What Amanda Dobbins Can’t Live Without
Today we’re trying something a little different with our “What I Can’t Live Without” column. Instead of interviewing a celebrity as we normally do, we’ve invited Amanda Dobbins — co-host of the podcasts The Big Picture and Jam Session, and an unabashed Strategist superfan— to write her very own list. When we read in her Substack just how much she wanted to do it, we couldn’t help ourselves. Plus she’s got great taste.
For most of my adult life, my longest-held career goal was to work at New York Magazine — a dream that came true from 2009 to 2014. I learned almost everything I know at New York: light HTML, what to do at a Rachel Comey sample sale, the best place for lunch near Varick Street (Mooncake Foods, we miss you!), and that the best journalism is both rigorously researched and specific to the point of oddity. Put another way: The best journalism is the Strategist. I’m such a die-hard fan that in 2021, I started a special file in my Notes app dedicated to the products I would include should I ever achieve my second longest-held career goal: writing this very column. The note has changed through the years; a lot more baby products in 2022–24, when I was in the business of birthing those, and the beauty products have evolved as I’ve journeyed deeper into the world of video podcasting. (I’m 42, please help.) When I finally got the call to contribute — after some truly shameless Substack fishing — I had to edit the longlist dramatically for both space and, as my other journalism hero Tina Brown likes to say, “the mix.” I’ve tried to include a range of categories here: home, food, fashion, beauty, kid, and brain. I also made the controversial decision to exclude every single product I discovered from the Strategist, which meant saying “good-bye” to these scrubby washcloths (the only product that works on keratosis pilaris, in my experience), Dazzle Dry Red Chili nail polish (perfect, wearing it right now), this parachute beach blanket (recommended by my very own sister-in-law, though I do not endorse the Shibumi and Ruthie Baron knows this), and the Saie SuperSuede Radiant Talc-Free Baked Powder Blush in Ciao (recommended by Hunter Schafer via Rio Viera-Newton, another Strategist hero). We’re left with 11 products, which I hope the editors like enough to ask me back for “What I (Still) Can’t Live Without.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
New! You can now save this product for later.
New! You can now save this product for later.
Already cheating with three products in one. Tina Brown was the editor of Tatler in the late ’70s, Vanity Fair in the ’80s, and The New Yorker in the ’90s, among other illustrious pursuits (and Talk). She more or less invented the celebrity magazine cover and the aforementioned high-low mix, understanding that a reader can appreciate both intensely reported political journalism and some glossy photos of Tuscany or Demi Moore. While at Vanity Fair, Brown wrote an infamous cover story about Princess Diana that she turned into a book in 2007; for my money The Diana Chronicles is the best and savviest book written about celebrity in the pre-social-media age. The Vanity Fair Diaries is just that — a lightly edited collection of journals Brown kept from 1983 to 1992, covering ’80s New York, Condé Nast, motherhood, Hamptons real estate, Hollywood, how to throw a great dinner party, and the media industry in trademark-Brown detail. (An entry that I think of weekly: “Life is unmanageable. My oven has a cockroach in it.”) Now Brown is on Substack like the rest of us, where she writes about politics but also what it was like to have a cameo in The Devil Wears Prada 2. (Where else will you learn about Kara Swisher ordering food to the set?) I’m trying to live my life like Tina Brown and Dua Lipa in equal measure, so it’s important to study the texts.
New! You can now save this product for later.
Campari
Not sponsored, though I’d love for it to be, but Sarah Michelle Gellar locked down the campaign first. Anyway: I’m a negroni person, have been since well before the sbagliato meme, and feel very strongly that the only correct way to make a negroni is with Campari. In Los Angeles where I live, it’s en vogue to substitute a fancier bitter or amaro, usually one with the murky characteristics of a natural and, God forbid, orange wine. To this I say: no. Give me the original, preferably in these exact measurements. We can have the orange-wine conversation another day.
New! You can now save this product for later.
