this thing's incredible

Mary-Kate Olsen and I Both Own a Pair of Rather Nice-Looking Tevas

Photo: Simone Kitchens

It took me three summers to finally buy these strappy $40 Tevas. The first time I noticed them was when they were on someone sitting outside Sincerely, Tommy in the summer of 2019. A couple of months later, Mary-Kate Olsen was spotted in a pair. But it wasn’t until they showed up in Samantha Adler’s mid-coast Maine “Steal My Vacation” packing list that I finally made my move. “Waterproof and comfortable enough to hike in,” she described them convincingly, “and they’re great in the city too.”

I own almost every kind of plasticky rubbery summery sandal out there: Birkenstock EVAs, Chacos, Teva Hurricanes, Plasticana hemp jellies, Crocs, Salt Waters. But each has their limits. The Voyas, however, with their adjustable bungee-cord straps, quickly revealed themselves to work in all kinds of warm-weather situations: trips to the pool, morning walks, puttering around in the garden, sudden downpours. I wore them on a canoe trip in July, occasionally hopping out to trudge through shallow marshy water. (They dried off instantly and never got gross.) A few days later, I wore them out to dinner with a black, tent-y Shaina Mote dress. There’s something almost delicate about the skinny straps, something vaguely Emme Parsons–ish, but they’re just as sturdy as my Hurricanes and, honestly, way more comfortable.

This is because they literally feel like nothing. The foamy, non-slippery footbed is cushy yet supportive. And there’s no break-in time, no rubbing on your ankles or arches. Slip them on (you can do it mostly without hands — you just need to pull the back strap over your heel) and you’ll soon forget you’re even wearing shoes.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Mary Kate Olsen and I Both Own a Pair of Nice-Looking Tevas