The Best Women’s Slippers on Amazon, According to Hyperenthusiastic Reviewers

By
Photo: Gary John Norman/Getty Images

Here at the Strategist, we like to think of ourselves as crazy (in the good way) about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed (that’s four-to-five-star reviews and lots of ’em) products and single out the most convincing. We’ve already sought out the best men’s slippers on Amazon, asked a homebody about her favorite house slippers, and singled out the best unisex wool slippers, so now we’re feeling out the coziest women’s slippers you can find on Amazon — whether you prefer dainty ballet-style slippers, kicky slipper socks, or a solid fur-lined slipper (note that reviews have been edited for length and clarity).

The Best Shearling-Lined Slippers

4.3 stars, 1,457 reviews

“These slippers are fantastic. I wear them to keep me warm in the house, and I wear them outside. I have even worn them to the supermarket, when I broke my foot. I wear them when I am putting the garbage out. I have worn them when it rains, I wash and dry them, and they’re still wearable, after two years, without the uppers coming apart from the sides. For $40, you just can’t beat how well they’re made. I just bought another pair, but am sitting here right now, wearing the two-year-old ones. If this helps, then great, because you will fall in love with them, too.”

The Best Fleece-Lined Slippers

4.4 stars, 898 reviews

“These are extremely comfortable. I needed some house shoes that provided support and cushion from being on hardwood floors, and these do a great job. They’re incredibly soft and give the right amount of cushion. They have a hard sole, so they can be worn outside if needed and provide traction. I ordered the size that I normally wear in shoes, and they fit perfectly.”

The Best Faux-Fur-Lined Slippers

4.6 stars, 1,054 reviews

“My feet were cold at home, so I ordered these slippers to wear around the house in the winter. I had Sorel boots in the past and was impressed with their quality and warmth. These slippers are warm and cozy and look great on. They are nicely stitched suede with a 50 percent wool, 50 percent polyester lining. The rubber sole is thick and durable, but I would not advise walking on ice with them, as there is no tread on the soles, just a pebble finish, which is fine for indoors. They have a cushioned feel to them. You do not feel like you are barefoot like you might in less expensive, less substantial slippers. I put them on the minute I step in the house and don’t take them off again until bedtime. I wear them with socks in the winter. In the summer, I imagine they would be too warm with socks.”

The Best Cashmere-Lined Slippers

4.4 stars, 265 reviews

“I absolutely love these. They’re so soft to put on when lounging around at home and don’t slip off too easily. The fit is great, and they seem to be holding up well so far.”

The Best Memory-Foam Slippers

4.4 stars, 843 reviews

“I love these so much. I got two pairs — one for my mom and one for me, and she loved them. They fit perfectly and snugly. They are very comfy and have a nice plushy bottom. I like the hard sole as well.”

The Best Indoor/Outdoor Slippers

4.3 stars, 1,662 reviews

“I LOVE these slippers! I’m a slipper hoarder, and I got these specifically so I can comfortably go outside with my dog — something with soles on the bottom. They are AMAZINGLY comfortable. They’re well-made, and they have heavy rubber on the bottom, so you can wear them outside. I will say that I got a size up, and they fit perfectly. Width-wise, they’re as expected. The fur inside is warm and so soft. Winter is coming! Get these!!”

The Best Moccasin Slippers

4.3 stars, 471 reviews

“I am so happy with these slippers! I have the standard Minnetonka slipper, but I’ve had them forever and wear them every day, so I figured it was time for a replacement. I’m so happy I went with the bootie. Having your ankle and the top of your foot covered makes all the difference in the world for level of warmth, and the insides of these are SO soft. Very happy with my purchase.”

The Best Ballerina Slippers

4.6 stars, 822 reviews

“I really love these slippers! Comfortable, washable with lightweight but substantial sole and fairly thick padding inside. The terry fabric gives, so if you have bunions or crazy-shaped feet, you’ll still be comfortable. The fit around the top is snug, but it’s not uncomfortable, and they stay on your feet. I got these in black, and at a distance they look like black ballet shoes, which is great if you want to slip out in public in them. When these wear out, I’ll definitely buy another pair.”

