recommended by experts

The Best Craft Kits for Beginners, According to Experts

Photo: Fox

Do you feel that? The sweet thrill of hours spent indoors creating things? We call that crafting season, and it’s officially upon us. Chances are you or someone you know is looking for something to keep their hands (and minds) busy, whether by knitting, doing origami or needlepoint, tattooing, or even fermenting. You can buy everything you need piece by piece, but the easiest and, in many cases, most cost-effective way to try out a new hobby is with an affordable kit that includes all the tools you need to get started. But not all kits are created equal, so we spoke to dozens of experts — as well as a world-famous actress and a Strategist writer who moonlights as a painter — to find the best crafting kits for beginners.


When we asked instructors, store owners, and designers for their recommendations on how to start knitting, Carolyn Heitmann, co-owner of Brooklyn Craft Company, and Pearl Chin, owner of Knitty City, both recommended this attractive kit from Purl Soho featuring “two gorgeous skeins of our supersoft merino, an everything-you-need-to-know instructional booklet, bamboo knitting needles, and a tapestry needle for the last step.” Even better, you can choose from 28 different yarn colors for your kit, from turmeric yellow to a lovely purple crocus-bud yarn.

Strategist staffer Mia Leimkuhler put us onto the Audrey Cropped Sweater Knitting Kit from British company Wool and the Gang. The kit isn’t cheap, but it comes with seven to ten balls of supersoft merino yarn, optional knitting needles, a sew-in label, a sewing needle, and a knitting pattern. Leimkuhler says that the yarn is “very forgiving” and that “the piece’s edges — where a lot of knitting mistakes usually happen — are ingeniously hidden by the seaming and the natural curling of the knitted fabric.” Best of all, the final product “doesn’t look handmade.”

Erica Cerulo and Claire Mazur, owners of the late, beloved e-commerce site Of a Kind, approve of this knitting kit from Loopy Mango, based in Beacon, New York. It comes with five to six bundles of cotton yarn (available in more than a dozen colorways), circular needles, a pattern, and a nice bag for holding all your tools. It’s great for both beginners and intermediate knitters, and while this is technically a summer top, we think it would be great worn as a sweater-vest come fall.


Actress Parker Posey, who recently expounded on the joys of needlepointing, told us she recommends starting with a kit that includes canvases, needles that are the proper size for that canvas, and yarn. She especially likes the ones from British company Emily Peacock. She’s also into needlepoint eyeglass-case kits, which she gifted to Selma Blair, Cameron Diaz, and Christina Applegate on the set of The Sweetest Thing.


For people who like to craft on a larger scale, macramé is an ideal medium involving several feet of thick rope that can be tied into eye-catching patterns. Cerulo and Mazur recommend this DIY plant-hanger kit complete with rope, a solid-brass ring, three wooden beads, an S-hook, and a high-quality print with step-by-step photo instructions. “When it comes to macramé, Emily Katz is queen, and her price-is-right kit is the ideal level of complexity for someone to display it in their home and on Instagram in no time,” they say.


Zoe Dennington, the learning and participation manager for the Crafts Council in the U.K., recommends this highly rated lap kit for kids ages 7 and up. We found a less pricey, nearly identical kit that comes with a loom, soft wool yarn in multiple colorways, a weaving needle and comb, instructions, and more. And you don’t have to be a kid to try it — weaving is fun at any age.


This recommendation comes from a perhaps odd but reliable source: a priest. According to Father Kenneth Lasch, embroidery and needlepoint are relatively popular among the holy set. But even non-priests will love a nice embroidery kit like this one, which comes complete with presorted embroidery thread, cardboard, preprinted cotton fabric, a pattern, two needles, and instructions.


If you’d rather dye fabric than make it, you’ll need a really good tie-dyeing kit. Michelle Rizzi, a PR professional turned tie-dyeing expert, likes the powder dyes from Jacquard as well as the variety of colors the brand offers. “A little bit of the dye goes a long way,” according to Rizzi, who says she typically adds a quarter-teaspoon of the powder to an empty squeeze bottle, then adds cold water. “If I want the dye to be a bit more saturated, I just add a little bit more powder; if I want it to be lighter, I use a little less powder,” she says. The powder sets Rizzi likes are currently sold out, but Jacquard also sells kits featuring three dyes, plus gloves, rubber bands, and everything else you need.


