I’ve been researching and writing about beauty products since the 1980s. So yeah, I may come across as a beauty-product fiend. That is possibly true. Friends routinely ask me for recommendations, and I often get annoyed hearing what they’re putting on their skin. (What? You’re bothering with THAT?) I’ve chronicled my daytime skin-care routine here on the Strategist, but when it comes to nighttime products, I’ve got especially strong opinions about what works and what’s an absolute waste. Such as:
First of all, the whole idea that the skin sleeps and restores itself at night is completely ridiculous. The skin is an organ. It can’t sleep. We wouldn’t want it to. But at the end of the day, when the makeup comes off and our faces aren’t disturbed by wind, rain, or sweat — that’s a great time to power on hardworking treatment products such as a glycolic-acid serum, with its now-legendary buoyancy-restoring, cell-turnover, glow-giving skills.
Second, today’s skin-care market is flooded with a slew of effective and safe treatments. Some are longtime favorites of mine from legacy brands; others come from upstart backwoods suppliers I’d never heard of — not to mention the innovations flowing in from Japan and Korea. All of this is good news for anyone who cares about her or his skin.
Third, on the other hand, I don’t automatically buy the hype about all the exfoliators, peptides, antioxidants, anti-inflammatories, etc., that are now added to treatment products. Sure, some of them, like AHAs (my all-time favorite skin rejuvenators) and kojic acid (a skin lightener), have proven credentials. But others — sage … royal jelly … barley — while they may be nutritious when eaten, they don’t come with a lot of evidence that they’re beneficial when applied to the skin, which, after all, is a barrier.
Fourth, and this one is crucial: I’ve learned to hedge my bets when it comes to using high-octane treatment products. To get the specific benefits of each, I rotate them from day to day. So for example, I use only one glycolic product per night. And on non-glycolic nights, I’ll use just one of my moisturizers. I even take nights off with nothing on my face.
Fifth, a confession: I’ve developed a taste for scented treatment products. Late at night, my nose appreciates the ones that are soothing. But they’re not for everyone. Laurel Naversen Geraghty, a dermatologist practicing in Medford, Oregon (who led a past life as a beauty writer and editor), says, “Fragrance added to skin-care products is one of the most common causes of allergic skin rashes. For anyone with sensitive, rash-y, itchy, or irritable skin, it’s safest to choose unscented skin-care products.”
Finally, I’ve learned that nothing terrible happens to my face if I’m too sleepy to cleanse it every once in a while.
I always start my nighttime face cleansing with the moisturizing version of Andrea Eye Q’s Eye Make-Up Remover Pads. Better than any others I’ve ever used, these little discs pretty much do away with every last trace of eye makeup — even the mysteriously stubborn Moroccan kohl that otherwise stayed on my lids for a couple of days.
Next comes exfoliation via scrubbing grains, at least several nights a week. Dr. Geraghty recommends this step not only to strip away surface sebum, but very likely “enhance the benefits of a glycolic peel,” she says. To avoid irritations, the grains, I’ve found, need to be tiny and evenly shaped. Lancer. The Method: Polish has them to perfection in the form of quartz and sodium bicarbonate micro-crystals. I also love the omnipresent lavender aroma. Alternatively, I just discovered the brand new Face Stockholm Green Tea Exfoliator, whose scrubbing grains are paradoxically kind of droopy, making for extra-extra soft polishing. Key ingredients are green tea (and yes, it’s got that delicate green tea aroma), as well as aloe, and papaya. But it’s the addition of cellulose that interacts and clumps up with skin oils and winds up creating the floppy grain effect. Yet even gentle scrubs like these two aren’t for everyone. “Sensitive skin types would be wise to start off using glycolic acid on a test spot before committing to a full-face peel,” adds Dr. Geraghty.
Next comes exfoliation via scrubbing grains at least several nights a week. Dr. Geraghty recommends this step not only to strip away surface sebum but to very likely “enhance the benefits of a glycolic peel,” she says. To avoid irritation, the grains, I’ve found, need to be tiny and evenly shaped. The Lancer Polish has them to perfection in the form of quartz and sodium-bicarbonate microcrystals. I also love the omnipresent lavender aroma. Alternatively, I just discovered the brand-new Face Stockholm Green Tea Exfoliator, which indeed contains green tea and, yes, has a delicate green-tea aroma. Blended with it are aloe, papaya, and, most important, cellulose — which is there to clump up with skin oils, creating a semi-soft grainy effect as it does so. Yet even gentle scrubs like these two aren’t for everyone. “Sensitive skin types would be wise to start off using glycolic acid on a test spot before committing to a full-face peel,” adds Dr. Geraghty.
That same lavender scent pervades the Lancer Cleanser, the Lancer Polish’s follow-up. I find this cream cleanser incredibly satisfying. It foams, making inroads into every millimeter of my face, giving a psychological spic-and-span impression. Plus, it has a rice-amino-acid complex to rev up hydration and suppleness.
Alternatively, especially when the weather gets cold, I like an oil cleanser. Jessica Johnson 3N1 Hybrid Face Oil, which triples as a makeup remover and light moisturizer, has terrific cling power, and within seconds its light lemongrass aroma bursts through. Maybe best of all, on really late nights, when the last thing I want to do is stand at the bathroom sink, it feels so great left on my skin that I don’t bother with follow-ups. FYI, Johnson is a savvy aesthetician who plies her trade in Portland, Maine.
Next comes a toner. I like the frill-free varieties that feel like they’re clearing out any cleanser residue. That’s what the water- and alcohol-free Amore Pacific Treatment Toner does using red-ginseng extract as a water replacement and water-lily extract as a very mild astringent. I splash it on with my fingertips, rather than bothering with a cotton puff (which absorbs a lot of the liquid).
After umpteen years using prescription Retin-A and AHAs, my face doesn’t have a ton of wrinkles, but I do get brown spots (which Dr. Geraghty often calls “adult freckles,” adding that they’re caused by the sun). For stubborn discolorations, I spend a few months spot-treating them every morning and night with a prescription hydroquinone. Then, for the next few months, I switch to SkinCeuticals Discoloration Defense, containing kojic acid, a well-established botanical lightener derived from the same fungi used to make soy and sake. It operates by turning off melanin production and is extra-effective when combined, as it is here, with a couple of other melanin-busters: tranexamic acid, another Asian favorite, and niacinamide (vitamin B3). And since it helps prevent future discolorations, I apply it all over my face. You’ve got to be persistent and patient with a lightener like this, using it every morning as well as at night. Spots begin fading after a month or two. Just keep at it. And whatever else you do, wear a broad-spectrum consistently. “Otherwise,” per Dr. Geraghty, “there’s no point to any of it.”