I do my own hair and makeup for podcasts, so I had to narrow down this category dramatically. I’m sorry to Victoria Beckham Beauty’s Foundation Drops, Merit’s Great Skin Duo, Westman Atelier’s Vital Skincare Concealer, and Hermès’s Matte lipstick (I know, I know, but it’s the only thing that stays put). Many products come and go, depending on the day, the wardrobe, how tired I am — but the 19/99 Cream Highlight Stick is on my face every damn day, giving me the “I have cheekbones and I’m having fun” party-photo look perfected by Elle Fanning. 19/99 is a Canadian brand that I learned about from Amanda at Iris+West; mascara is great too!
New! You can now save this product for later.
You hear someone talking about a yogurt — even former Strategist contributor and 831 Stories co-founder Erica Cerulo, the friend with immaculate taste who recommended Painterland Sisters to me — and you think, Yeah, okay, but how good can a yogurt be? I will go door to door for this yogurt if I have to. (No one has asked me to.) I tried to buy cheaper yogurt for my sons and keep the Painterland for myself, but they learned to distinguish the packaging and now scream for the good stuff. To be honest, all yogurt is so expensive now that I gave in. I respect their discernment.
New! You can now save this product for later.
I’ve learned the hard way — see The Great Bathing Suit Experiment of July 2026 — that clothing recommendations are extra difficult. Bodies are different! Tastes are different! Sometimes the products are different, depending on where you buy them. (I can’t prove this, but I swear the Petit Bateau crewnecks I bought in Paris are made with a different cotton mix than the crewnecks I bought on Amazon.) This jean short is the only piece of clothing that I can confidently say works on everyone, and that is because I have done the work. Tall, petite, hips, no hips, butt, no butt (guilty), nine months pregnant, legs of all lengths — I have seen, with my own eyes, the Agolde Parker Long suit them all. I prefer the cutoff style but last summer I was wearing the hemmed version, which just goes to show that people can change, and the shorts change with them. Widely available on TRR and Poshmark FYI!
New! You can now save this product for later.
Please don’t close the tab because you saw the word “lymphatic!” But yes, we’re moving into the face-devices portion of this list. I have tried them all (except for the LYMA Laser because I’m not made of money). I am quite devoted to the Ziip Halo, which has already been recommended on the Strategist by none other than Jennifer Aniston, so all set there. But I find I reach for this tool daily because it requires no gel, no rinsing, no charging or freezing, and no real know-how — you just brush your face, and then you look a little less puffy. I am someone who wakes up with “sushi face,” as Julianne Moore coined it, and I find this brush makes a difference, even if it’s just placebo confidence. (I don’t think it is, though.) I switched from a cheaper Instagram version to Cecily Braden because Kaitlin Phillips said this one is patented, and I like to do what Kaitlin says whenever possible.
New! You can now save this product for later.
When we moved into this house six years ago, its door and trim were painted in a robin’s-egg blue that turned a hundred-year-old former duplex into a Mediterranean villa, or maybe a hobbit house gone on vacation. (The cans we found in the garage are a custom mix, but the closest match I could find on my phone is Benjamin Moore Rocky Mountain Sky.) My husband and I suspect that the blue trim alone added thousands to the price of our home, which I guess is some real-estate advice if you’re selling — but we find the blue immensely charming, and I love the fact that I now live in “the house with the blue door” à la Notting Hill. A few years later, we turned the second kitchen from the former duplex into a primary bathroom, and inspired by the trim I picked a gray-blue (but emphasis on the blue) paint to cover the entire room, even the ceilings. There’s a good joke in The Invite about choosing paint colors and it’s true that committing to something big at such a scale can be intimidating — ooh, it’s a metaphor — but color can bring such joy! Let it in! If it sucks, you can repaint it.
New! You can now save this product for later.