The Best Luxury Slippers

4.5 stars, 606 reviews

“Searched for the ultimate in comfort and style in a house slipper … now I’ve found it!!! This slipper truly lives up to its reputation … I was hesitant to pay the price, but now I’m sooo glad I did. This shoe will most likely last me for the rest of my life . It is totally comfortable, stays on my foot snugly, and doesn’t slip and slide; the sole is just right for stepping outside for the mail, and is quiet and secure on hardwood floors. It doesn’t have an arch support, but the softness and thickness of the fleece makes up for that (I don’t have any foot problems). I wear a size seven and ordered a size seven, which fit perfectly! This slipper is going to be my ‘go-to’ shoe after a hard day of standing on my feet … I am sure I’ll enjoy these house slippers for many years to come … they are well-made and of excellent quality!!”

The Best Slipper Socks

4.6 stars, 618 reviews

“These feel great on my feet!! Sooo comfy! I am so excited!! They fit exactly as expected. I am a shoe size 7.5, and I ordered a MEDIUM. I am wearing them right now without socks, just the slippers. I also tried them on earlier wearing socks, and they were still perfect, not tight at all! I am in love with these and will be purchasing the other colors as well. My feet feel like they are in heaven right now. These are adorable. The material is super soft. Glad I made this purchase.”

The Best Open-toed Slippers

4.1 stars, 227 reviews

“These are very soft and have a cushioned bottom. They have the bottom that keeps you from slipping. I am someone who doesn’t like to be hot at all, and they aren’t warm enough to be an issue. They are pretty perfect and the price was just right. I highly recommend them to everyone.”

The Best Heavy-duty Slippers

4.2 stars, 816 reviews

“It’s cold, and I know I need some kind of slipper around the house, but I wind up ditching the slip-on variety too often (and get icy-cold feet) and slipper socks pick up whatever is on the floor (eww!), so I take them off as well (getting icy-cold feet). No matter what, I wind up with really cold feet that are hard to warm up. I had hoped that these would help me keep my feet warm and not make me want to take them off.

These are great — they are comfortable, no problem to keep on, and they don’t pick up lint and other stuff from the floor. If there’s a negative to them, it’s that they don’t promote a natural gait when I am walking around the house. I wind up picking up my feet more — which really isn’t a bad thing after all, since I get more exercise. I don’t mind having them on because my feet are finally warm.”

The Warmest Faux-Fur Slippers

4.3 stars, 1,007 reviews

“Honestly, these are the best slippers I have ever owned. Throughout the winter, if I don’t have shoes on, I practically live in my slippers. These Acorn slippers are THE WARMEST slippers, not to mention the soft padding in the bottom that makes you feel like you are walking on a cloud, and the fuzzy inner lining. There were a few people that said these slippers might make your feet a tad too warm sometimes, and I would agree with that, BUT my feet are so hard to keep warm that doesn’t happen very often. Another feature I liked about these slippers was the rubber sole. I don’t have to be afraid of ruining the bottom of my slippers when I go in the basement, on the porch, or take a bag of trash outside. Also, I am not the most graceful person, so I need all the traction I can get.”

The Softest Slippers

4.4 stars, 1,730 reviews

“We’re a no-shoes house, so I’ve had occasion to own many slippers. These truly are the most comfortable slippers I’ve ever had — very warm, soft, and with plenty of room inside. I am a size 8.5, and the slipper size 7.5 to nine fits perfectly. They’re also easy to put on and take off, while at the same time, the elastic band at the opening keeps them from falling off unintentionally. Lastly, the slippers are ambidextrous, so there’s no need to match a slipper to a particular foot.”

The Best High-top Slippers

4.2 stars, 251 reviews

“I love my new slippers! They keep my feet so warm and are very comfortable. The soles are a flexible rubber, so I can run outside to bring the kids to the bus or grab the mail, and the slippers are just fine. They took awhile to arrive, but they were so much cheaper than some of the other slippers for this quality, it was worth the wait.”

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Women’s Slippers, According to Amazon Reviews