Between my 3.5-year-old and almost-6-month-old boys, I’ve tried a lot of diapers. With my older son, Augie, Pampers Pure was my go-to because I wanted something that was reliable; free of chlorine, parabens, latex, and scent, with a non-cheesy design; and available everywhere.
Then, when Augie was about 1.5 years old and on the cusp of beginning potty training, I was offered a sample of Coterie diapers and promptly fell in love with them. As I’ve written, they were incredibly plush and soft to the touch — as soft as cashmere, which, incidentally, is what the brand was after when designing the diaper. They also looked quite elevated for something meant to catch pee and poop: an all-white design with only a tasteful logo and wetness indicator, plus oversize leg-opening frills that make your kid look straight out of a vintage ad. And most important, they kept the baby dry and comfortable.
But they were expensive. Ridiculously so. I couldn’t justify spending $100 on a one-month supply of Coterie when Pampers Pure cost half that — and Pure is the priciest option the brand has. I could only bring myself to spend my own money on one more box.
In preparing for the arrival of my second child, Solomon, this spring, I was back to thinking about diapers. Enter Millie Moon. When I was pregnant, a very discerning friend texted me about the brand. “They’re the best cheap diapers by far,” she wrote. “They’re so padded, like luxury diapers.” And she had tried Coterie, too. Naturally, I had to buy some.
First, they’re actually cheap. Depending on the size and quantity, each diaper costs between $0.23 and $0.27. For comparison, Pampers Pure costs between $0.34 and $0.40 for the smaller sizes (newborn-to-3), Pampers Swaddlers (the cheaper line) between $0.27 and $0.33, Honest about $0.37, and Coterie the most expensive at $0.51 per diaper.
Millie Moons are soft, thick, and just feel really nice, as if they’re actually made of fabric — just like Coterie but for half the price. They’re supposedly made of an “enhanced fiber blend” with a “high-GSM” top sheet (GSM stands for grams of fabric per square meter and measures absorbency), but all I know is that they are fluffy and cloudlike to the touch. And, of course, super-absorbent as well, keeping baby dry overnight, too. The diapers are designed with a higher waistband and meant to fit more snugly than other brands, but I honestly can’t say I’ve noticed a difference. (We still get frequent up-the-back blowouts, but I don’t blame the diapers for that.) I also appreciate how sweet the branding is, with a muted pattern of owls (that’s Millie Moon), butterflies, and florals that a mom-fluencer type wouldn’t mind posting. (We did a 5-month photo shoot of Solomon in just his Millies and put them on my Instagram Story.)
They’re also pH balanced; Oeko-Tex certified (which means they’ve been tested for harmful chemicals); free of fragrance, lotions, and latex; dermatologist approved; and sustainably sourced, all of which is common with more premium brands, which makes their affordability that much more impressive. When I put a pair of Coterie and Millie Moon side by side and open them up, I can barely see or feel the difference between them. They both have a cushiony, quiltlike core that looks more or less identical. As much as I love Coterie, I have to say that Millie Moon gives its diapers a run for their much higher price. Plus, many premium brands only sell through their websites, often on a subscription basis, an extra step that I can’t be bothered to take. Millie Moon is available at Target exclusively, which makes them so much easier to pick up as I’m grabbing a tub of Vanicream and Augie’s nighttime pull-ups.
The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.