SotoMethod
I spent three years doing IVF and another four pregnant and/or nursing (while supplementing every day, I love you Enfamil), which is to say I had a seven-year run there when my body was not my own. I have responded to this by getting really into working out but in a cool way. If you’re lucky enough to live in New York, you can attend SotoMethod classes in studio, but here in Los Angeles I do it in my room with the app and some free weights. Soto was founded by Hilary Hoffman, who still leads many of the classes and who is the most get-shit-done person I have ever met through a screen, my highest compliment. The classes are divided into four-minute-and-20-second increments, and the main goal is efficiency; you can customize classes according to how much time you have or what you want to accomplish, or follow the specific strength, fertility, prenatal, and postnatal programs. Also, there are no surprises, which I think about every time a Pilates instructor throws one more pike-to-plank into the mix at the end of a studio class. “Tell them what you’re going to tell them, tell them, and then tell them what you told them” — great advice for essays and exercise alike.
New! You can now save this product for later.
Full disclosure: I originally had the Yoyo BabyZen in this spot as my stroller/kid pick. I’m quite passionate about the Yoyo and about travel strollers more generally — if you only have one stroller, I do think it should be a travel stroller that folds up and fits anywhere. (And I do think you should buy it on Facebook Marketplace!) Beyond that, it’s a geography and lifestyle decision; as someone who lives in a car city, I use a travel stroller for errands/restaurants/car-based tasks and my beloved Thule Urban Glide 2 for walks and actual running. This is the Rolls-Royce of strollers. I feel so fancy pushing it. It does in fact glide over everything, including uneven sidewalks and most park terrain. It’s large and hard to store, so the Thule is not going to be ideal for a city-block-based lifestyle. But to actually jog behind, I can’t endorse anything else.
New! You can now save this product for later.
My Aunt Betty taught me how to duck under waves in the ocean, how to make Key-lime pie, and how to make fun of the people you love most. I inherited her solitaire engagement ring and wanted to find a way to wear it regularly; my friend Claire Mazur recommended Kathryn Bentley, who does custom heirloom pieces along with her beautiful jewelry. I met with Kathryn shortly after the birth of my son Knox, who Betty never got to meet, and Kathryn very kindly let Knox come to our last fitting (in his Yoyo stroller), so now when I put the ring on I think of Knox and Betty both, together.
New! You can now save this product for later.
‘Kismet: Bright, Fresh, Vegetable-Loving Recipes,’ by Sara Kramer and Sarah Hymanson
This is an L.A.-specific recommendation that can be made international with the help of a Kismet cookbook and/or a motivated investor willing to bottle and distribute this stuff. Best chile oil I’ve ever had!!! Sold exclusively as a side order at Kismet Rotisserie, which is the fast-casual mini-chain spinoff of Kismet, a wonderful vegetable-forward restaurant where I once saw Ruth Reichl. (Take that, New York.) The recipe for the chile oil is also in the Kismet cookbook and it does get close to the original; they say the cinnamon is the secret. I still think the chile oil proper should be available on shelves throughout this great land. Maybe for my next column!
More celebrity favorites
New! You can now save this product for later.
“For a basic, good white T-shirt, this is the best. I’ve gotten maybe ten of them now.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“These stay in. They can also tell when you have fallen asleep and switch to white noise.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I used to lose good glasses, and now I wear these. They cost $50. They’re beautifully designed.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
“I wear them every day. They’re not so baggy that you look foolish. They’re pretty elegant.”
New! You can now save this product for later.
"You don’t have to be very skilled to do it and get a really long throw, so it’s really satisfying."
New! You can now save this product for later.
“These get just hot enough, but I don’t feel like they’re going to burn my hands or my scalp.”
More From The Strategist
- The Best Things Strategist Editors Have Bought This Year (So Far)
- Hark, the Advent Calendars Arrived (Very) Early This Year
- 63 Things You Should Never Buy Full Price
- The Strategist Fall 100
The Strategist is designed to surface useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Every product is independently selected by our team of editors, whom you can read about here. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.