Stuff We Buy Ourselves: The Wallets Our Editors Own and Love

I got my first one of these in 2011, I think. It was a hand-me-down from my sister and in perfect worn condition. I loved it and used it until I left it in a Long Island rest-stop bathroom one August day in 2015. It was not there by the time I remembered and ran back to get it. Getting new cards and IDs was annoying, but mostly I missed my wallet. I bought the exact same one and it’s just now starting to get that nice gently-used feel. The CDG wallet is a classic, and the neon green and orange and zany polka dot iterations are fun, but in unassuming brown it only gets better-looking after a few years.

When I got my first job out of college, I made the rookie mistake of spending my first paycheck all in one place and treated myself to a long wallet from Proenza Schouler (similar to this one), which I very much could not afford. I ultimately got my money’s worth though as I used and loved it for seven years, until I started to want something more compact. I downsized to this much more budget-friendly Cuyana wallet (which shouldn’t be surprising since I’ve already confessed my love for their tote bag and bag organizer) and couldn’t be happier. For a small wallet, it holds a lot — though the zipper will sometimes get stuck if it’s too full — which is good, because I’m always shoving in a dry cleaning receipt or coffee shop punch card. With pebbled leather and gold hardware, it’s stylish in a subtle way, and not in a my-wallet-costs-more-than-everything-inside-it way.

Karen and I always share knowing looks when we spot each other with the Cuyana wallet. It’s one that I came to after a failed experiment with a snakeskin cardholder that was small enough to fit in virtually any bag, but so small that it fell out of my coat pocket and was immediately snapped up by a grifter. This one has the looks of the zip-around Comme des Garçons wallet, but in my opinion, the pebbled leather looks fancier and the tiny envelope for your coins is a nice, delicate touch.

I have a two-part wallet system that I can layer or carry separately depending on my pocket or bag situation. For my credit and debit cards, driver’s license, and other essentials, I use a minimal card case from a company that no longer exists. It’s similar to this one from COS, which I have been eyeing in bright yellow. If I’m not carrying a bag and want to go super lightweight I’ll just stick the card case in my back pocket and go.

But for days when I am carrying a bag, or a coat with big pockets, I stick the card case inside this simple leather envelope so I can also have cash, coins, coffee cards, and business cards on hand. It also fits a passport for vacations. I love how pared-down the envelope is and how thin they both are, even when they’re layered like Russian nesting dolls.

I’ve had the same cream-colored leather Abas wallet for over a decade now. The thing is absolutely huge, approximately the size of a paperback book. Which is precisely what I love about it! It fits about 2,000 cards, so I never have to throw anything out (who knows, I may need a Hudson Valley masseuse at some point in the future), and it’s impossible to lose, because it’s just too huge to leave anywhere.

Editor’s Note: The cream colorway is no longer available, but you can still buy it in this lovely, melodramatic purple hue.

My wallet only has four card slots and one big pocket in the middle, so it forces me to edit (even so, mine’s totally overstuffed — it does stretch). It’s just simple and compact and nice-looking without being loud. I like the case’s color, too, and that it’s not some anonymous black or brown thing.

Of course I bought my first Comme des Garçons wallet at Opening Ceremony, specifically the Super Fluo zip-around Continental wallet with a neon orange exterior. That longer style is great for travel because it’s wide enough to fit a passport, but eventually, I found it a little too big for everyday use. So a couple of years ago, I bought the smaller zip-around Super Fluo wallet in neon pink, with a neon yellow and orange interior. (I can’t find the exact colorway online, but this one at the MoMA Store is the same size and style.) I realize this wallet is a little clichéd in 2019, but I love the way the interior is organized, the feel of the leather even as it ages, and — most importantly — the color, which is so bright that I can always spot it, even when it wants to hide in the depths of my bag.

With an interior zip pocket, 12 card slots, and 4 billfolds, this wallet is large enough to keep my vast collection of barely-punched loyalty cards organized. It was a (very generous) gift and I’m not going to lie: carrying around my money in a wallet I cannot afford feels undeniably chic. Is it worth the investment? As a bit of anecdotal evidence, my mom has had the same Gucci wallet bouncing around in her pocketbook since the ’80s, so I do think this wallet is built to last.

It seems like overnight, every Instagram influencer I follow suddenly had one of Susan Alexandra’s delightful beaded bags on their arm. This little cardholder is equally charming but much, much cheaper. After Lori wrote about it, I decided I had to pull the trigger. I use it when I’m going out and only want to carry the bare essentials. It fits my debit card, ID, cash, and MetroCard, and is slim enough that I can slip it into my pocket.

Please believe me when I say I thoroughly surveyed the “simple billfold leather wallet market” before settling on this one from Tanner Goods. Before this I had a nice black leather wallet that served me well for about 12 years before the stitching came out. When it came time to buy a new one, I was set on finding a simple bifold in a light-colored tan leather (everyone has black or brown, and I like the way tan leather ages and darkens with time). I knew about Tanner from their leather belts, and their wallets seem like they’re built to the same standard: thick leather, strong stitching, thoughtful construction, etc. I was worried when I first got it because the leather was really stiff and the color looked awkwardly pristine, but it didn’t take long to break in and soften up.

I got this gingham Diane von Fürstenberg wallet when it was on super-sale (I believe it was $60), and I love it. It doesn’t fit a ton of cards, but that’s helped keep things under control (I can’t, say, carry around my Washington, D.C. SmarTrip card on a daily basis, and that’s fine.) People often think it’s Comme des Garçons, which, for a wallet, is the ultimate compliment. They no longer sell this exact one, but, hello, here is a very similar-looking one for $9 at Urban Outfitters, and well, here is one from Comme des Garçons.