land Where There Are No People, A Tiger in the Land of Dreams, I Am A Wolf, After All, and The King of Circles.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“And some of my all-time favorite picture books to give as gifts: Arm in Arm by Remy Charlip; The Rainbow Goblins by Ulde Rico; Zoom by Istvan Banyai (you could do a whole series of wordless picture books: Journey, Il Pallocino Rosso…); Piggybook — very off first wave feminist text with great illustrations; and Could be Worse! — a good gift for a grandparent. This is out of print: When I’m Big by Dick Bruna (creator of Miffy)”
Tembe Denton-Hurst, author
New! You can now save this product for later.
“This was my favorite book as a kid. I got it when I was maybe 4 years old — I might have been younger — but when I became sentient it was there. I loved it so much because it was my birthday and the book was about his birthday. The one I had, there were flaps so you could discover things behind the presents, which I enjoyed.”
Sophie Raseman, writer
New! You can now save this product for later.
“One of the authors whose books should only be bought in their vintage condition is Ellen Raskin. Raskin was a polymath who moved from art form to art form: first graphic design, then book illustration and design, writing and illustrating picture books, and ultimately writing (and illustrating!) children’s fiction. She lavished care on all the parts of a reader’s experience, designing the cover art and illustrating the novels herself.
Raskin came back to certain themes again and again: Loneliness and the value of kindred spirits. Art, craft, and commerce. Hope after pain. (The author knew of what she spoke; she suffered from a painful disease that ended her life far too soon.) And … puzzles, puzzles, puzzles. A complete set of early editions of her novels would make a terrific gift for the type of middle schooler who likes escape rooms: The Westing Game, Figgs & Phantoms, The Mysterious Disappearance of Leon (I Mean Noel), and The Tattooed Potato and Other Clues. Younger children will enjoy her visually inventive picture books like Spectacles and Franklin Stein.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Before it was transformed into Tchaikovsky’s ballet, The Nutcracker was a children’s tale by German Romantic author E. T. A. Hoffmann. The story is stranger and darker than the version audiences have come to know — fittingly for Hoffmann, whose gothic works inspired the likes of Edgar Allan Poe and featured in Freud’s The Uncanny. Maurice Sendak disliked the sugar-coating of life for children, so when he had the opportunity to do set and costume design for a staging of The Nutcracker, he embraced the story’s macabre elements. After the ballet, Sendak released his own surreal illustrated edition of Hoffmann’s story. The book is still in print, but a vintage copy signed by the late Sendak would make a truly special gift for a young dancer with a spooky streak.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Margaret Mahy was New Zealand’s Roald Dahl, but with greater warmth. She remains a giant in her native land, but is less known here. Her Tick Tock Tales is a collection of witty, inventive tales with offbeat twists. Mahy shines in the deadpan moments so rarely allowed into today’s picture books — as when a sailor tells a magical sea-woman of his plan to rescue twenty orphans, and she responds ‘Indeed … I’ve often thought I’d like twenty boys myself.’ Reader, she marries him. Excellent for parents longing to elevate their bedtime read-alouds.”
Kaitlin Phillips, writer
New! You can now save this product for later.
‘Gila Monsters Meet You at the Airport,’ by Marjorie Weinman Sharmat, illustrated by Byron Barton
“For me it’s always Gila Monsters Meet You at the Airport for every new parent. It’s exceptionally written, plausibly useful (is someone moving towns with a child?), and beautifully illustrated! I literally found my copy at my town’s dump. They have a giveaway section. And I’ve since always ordered all of the authors’ books for anyone pregnant, etc. She understands ‘writing for the parent.’”
Ari Spool, Enorme gallery
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Lois Ehlert took photos of her folk art collection and used them as collage to make a story about going to the farmers market. Since our gallery is in Union Square, our daughter is very acquainted with farmers markets, so she loved it. (Nuts to You by the same author is a favorite).”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Our daughter likes to look at books while she’s eating, so we go through a lot of material, and this 175-pager is sitting next to me as I write this. Arnold Lobel is best known for Frog and Toad, but he was very prolific, and they are all bangers. He’s a really good illustrator, and it’s pretty fun when your kid starts to recite all these nursery rhymes everywhere they go …”
Katie Frederich-Smith, @childrensbookclub
New! You can now save this product for later.
“The Night Before Christmas, written by Clement C. Moore and illustrated by Gyo Fujikawa, is the most perfect Christmas book to give as a gift. From the first ornately detailed cutaway of the house to the final spread of Santa and his reindeer flying off into the sky, Gyo Fujikawa is delivering pure enchantment on every page. My favorite is the dreamy pile of sleeping children nestled under cakes, candies, and berry baskets on a bed of pink clouds.”
Youngna Park, writer
New! You can now save this product for later.
“This book introduces math concepts through art, illusions, and playful on-page games, rendered in gorgeous, precise watercolors and pen and ink by the Japanese artist and author Mitsumasa Anno. My 9-year-old begs to read this (and also Math Games II and III) over and over again, despite knowing all the answers. It’s a picture book but also an activity book and a play thing all in one.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“This black-and-white picture book about a family journey from country to city and back again is sparse on words, but genius in concept. You read it front to back as you go to the city, then flip it over and read it back to front for the trip home. Jonas uses the power of negative space to create Rorschach-like images that tell a story in either orientation. It’s quiet and clever, with more to discover in the details on each read.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“First published in 1969, this book is a true masterpiece: an amazing readaloud for a 4-to-8-ish-year-old kid, full of wordplay, with illustrations each miniature works of art. Charlip was a creative polymath, and his love of play comes alive on the page. This book is a collection of stories, poems, and word experiments. Some rhyme, others are recursive, and some are just befuddling. Charlip defies traditional left-to-write structures of storytelling, and words take on shapes that inform how you read them.”
Geoff Snack, Wrong Answer bookstore
New! You can now save this product for later.
“Enzo Mari’s The Fable Game consists of six large interlocking panels with illustrations of various farm animals and wildlife in both night and day scenarios. The illustrations are super simple and very charming, but the narrative possibilities are endless. I really love the simplicity of the illustrations. Originals can be tough to find and sometimes pricey, but reproductions can be found at Corraini Editions.”
Thank you for subscribing and supporting our journalism. If you prefer to read in print, you can also find this article in the November 16, 2026, issue of New York Magazine.
More From The Strategist
- Every Holiday Gift Guide From the Strategist (So Far)
- The Best Advent Calendars This Year (So Far)
- The Best Things Strategist Editors Have Bought This Year (So Far)
- 63 Things You Should Never Buy Full Price
The Strategist is designed to surface useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Every product is independently selected by our team of editors, whom you can read about here. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.