Here Are All of Our Favorite Clogs in One Place

As a Strategist contributor, it was only a matter of time before Mya Gelber found herself tempted by an inevitable fate: the orthopedic shoe. “I wanted something that would ease my runner’s-knee pain, and also look slightly rustic yet stylish enough to pair with any outfit.” And so, she went on a hunt for a shoe “with the aesthetic appeal and versatility of a Birkenstock but not a Birkenstock” and landed on this option from Earth. “I really think it’s a misnomer to even call them orthopedic: They’re simply comfortable shoes with great support. But if that’s what gets them the title, so be it,” she adds.

In our search for the best slides, Drew Romero, a floor manager at Dover Street Market New York, recommends these rubber Sloggers as a less expensive alternative to Chillbies (see below). Easy to slip on with a heavy-duty lug outsole, the Sloggers are waterproof, scratch resistant, and “great for the indoors or gardening,” Romero says. Whereas the Chillbies are offered only in black and brown, the Sloggers come in eight colors.

Writer and clog enthusiast Erika Veurink wrote an impassioned ode to these UGG clogs. She’d been ambiently thinking the UGG Tasman X after seeing them on an Upper West Side mom on TikTok, but it was after noticing her server at Fort Greene restaurant Margot wearing a pair that she ordered them for herself. Her verdict: They’re amazing. As she wrote, “My favorite part of these clogs, other than the washable inserts, is the subtle cut below the ankle. I’ve worn them on after-work walks and to Friday night movies with friends. I keep waiting for a pain point, but instead, these clogs have taken up permanent residence next to my front door.”

In the past few years, the Plasticana jelly clogs have replaced the No. 6 (see below) as the clog of choice among a certain subset of fashionable ladies. Brooklyn Heights shop Salter House and its owner Sandeep Salter are to thank. As Chantal Tattoli wrote, Sandeep and her husband Carson were responsible for bringing this French brand to the States and were long the U.S.’s sole retailers. Emily Bode sent her models down the runway in a pair in 2020, and the rest is history. Features editor Katy Schneider, who loves her Plasticanas, wrote, “They remind me of something my mother would have worn gardening in the ’90s, and they’re just really pretty and unusual and perfect.” (Note: They don’t run true to size; you might need to go down one or two from your usual.)

Designer Phillip Lim told us he has four (!) pairs of these Gardenheir Italian clogs — in a now-sold-out royal blue, as well as in orange, white, and navy. “What’s incredible about them is the way they’re built,” he said. “It’s a full rubber-injection construction, and then there’s a removable cork insole. So when it gets dirty, you remove the cork insole and rinse it down and it looks brand-new.” He wears them everywhere, even to fancy events. “Everyone wears those chunky Bottega rubber mules — these are the Italian clog version, but for $78.”

A Croc cousin, if you will. As we’ve written, “Fans include art adviser Ryan Simons, along with a couple Strategist editors, and Chris Black, who calls them a ‘shoe-sandal hybrid.’”

Former Strategist senior editor Anthony Rotunno bought these OOFOS OOcloogs in preparation for a trip with a lot of walking. Initially, Rotunno says, the soles’ thick cushioning “felt somewhat uncomfortable but in a good way that made me wonder just how not ergonomically designed my other shoes might be.” After the initial wearing-in period, he says “they feel great — stable, supportive, and so easy to wear (especially for travel).” Veteran journalist and Strategist “Auntie Approved” columnist SuChin Pak also found the recovery-focused foam footbeds “a little wobbly” when she tried the slide version since they alleviate joint pain by forcing you to put pressure on different points of your foot. But after getting used to the feeling, Pak confirms that “it’s like walking on two duvets, and this is the duvet of slides.”

With Birkenstock clogs ever ubiquitous, one reader asked Chris Black: “What’s the new taupe Birkenstock clog?” For those looking for an actually comfortable option, he recommends these recovery clogs from Oofos. “The look is unassuming and inoffensive with no holes to attach ‘Jibbitz,’ etc.,” he adds.

