compulsive shopping

I Can’t Stop Buying Reusable Food Storage Bags

Photo: Retailers

After buying and tossing thousands of throwaway Ziploc bags in my lifetime, I decided to get serious about finding a more environmentally friendly way to store food and leftovers that wasn’t so wasteful. I’m now on my fourth straight year of using zero of them.

When I first began my quest, I furiously bought all sorts of reusable bags, but it was a serious challenge to find a replacement that works just as well as the disposable ones (and is ultra-easy to clean, because if they aren’t, I promise you’ll never use them). Turns out, there isn’t just one product that can replace all of those wasteful sandwich baggies; you actually need a small arsenal of different things at your disposal to kick the disposable ones to the curb. (I’m also not talking about Tupperware, which, of course, is inherently reusable.) After buying fistfuls of the things over the past few years, these are my favorite plastic zipper-bag replacements I’ve found that have helped me kick the Ziploc for good.

The very best reusable food storage bags money can buy are these food-grade silicone ones from Stasher. I have every size, shape, and fun color they make, and while they are pricey, I reach for them above all other food storage options I have in my kitchen. They can go in the microwave, freezer, and dishwasher, absolutely never stain or leak, and even though I’ve washed mine in the dishwasher hundreds of times (with the high heat drying cycle on, even), they haven’t fallen apart or degraded in any way. They are so useful that I’ve branched out to using them in other areas of my life as well.

I use this tiny 4.5-inch pocket-sized Stasher bag to store the cheese bits I use to give my senior dogs their pills and also to stash an individual lipstick in my purse — cleverly avoiding the mess that can result when a cap pops off the tube, smearing lipstick all over your wallet, keys, and hairbrush. The large “stand up” size (which can hold up to 56 ounces) is perfect to use as a makeup bag alternative, because even if an eye-shadow palette cracks or a bottle of foundation leaks, cleanup is a breeze — and when it’s not busy holding beauty products, it’s large enough to marinate a pork loin in.

My most-used size of Stasher is this classic 7-inch “sandwich size,” which is perfect for storing a few handfuls of leftover green beans, a chicken breast, or sliced cheese for sandwiches, while my boyfriend mostly uses the shortie “snack” size to freeze pieces of sliced banana to pop on his cereal in the morning. The half-gallon sized Stasher is the largest bag they make, and it’s good for folks that like to sous vide things, as it has a slim profile and can hold just over 64 ounces.

This cost-effective set of six reusable silicone bags is a good choice if the Stasher bags are out of your price range, but they can’t take quite as much abuse as the Stasher bags can. I have a set that gets used almost exclusively for taking snacks in my car or to work, as I can’t be trusted to always bring the empty bags back home in a timely fashion. They have a flat, stand-up base that makes them easy to fill and are safe for the microwave, dishwasher, and freezer — but will definitely last longer — if you hand-wash them instead. I’ve noticed that the slightly thinner silicone material means they actually work a little better than the Stasher bags when you need to use one as an ice pack for bumps or bruises.

Stasher is my everyday go-to, because they are so easy to clean and so versatile, but these all-silicone food-storage bags are the undisputed star of our kitchen. They hold up to 32 ounces, are absolutely airtight and totally leakproof (I put water in one and stored it upside down for four hours, then squeezed it hard and still had zero spillage), and never stain or retain odors — even after holding oily spaghetti sauce. They are specifically great for freezing (rated for use all the way down to -58 degrees Fahrenheit), and I’ve had almost no freezer burn while using them (due to the fact that it’s ultraeasy to squeeze out any extra air that could get trapped inside and cause dehydration and oxidation — the two causes of freezer burn in the first place).

I’ve frozen huge batches of homemade dog food in them weekly for the past year, and they’re still going strong. I don’t use them to boil food, but they are rated for use up to 482 degrees Fahrenheit (they aren’t meant for sous-vide cooking, though — you’d be better off using Stasher for that). I have run mine through the dishwasher inside out to clean them at least 150 times, with zero damage. I even use them to sneak snacks into the theater because they make absolutely zero crinkling noise. They stand up for easy filling pretty well on their own, but if you’re trying to store liquids in them by yourself on a regular basis, you’d do well to spring for this hilarious old-person invention: a hands-free baggie stand.

