Anyone who has shopped at a retailer with few physical storefronts to browse knows it can be hard to figure out where to begin. There are dozens upon dozens of options that all seem as worthy as the next, but the reality is that products from any given brand are not all created equal. When you shop as regularly as we do, you learn that many brands just do some things better than they do other things — and Glossier, the skin-care and beauty brand known for its promise of fluffy eyebrows and dewy skin, is no exception. With just four stores worldwide that hawk its ever-growing inventory of millennial-pink-packaged creams, oils, glitters, and glosses, we would understand if you’ve had a hard time determining what colors really pop or what products give a healthy glow without making your face look like the site of an oil spill. To help you narrow down which lip balms, brow gels, highlighters, and concealers are worth the space on your vanity, we culled through our archives to put together a list of all the most praised products from Glossier we’ve written about, from the moisturizing cleanser beloved by VSCO Girls, to the highlighter stick Rio swears by, to the body wash a celebrity makeup artist can’t shave without.
“I love everything [from Glossier], but the one thing I come back to is the cleanser,” eternal “It” girl Alexa Chung told us. “It’s so soothing and nice on the face.” Celebrities aren’t its only fan: Teen and tween VSCO Girls also swear by the pH-balanced, hypoallergenic Milky Jelly cleanser, which users say works for a variety of skin types.
Glossier’s cult-y Balm Dotcom comes recommended by three celebrities; our beauty columnist Rio Viera-Newton; the co-founder of another style-and-beauty website; and a handful of cool teens. Teen singer Grace VanderWaal “really likes” the original Balm Dotcom, as does Rio, who says it can be dabbed over highlighter for “extra shine.” But if you’re looking for some flavor, Who What Wear co-founder Katherine Power is “partial” to coconut. And for a little color and scent, both Rosie Huntington-Whiteley and actress-slash-model Molly Sims opt for the rose Balm Dotcom: “This hydrating, long-lasting lip balm is seriously amazing,” promises Sims, who also raves about its “perfect” scent.
When Rio’s skin is “acting extra-parched,” she reaches for this moisturizing Super Bounce serum. Formulated with hydrating hyaluronic acid and soothing vitamin B-5, she pats one or two drops onto her skin before applying moisturizer, which Rio says gives her the “perfect balance of radiance and plumpness.”
The Invisible Shield sunscreen is beloved by Strategist staffers and beauty YouTubers alike for its clear, lightweight, gel formula. “A little while ago, I heard through a friend of a friend who works at a major heritage makeup and beauty brand that they’ve been experimenting for years in an effort to develop a sunscreen that goes on truly clear but haven’t been able to nail the formula,” wrote former Strategist writer Lauren Levy. “Glossier did the damn thing.” Beauty YouTuber Madelynn De La Rosa also swears by the product, which “never leaves a weird white cast,” according to her, and “feels like a second skin.”
When Rio couldn’t get her temporary-tattoo-grade Fenty eyeliner to budge, she tried cleansing with the makeup-melting Milky Oil in a pinch — and became an instant convert. “The light, watery formula can take off anything from a touch of mascara to a glossy, bright-blue lid in literal seconds,” she says, adding that it even makes a convincing cruelty-free Bioderma dupe. “For absolutely any eye makeup, I now immediately reach for my Milky Oil,” concludes Rio.
Body Hero Oil Wash — a bodywash made from a blend of hypoallergenic and gynecologist-tested body oils — is beloved by both Rio and celebrity makeup artist Katie Jane Hughes. “The scent is almost fruity and playful, and I love how the hydrating and cleaning oil emulsifies into a soapier texture as you wash,” Rio raves. Hughes is also “obsessed with the scent” and told us that she “loves shaving with this.”
Katie Jane Hughes and Rio also have Glossier’s cruelty-free Stretch Concealer in their daily rotations. “The dewy, creamy consistency of the product works like a dream when it’s used like a foundation,” explains Rio, who says this left her skin looking “even more glowy than” Nars’s cult-favorite Radiant Creamy concealer. Hughes calls this “the first step to complexion,” praising the product for its adequate coverage and dewy, luminous finish.
Celebrity makeup artists, YouTubers, and Strategist writers seemingly can’t say enough good things about Boy Brow, which drew a waiting list of 10,000 people after it first launched in 2015. “For a perfectly messy brow, I love to use it,” says Rio, who started using Boy Brow after Beyoncé’s makeup artist Sir John talked about it in an interview with Allure. “The spoolie is the perfect in-between size so that my brows look kept but nice and big,” she adds. The tinted brow gel is also an easy way to make brows look fuller without actually dyeing them, according to brow experts, who also say that a quick swipe of it can make you look more “convincing and confident” on Zoom calls.