Liquid eyeliner is a bit like the megaformer of the makeup world: challenging to figure out, but once you do, it can offer dramatic results. The right liquid eyeliner is your key to an everyday cat eye, an Amy Winehouse–esque wing, or a graphic pop of color. And not just for Sephora prices, either: Many of your drugstore liquid eyeliners can work wonders, as the eight makeup artists we spoke to below can attest. Their favorites include options with felt tips, matte pigments, and and even a highly smudge-proof formula that Winehouse herself was known to use; they’ve also called out the best choices for those with monolids, hooded eyelids, and mature skin. And if you’re struggling to master the stroke, one guiding application rule to follow, according to makeup artist Amanda Shackleton, is to “apply very tiny, evenly spaced dots close to the lash line in the shape you wish to achieve, which will give you a much better chance of making a tighter, more precise line. Then use gentile strokes to connect the dots.” Eventually, as you get more confident, you’ll be able to get your flick right in one go.
Best overall drugstore liquid eyeliner
Four of the experts we spoke to praised the Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner for its ease of use, super-inky pigment, and fine tip. “I find felt tip pens so much easier and more comfortable to use than traditional liquid liners,” explains makeup artist Glenn Brownell, whose clients include Eva Chen and Audrey Gelman. “This one is ideal because of its superfine tip, and its fluid consistency doesn’t skip so you can get the perfect wing every time.” Makeup artist and groomer Amber Amos agrees and adds that “the slightly stiff felt applicator gives the control and precision you need.” Both Amos and New York City–based celebrity makeup artist David Maderich also mentioned that the tube has a nifty rubber grip that helps you keep control over the line as you go.
Best drugstore liquid eyeliner for beginners
This eyeliner from drugstore standby L’Oreal Paris was another favorite among the experts we spoke to, especially for beginners, because of its precision felt-tip applicator and removable stencil that makes “drawing the perfect feline wings and flicks easy,” explains Maderich. Celebrity makeup artist Amy Zdunowski-Roeder, who has worked on sets for Bravo and Netflix, agrees and adds that the pigment is “super-duper black,” dries down fast, and is waterproof so it will last all day (and night). And if you happen to lose the stencil, Maderich has this hack: “Apply a small piece of scotch tape to the corner of the eye, then follow the line with your liner.” If you do make a mistake, use a cotton swab soaked in eye makeup remover, like Dermalogica’s Soothing Eye Makeup Remover, to get rid of any mistakes quickly, he says.
Best drugstore liquid eyeliner for experts
If you can apply a wing in your sleep, then you’re ready to graduate to this liner, which Rodriguez recommends for skilled users. The trickiness comes down to the consistency, which Rodriguez describes as “very liquidy,” and the stiff felt tip that doesn’t conform to the eye. It also picks up a lot of product, they say, and takes a while to dry, so it isn’t something to grab and go, but rather best applied when you have time to let it dry. But complications aside, Rodriguez insists that it’s worth it: “It is incredibly, incredibly black, incredibly matte, and seriously lasts all day,” they say.
Best classic drugstore liquid eyeliner
Liquid liners fall into two categories: those with felt-tip applicators — like the two above — and traditional liquid liners. While the felt-tip pens function more like Sharpie markers, the classic versions of these liners, of course, involve dipping your applicator into a paint pot filled with liquid pigment. Generally, the experts we spoke to agreed that felt-tip liners are easier to use and are more beginner-friendly. While it comes down to a matter of preference, if you’re looking to achieve “razor-sharp wings and tight lines,” Maderich suggests going for an old-school paint-pot-and-brush liner, like this one, which has been praised in reviews for the classically thick, stay-put line it creates. Maderich admits it does “take practice” and steady hands to master, and offers this tip: Steady your drawing hand by resting your elbow on your other hand, which will help you get a straight line. The product is also cruelty- and paraben-free, as well as hypoallergenic, making it a good bet for those who struggle with sensitive eyes.
Best drugstore liquid eyeliner for mature skin
Zdunowski-Roeder loves this sweat-, humidity-, and heatproof liner because it offers “a pigmented punch” while still “creating a flawless, even soft-looking effect” due to the precise applicator. She specifically uses it for her clients with mature skin, as the liner doesn’t seep into fine lines around the eye. And if you find that you can still see your lid through the line, Shackleton has this trick: “Lift your lid and fill in the lash line from underneath,” which will also help give more definition around the eyes.
Best long-lasting classic drugstore liquid eyeliner
Zdunowski-Roeder also loves this liner from Milani (a classic paint-pot-and-brush version), calling it “immovable,” and a product that really “goes the distance throughout the day.” Makeup artist Kasey Spickard is also a fan, but notes that it does require a little more skill than a felt tip liner. But, he says, the payoff is worth it. “The payoff is worth the work. Once it’s locked in, it won’t move for the rest of the day,” he says. To add an extra level of staying power to your makeup look, remember to prime your eyelids first. And because waterproof formulas can be tough to get off at the end of the night, opting for an oil-based makeup remover, like Glossier’s Milky Oil (a favorite of Rio’s), is best.
Best long-lasting felt-tip drugstore liquid eyeliner
According to Zdunowski-Roeder, “This product will not move! Whether it’s a hot day or you’ve just watched a tear-jerker movie, this liner will stay intact.” Of all the drugstore liners she’s used, she calls this felt-pen one “overall favorite,” due to the vegan formula, highly pigmented formula, and superfine tip.
Best drugstore eyeliner for creating Amy Winehouse wings
According to New York City–based makeup artist Clara Rae, this is the liquid eyeliner used by none other than Amy Winehouse. To wit, it’s great for creating wings — the tip is “super-pointy and flexible,” according to Rae, and it moves with the contours of your eye. It also has a “very rich black” pigment that dries very matte, is smudge-proof, and lasts up to 16 hours. “Usually liquid liners tend to dry out fast, but I have found that this one lasts the longest,” she adds, so you’ll certainly get the most bang for your buck.
Best drugstore liquid eyeliner for monolids and hooded eyes
Because of the no-budge formula, Maderich recommends this eyeliner for people who have hooded eyes or monolids, promising that it “will never transfer” onto your upper lid. “Most liquid liners stay put pretty well, but L’Oréal Lineur Intense Felt-Tip Liquid Eyeliner stands out as being indestructible,” says Maderich. “I’ve used this eyeliner on an underwater photo shoot and it held up for the entire shoot.” Former Strategist writer Lori Keong also had this eyeliner on her list of the the best liquid eyeliners for monolids, calling it the best drugstore eyeliner she’s ever tried. “I’ve gone through countless tubes of these over the years and like how well they draw lines with minimal smearing.”
Makeup artist Karol Rodriguez also likes this one for hooded eyes, which dries down to a satin finish, has an ultrafine tip, and gives you an incredible amount of control. “Hooded eyes can sometimes be overpowered by liner that’s too thick,” they say, noting that the bristled tip adds to its flexibility. It also won’t skip or bleed into any small wrinkles on the eyes, they say, and “seriously lasts all day.”
Best metallic drugstore liquid eyeliner
For more rock-and-roll makeup looks, Shackleton is a fan of Wet N Wild’s Metallic Mega Liner, which comes in both metallic brown and gunmetal. The hint of glitter is quite wearable, she says, and adds some “shine and dimension” to the eye. When drawing your flick, Shackleton says that if you extend it out too far past your eye or angle it too low, the eye can actually begin to look droopy. To make sure your eye looks elongated and open, she suggests using your lower lash line as a guide, and stopping where your lower lash line ends.