These zipper-top bags (made of FDA-grade PEVA material) are the closest thing I’ve found to the classic disposable zipper-lock storage bag. They’re airtight, easy to open and close, and are especially ideal for dry snacks: chips, nuts, crackers, and cereal. I’ve also stored fresh herbs and cut-up fruit in them. They aren’t so great for really saucy items, as they tend to stain easily. You’d also do well not to put them in the dishwasher, as any contact with the machine’s heating element will result in a melted mess. But they never tear or split — and have lasted through 100-plus day-to-day uses so far. They’re especially great for organization: I’ve even used the medium-size one to corral tampons in my tote bag, and the smallest size to stash makeup that tends to break easily and make a huge mess inside my purse.

These silicone food storage bags have the same qualities of almost every silicone storage bag you’ll find (freezer, microwave, and dishwasher safe), but for half the price — and with two major, useful differences. My favorite feature is the two loops on either side of the press and seal zipper that allows you to pull it open easily without breaking a fingernail, but the added date dial that reminds you when you stashed something in the fridge without having to resort to the smell test is a close second. The largest bag they offer is about nine inches square, which is large enough to hold a few heads of romaine lettuce or two giant steaks, but you can also get an inexpensive set of three that also includes a sandwich-sized bag and a mini snack-sized one (good for holding a handful of almonds or cashews).

[Editor’s note: These bags are no longer available, but we found a comparably priced—and well-reviewed—7-piece set on Amazon for $10. We’re not sure if they have the easy-open loops along the zipper that Alison liked , but they come in similar sandwich and snack sizes, have the same simple design and cost less than $1.50 per bag. If you want larger bags, the 12-piece set includes gallon-sized bags in addition to the sandwich- and snack-sized ones for $13.]

These zipper-topped, waterproof fabric bags by Bumkins come in over two dozen cute designs (including rainbows, unicorns, arrows, chevrons, dinosaurs, and fire trucks), can be popped into the washing machine along with a little bleach or vinegar to clean, and are easy to open for little hands (there’s a fair amount of finger dexterity needed to pry open a classic silicone press-and-seal bag). I gifted a set to my pal who has a 5-year-old and a 9-year-old, and she soon pointed out that the clever zipper design doesn’t hold crumbs from dry cereal, crackers, or cookies like regular resealable bags do. I store my foundation brush in a watercolor floral snack-sized version when I travel — it fits perfectly and keeps it clean and sterile in my larger makeup bag. One caveat: these bags are not leakproof, so don’t put anything too runny or juicy in them — but things like grapes and apple slices are fine.

These bags are available with either a Velcro or cloth zipper closure, both of which are far easier to open and close than a traditional zipper-lock sandwich bag. Made from food-grade EVA (a rubberlike material), they are not totally airtight, so use them to stash a piece of whole fruit (like grapes and apples) or a sandwich inside your purse or lunch bag.

Of everything I’ve tried, these are the easiest to handwash: Just turn them inside out and swirl around in warm soapy water for a minute or two, then rinse and lay flat to dry. I’ve used a pink zipper one to bring my daily PB&J to work for an entire year, and it’s still going strong. (The company that makes these, called Planet Wise, also makes a reusable 13-gallon trash bag that I’m trying out. It takes a little more effort to rinse and clean it every time, but so far, so good.)

Once I realized that plastic wrap fell into the same category as disposable zipper-lock bags, I almost gave up on this resolution because the only foolproof way to store cheese in a completely airtight fashion (ensuring that it won’t ever get speckled with those hard, dry, white flecks) is to wrap it tightly in cling-wrap. Same thing goes for keeping half a leftover onion fresh for future use, as exposure to air is the real enemy of all food storage. But once I tried this clever Bee’s Wrap plastic-wrap alternative (it’s been written about here before), I was back onboard.

Bee’s Wrap is made from organic cotton that has been covered in beeswax, jojoba oil, and tree resin. You use it to wrap up any foodstuff you’d normally store in plastic cling wrap, molding the edges tightly closed with the warmth from your hands; the heat softens up the wax, resulting in an even tighter seal than you’d get from the disposable stuff. It’s also simple to clean: Just wash it by hand with a little dish soap and cold water. The best part of this replacement wrap is that it’s far easier to work with than the old-school plastic stuff — it never sticks back onto itself or puts your fingers at risk against a jagged metal edge. I like to buy it in larger sheets and cut it down to the sizes I use most often, but if you’re just getting started, the multisize pack is the way to go. It comes with two sheets small enough to cover half a lemon, two sheets perfectly sized for covering a bowl in the fridge, and two sheets large enough to cover an entire casserole.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

I Can’t Stop Buying Reusable Food Storage Bags