Chris Black–approved Crocs may read as an oxymoron, but he calls these “the only passable Croc” for those who “cannot escape the warm hug of a plastic mold.” Compared to the be-holed pairs, these, he says, are “a little mature (you can’t decorate it with charms).”

Most people winterize their clogs by adding a pair of thick wool socks, but designer Sandy Liang prefers these fleece-lined clogs to keep her feet warm in cold weather. Plus, Liang says “the shoes’ Beluga whale-shaped area around the toes is strangely flattering on my wide, flat feet, which also appreciate their slight heel. It’s added support that keeps my feet happy, even if I’m standing on a shoot all day.” She loves them so much she has them in two colors: black and stone. The Q2 style Liang recommends is no longer available, but apart from slight differences in stitching and logo, the updated Ice 4 is very similar.

Sweetbitter author Stephanie Danler tipped us off to Swedish brand Troentorp. She in turn was tipped off to them by Jody Williams, a James Beard award winner and the chef behind Buvette and Via Carota in the West Village. The brand makes basic clogs like these as well as a handful of more decorative styles with cutouts, laces, and braiding. They’re a favorite of the editors of our Secret Strategist newsletter, too — which, incidentally, you should subscribe to!

If you’re looking for a slim alternative to rain boots that can be worn on non-rainy days, too, look no further than the SeaVees clogs that Meg Strachan, the founder of Dorsey, wears just about every day. “They’re a perfect shoe to just throw on if you’re out doing things: running to Pilates, going to the grocery store, picking up something at the pharmacy,” she says. And while she already has pairs in beige and black, they’re so comfortable that she’s debating buying them in another color.

Dansko clogs are so popular with medical professionals and restaurant workers they’re part of the uniform. But they’re also popular with non-doctors too. At least four Strategist staffers own these matte black Dansko clogs. Strategist writer Lauren Ro got her pair when she was eight months pregnant and desperate for comfortable shoes. In addition to liking the way they look, Ro says that in her Danskos she doesn’t miss the custom orthotics she wears for bunions. “When I got them, they became the only shoes I wore for a really long time. They’re easy to slip on and off and don’t require bending over or stooping down. I also really appreciate the lift they provide, which actually makes them more comfortable for walking in,” she says. It should be noted that Builder has them in a lovely shade of honey brown.

Leave it to restaurant people to know what clogs can handle hours (and hours) of standing. These come recommended by Cerise Zelenetz, the owner of Cherry on Top, a natural-wine bar in Brooklyn, who learned about them from her mom, a teacher in Vermont accustomed to standing all day. She says, “They look kind of like clogs and Blundstones had a baby.” Inside, the shoes have the perfect amount of arch and lift.

Like Danskos, Calzuro clogs are loved by people who work on their feet for long periods of time. The Italian brand has a cult following that includes surgeons, nurses, artists, and cheesemakers. But a few years ago, we began noticing them on people like a woman going into her Pilates class in Bed-Stuy and a waiter at Achilles Heel in Greenpoint. They’re made of super-durable plastic that can be sterilized in an autoclave or thrown in a dishwasher and each pair has a series of tiny massaging nubs on the inner sole. Because they’re waterproof, Calzuros are also great for gardening, and you can choose to get yours with or without ventilation holes.

Strategist contributor Kate Branch recommends this Calzuro model that features ventilation holes on the upper. She brought her pair to Montenegro, where the rubber soles and slight heel made for an enjoyable stroll on the rocky beaches along the Adriatic Sea and kept her feet “comfortable while wading in the water.”

“They last forever,” says chef and farmer Pheobe Cole-Smith of the wool Haflingers she first bought back in the early ‘80s at Barneys New York. These wool clogs have a cushy cork sole and rubber bottom so they’re great for wearing as house shoes but won’t fall apart if you wear them outside. “I asked for them for Christmas to wear as slippers, then wore them pretty much everywhere I went,” she says.