When it comes to the Japanese art of paper folding, you may think all you really need is the paper, but learning origami is so intensely visual that origami artist Talo Kawasaki, the resident origami teacher at Resobox, a Japanese cultural center in the East Village, recommends this book and kit, which has paper, incredibly clear diagrams, and even a DVD of tutorials. Both should help with the intense frustration that comes with trying origami for the first time.


Strategist writer Liza Corsillo recommends the kits from Sakura for anyone who wants to get into watercolor painting. She initially bought one for a solo vacation to the Hudson Valley but now says she takes it “on a hike, for a swim, or to the park with friends to draw.” “The actual paints are technically student grade, so not as vibrant as more expensive watercolors, but they do the trick for me,” she adds. “And the best part is they come with a little water brush — it holds water in the handle — so you don’t have to remember to bring a jar full of water.”


For those who see their own skin as the ultimate canvas, Julissa Rodriguez, a tattoo artist based in New York, recommends this handy stick-and-poke kit from Pick and Poke Tattoo. It comes with three needles, black ink, an alcohol pad, gloves, stretch wrap, tattoo ointment, and sticks, plus an online instructional guide on how to tattoo safely.

Living crafts

If you prefer your DIY projects to be edible, consider the humble fermentation kit, which is ideal for anyone who wants to make their own pickles or sauerkraut. Michael Perrine, founder of the rejuvenation and detox clinic Vitality NYC, usually recommends that beginners start with kits because “they make it easy enough to get everything at once,” he says. This one comes with all you need except the jar and vegetables.

Sera Rogue, owner of the Brooklyn gardening company Red Fern, introduced us to this great organic oyster-mushroom indoor gardening kit that makes it easy to grow your own fungi in a matter of days. “It brings almost instant gratification” she says. Plus, the mushrooms regrow after you pick the first batch.

If the mushroom craze isn’t for you, consider salad. Lindsey Arnell, owner of the Grow Room, an NYC-based gardening store specializing in hydroponics and indoor growing, recommends this “easy-to-set-up, eight-site countertop hydroponic system” to grow your favorite lettuces at home. It’s electricity free and can grow vegetables up to 30 percent faster than in soil.

Editor’s note: This kit is expected to be back in stock on January 17, according to the retailer.

For kids

Julie O’Rourke, owner of Rudy Jude, an ecofriendly clothing label for kids and adults, started sewing with her older son when he was 3. She recommends this kit, which comes with a dull, kid-friendly needle, yarn in four colors, an embroidery hoop, and burlap fabric that’s easy to push a needle through. It helps kids work on their fine-motor skills and, as O’Rourke puts it, “There’s nothing cuter than watching your kid sing and sew at the same time.”

Last Christmas, I, the writer of this story, gifted the 5-year-old I babysit a Perler bead kit. My sister and I loved them as kids, and, as it turns out, they’re still a hit with the under-10 crowd. (Honestly, they’re fun to play with even as a 30-year-old adult.) Placing individual beads on the spiked grid is great for helping kids quietly focus their attention and requires an adult for only one step: melting the beads together with an iron.

Child psychologist Dr. George Sachs recommends this comic-book kit — featuring comic-book template pages, instructions, a guidebook, a pencil, a pencil sharpener, an artists’ eraser, an outline pen, and color markers — for kids with a creative streak. It “provides a kind of pathway to creativity but allows the child to really develop what’s on their mind in the form of the comic book,” says Sachs. “It doesn’t tell them who their superhero is; it allows them to really come up with their own ideas.”

For kids who like to work with their hands, Sachs recommends this modeling-clay kit with instructions that kids can follow or completely ignore. It’s also great for kids who are working through difficult emotions. “This is actually a part of play therapy, in that children are given clay, and they can create whatever they want,” Sachs says. “Often it’s an expression of what they’re thinking and feeling.”

Editor’s note: This clay kit is expected to be back in stock on January 12, according to the retailer.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

The Best Craft Kits for Beginners, According to Experts