For a video game with five titles, three spinoffs, and over 11 million players, the Animal Crossing Nintendo franchise has surprisingly slim merch offerings. Officially licensed merchandise is limited to a handful of plushies and uninspiring T-shirts, most of which sell out in a matter of hours. And while there are finally some satisfying (and still-in-stock) options at Target and Urban Outfitters, the game’s fans (myself included) have taken our search for merch elsewhere, sifting through Etsy page after Etsy page of homemade key chains and D.I.Y. embroideries.
But not all Animal Crossing merch — especially handmade Animal Crossing merch — is created equal. So to help you find the best — from actually tasteful tees to fan-inspired figurines (that don’t look too crafty) — we talked to several of the biggest Animal Crossing fans we know for their favorite official and unofficial merchandise. And even if you’re not in the merch market yourself, we think any of our finds would make a very thoughtful holiday gift for the gamer in your life.
Decor and Doodads
For the fan whose merch taste skews minimalist, this unassuming apple plushie could easily be passed off as fall décor.
A little more practical than a plushie, gamer Woodsy, the primary data miner for the Animal Crossing: Pocket Camp community on Reddit, likes this limited-edition journal, which he says is “nice for recording your activities” and making island-chore checklists, thanks to its “clean layout.”
A personalized Animal Crossing mug would make a “perfect” gift for any player “who takes pride in their island,” says Sarah Cwynar, who runs the Animal Crossing inspiration account @crossinginspiration on Instagram. The fruit, grass pattern, and town name can all be customized, too.
And for those drinking on the go, gamer and YouTuber Erika Paige pointed us to this New Horizons–edition water bottle from Target. “I think the design of Tom Nook’s face on this water bottle is so cute yet understated,” says Paige, “and the symbolic Animal Crossing: New Horizons mint-green color on this water bottle is a really nice touch.”
For when your eyes need a screen break, here’s a 1,000-piece limited-edition New Horizons puzzle.
Two Animal Crossing: New Horizons fans we spoke to recommended the Animal Crossing-edition PowerA controllers for Nintendo Switch. Woodsy, who uses the wireless version, assures us that they’re “high quality, responsive, and durable controllers that are really a must for non-Joy-Con gaming,” while Alex Byrd, who runs the Animal Crossing-themed YouTube channel Lex Play, told us she’s a “big fan” of the wired version. “It features some cute villagers and calming, soft hues. It’s perfect for Switch gaming, but it can also be used with other USB-compatible devices and with PC games,” she says. “Definitely a lifesaver if you’re waiting for your Joy-Cons to charge.”
For serious players, Woodsy “really recommends” this New Horizons companion guide. “It’s extremely, thoroughly researched and is beautifully printed. It’s enormous and includes images of everything you could conceivably need, including interiors for every single villager — great for planning out which neighbors you want,” he says.
And for when you’re not playing Animal Crossing, here’s a New Horizons–themed carrying case to protect your Nintendo Switch Lite.
I own two of Nintendo’s Animal Crossing amiibo figurines: Celeste and her brother, Blathers. Not only do they make for some cute, inexpensive bookshelf décor, they can also be used during gameplay with amiibo-compatible Animal Crossing titles, including New Leaf, Amiibo Festival, and New Horizons.
It wouldn’t be 2020 if some Animal Crossing–inspired face masks didn’t made the list. “I love the design of these masks,” says Cwynar. She likes that they’re 100 percent cotton, come in different sizes, and are offered in six different AC-themed designs.
New Horizons players will instantly recognize the graphic on this tee, which comes recommended by Brooklyn-based artist and avid Animal Crossing player Annie Narrigan. “It’s always an unexpected joy to get merch in the mail from Wilbur and Orville, the Dodo brothers,” she says. “So it’s even more exciting to see someone making some of that merch real.”
If you’re looking for even more wearable merch, Etsy has you covered. I’ve been wearing this T-shirt since high school, and it’s still going strong. It’s not title specific, which is nice for those of us who play more than just the most recent title, New Horizons.
These unisex tees are another favorite of Cwynar, who likes that they’re “subtle enough” for everyday wear. “Only other AC players will know where it’s from,” she says, “and I love that!”
Serious fans may be tempted to splurge on this New Horizons–themed sundress from Australia-based Black Milk Clothing, which is, according to Paige, surprisingly stylish. “You can spot some iconic Animal Crossing: New Horizons items in the pattern,” she says, like fruits, flowers, and the occasional villager, without screaming Animal Crossing.
Art and Stickers
If you’re hoping to adorn your gallery wall or laptop with some Animal Crossing flair, Byrd likes these stickers and prints by Mina Kahn. “All of her artwork is incredible,” says Byrd. “I love her stickers because they’re handmade and original, and they’re a unique representation of our shared passion for New Horizons.” Plus, she says, the packaging for the stickers is “also adorable, and it reminds you that you’re supporting a real individual when you make a purchase.”
Byrd also likes the Animal Crossing–themed embroideries from Etsy, which range from villager portraits to furniture and insects. The embroidery frames make “amazing holiday gifts,” she says, and they’re “another way to support a small creator and acquire unique, original artwork.”
For a more understated art print, Narrigan “loves” this one by Sarah Lasater. “I love seeing Sarah take on the struggle of digging holes and finding fossils, presents, or rare mushrooms in her own unique style,” she says.
If you happen to be a politically active player, Narrigan also recommends these stickers made by @animarx.crossing on Instagram, a social-justice-focused Animal Crossing account. “Maya’s feed is hilarious and thought-provoking,” says Narrigan, “and these stickers are a great way to take some of her wisdom and apply it (literally).”
“I stumbled on Abbie’s work recently and appreciate how positive and affirming it is amidst the dark cloud that was this year,” says Narrigan of this cheery Animal Crossing print, which, she says, “actually saved me from spiraling on more than one occasion.”
For the player who has made millions from turnip stocks, we think this hand-crocheted Daisy Mae plushie would make a sweet addition to any WFH setup. (And though it’s handcrafted, it certainly doesn’t look it.)
This woodworked, customizable Animal Crossing title card is “sort of a bonus for anyone who’s really passionate about the game,” says Byrd. It comes with a sawtooth hanger for easy installation, is made from solid poplar, and is “a really unique addition to your merch haul,” she says.
One of the few Nintendo-manufactured gifts on this list is this Animal Crossing sticker book, which just so happens to be a favorite of Woodsy. “There’s a huge amount of stickers in there,” he says — over 800, to be exact — which makes it “perfect for decorating your Switch or anything else, whether Animal Crossing–related or not.”
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.