Before Birkenstock Bostons were dubbed “the official cool-girl shoe of fall” by cool girls on TikTok, they were mostly seen on menswear enthusiasts, as gorpcore and nouveau Deadhead trends prioritized comfort and casual, chunky silhouettes. Of all the clogs available to men, including Crocs and their high-fashion doppelgängers, these Birkenstocks were mentioned most by the stylish men we polled too.

While Chris Black also gives his stamp of approval to the suede Birkenstocks above, he insists this leather pair is just as much a must-have. He says the “black natural leather is an ideal footwear choice,” opting to wear them for school pickup, while running errands, and through TSA security for convenience.

While these new Birkenstock Crosstown clogs didn’t win Zhao’s hunt for all-terrain clogs, they hold another title: the only Birk that has worked for his feet. Unlike most Birkenstocks, the shoes, he reports, are easy to wear right out of the box. “I’m able to comfortably complete errands that I’d previously tagged as being too far to walk to in my regular Bostons,” he writes, adding, “That bit of extra bounce is apparently just enough to keep my feet and calves from cramping up on longer journeys.”

If you spend hours on your feet, Strategist senior writer Liza Corsillo recommends Birkenstock Tokio Super Grips for their extra-grippy rubber outsole, adjustable ankle strap, and cushy EVA midsole. The professional-grade shoes are designed for people who spend hours on their feet and are worn by doctors and service-industry folks (including both Carmy and Sydney on The Bear). Corsillo prefers them as an elevated alternative to the popular Bostons if you’re looking for “a sleeker, less expected shoe and therefore a less basic, more statusy choice.”

Romero, the Dover Street Market employee we mention above, loves these industrial Hathenbruck Chillbies for their durability and comfort. The rubber galosh “definitely appeals to my utilitarian fetish,” says James Bailey, a creative director who has worked with clients such as Rihanna and the Weeknd. At once rugged and sleek, the aesthetic aligns with Bailey’s love of “anything that looks like it’s an offcut on the factory floor or that will only get better as it’s beaten up.”

[Editor’s note: Chillbies’ clogs are currently out of stock, but we’ll let you know when they become available again.]

According to Strategist writer Erin Schwartz, “Calzuro’s Italian rubber clogs have a massive fan base that includes gardeners and nurses, a trustworthy source for comfy-clog intel.” They’re available in a multitude of eye-catching colors, including hot pink and a teal-y green, and have developed a reputation for being comfortable enough to wear for a full day of standing.

If we were to describe the Strategist writer uniform, it would most certainly include a pair of Blundstones. While many of our writers and editors prefer the classic boots, associate editor Jeremy Rellosa swears by his Blundstone clogs. “I got them five months ago when I started working in a kitchen, and they’ve been great — mainly because the Vibram outsole is grippy even on wet surfaces, and the footbed is soft yet sturdy enough to give my feet support when I’m on them for a long shift,” he reports.

It’s the brand worn by Claire Danes, Julianne Moore, Michelle Williams, and Maya Rudolph, who wore several pairs in her Amazon show Forever. Although No.6 clogs are no longer quite as trendy as they once were, they’re not passé either. They’re not cheap, but they do last a long time. Plus, once a year No.6 hosts a sample sale with lots of deep discounts.

“The danger of working at the Strategist is that all my colleagues have incredible taste and it’s their job to find the best and nicest-looking things around,” Corsillo says. “That’s how I ended up buying these Beklina buckle clogs at 3 p.m. on a Thursday.” She ordered them in off-white for her wedding, and since then, she says she has found the low wooden platforms suitable both for everyday and for special occasions like her baby shower. “They keep getting more comfortable, and surprisingly they are still clean,” she says. Corsillo also loves how the leather-wrapped buckles dress up pants while the block heel keeps the shoe functional. “They’re sturdy-feeling, so I wouldn’t be nervous to wear them to a picnic or while holding my baby,” she says.

As comedian Bridget Everett told us, “It’s hard to find cute shoes when you have big-girl feet.” She loves these size-inclusive Charlotte Stone clogs—so much so in fact that she owns 12 pairs. “When you find something in your size and a nice color, I do like my mom and I buy multiples.”