one-stop shop

The Best Men’s Shaving Products (That We’ve Written About on the Strategist)

Photo: Columbia Pictures/Getty Images

You might think shaving is as simple as grabbing the first pack of cartridge razors and can of shaving cream you see at the drugstore. And although that may work, getting a better shave — one that won’t leave you with inflamed bumps on your face or neck or an uneven-looking beard or stubble — often requires some research into the best tools to use. Well, we went ahead and did that research for you (you can thank us later) and, after speaking to dozens of grooming experts and guys with great facial hair, put together the list below of everything you need for a proper shave. It includes expert-recommended products, things we’ve tried and loved ourselves, and other stuff passionate reviewers swear by. Read on for all the creams, razors, combs, trimmers, brushes, cleansers, balms, and aftershaves you need to get a barber-quality shave in your bathroom.

Shaving creams

When we pored through hyperenthusiastic Amazon users’ reviews of shaving creams, this one came out on top. It “lathers for days,” according to one reviewer, while another writes “this is exactly what I would expect an old barber shop in 19th-century England to smell like.” Other top-rated shaving creams on the list include recommendations for creams to buy in bulk, ones to use with cheap razors, fragrance-free options, and more.

Another tried and true shaving cream, Proraso was the No. 1 pick when we surveyed grooming experts about the best shaving cream for men. It’s made with glycerin, lactic acid, and menthol, which barbershop owner Russell Manley told us “work in combination to open up the pores and raise the beard hair. This helps to ensure a close shave with lower likelihood of ingrown hairs.”

Writer David Walters swears by this Cremo Shave Cream, which he says gives him a surprisingly close and comfortable shave even on his sensitive skin. He also can’t get over how long one bottle lasts him, especially at such an affordable price.

Cartridge razor

Cartridge razors with disposable blades are often the most practical option for men who want a quick, safe, and close shave. The Mach 3 is a trusted classic, according to the experts we spoke to about the best razors for men, who note its three-blade cartridges are a happy medium between single-blade razors and newer, five-blade cartridge styles. Other expert-approved cartridge razors include Harry’s and the Shick Hydro 5 (which one groomer recommends if you’ve got sensitive skin).

Straight razor

If you want to try giving yourself a hot-towel-style shave at home, you’ll need a good straight razor. When we asked experts to recommend their favorites, they told us that using a “shavette” straight razor like this model may be the best if you’ve never used one: Shavettes are lightweight and easy to control but still allow for a nice, close shave. Master barber Angelo Ruscetta recommended this affordable shavette from Parker, but our expert-approved list of straight razors also includes more traditional options, less expensive alternatives, and styles from Japan.

Safety razor

When we asked 13 grooming professionals about the best razors for men, 11 of them told us that a safety razor is actually a better style to use than the more ubiquitous cartridge razors. That’s because, like straight razors, safety razors shave with one blade, which means there’s less of a chance of causing ingrown hairs and razor burn. The German-made Merkur 34C topped our list of expert-recommended safety razors, because it has a shorter, “easier to grip” handle and a closed comb, meaning it “offers a more protected shave.”

Electric razor

After testing more than a few electric razors, we deemed this Philips Norelco model the best. “It’s lightweight, feels good in the hand, and catches hairs on the first pass with hardly any effort.” Plus, it’s easy to clean “with just a rinse under the sink.”

Back-hair shaving tool

Walters, who turned us on to the Cremo shaving cream above, also swears by this plastic wand that securely holds a cartridge razor and allows you to shave hair from that impossible-to-reach, middle-back triangle all by yourself. With “a few easy up-and-down swipes,” the Razorba solves the unfortunate dilemma of back hair “with the ease of a back scratcher,” he writes.

Manscaping tool

If you’re looking for a tool to manscape, experts told us this two-headed Philips Norelco shaver is the most essential. On one end, it has a foil razor, and on the other, a trimmer. According to groomer and hairstylist Ronnie Peterson, “The adjustable trimmer is better for sensitive areas like the crotch,” and you can use the foil-covered end “on the chest if you want to go really clean.” Our full list of expert-recommended manscaping tools also includes more specific picks for difficult areas like the nose and groin.

Beard trimmer

Writer Kurt Soller, who tells us he “has the kind of stubble that’s not quite a beard — but always verging on it,” swears by this Philips Norelco electric beard trimmer for keeping that stubble at the perfect length. Among the reasons he loves it are a convenient radial dial that lets you easily choose lengths as short 0.5 millimeters, and a vacuum-suction feature that collects the majority of your shaven hairs. Soller tested a lot of beard trimmers to find his favorite, though, and discovered more than a few worthy options, including ultralight models, a travel-friendly one, and more.

Beard combs

If you’ve got a beard, grooming pros say it’s best to use both a comb and a brush to maintain it (combs are good for detangling hair; brushes help exfoliate skin and move beard oil or beard balm through the hair). When we asked experts to recommend the best combs, the brand that came up more than any other was Kent, a British company that makes acetate combs known for their premium quality and versatility (because they’re made from fancy plastic, the combs are slim and easy to slip into a pocket). This set of three includes a large half-fine-tooth (for thin beard hair), half-coarse-tooth (for thick beard hair) comb; a midsize fine-tooth comb, and a small comb for the mustache portion of your beard.

Wood combs, on the other hand, can be better for fuller or longer beards, according to the experts we spoke with. If a wood comb sounds more your style, the pros love this double-sided Art of Shaving model. On one side, it has wider teeth to “help with thick patches,” and on the other side, “the narrower teeth help with thinner or finer hair,” explains grooming-supply store owner Chad Beightol. For more expert-recommended beard combs, check out our full list.

Beard brush

Professionals love that this brush is made of boars’ hair, which they say has the right strength for facial hair and the best texture to help distribute essential and other oils throughout a beard. It took the top spot in our expert-recommended beard-brush guide, which also includes specific brushes for short beards, long beards, travel, and more.

Beard and mustache scissors

For spot trimming rogue beard or mustache hairs, professionals agree that these Tweezerman facial scissors are a superior tool. They appeared alongside a handful of other grooming essentials you need to trim a beard, according to experts.

Beard shampoo

Enthusiastic Amazon reviewers and bearded Reddit users all love this shampoo in a bar because it cleanses your facial hair without stripping it of essential oils. Strategist writer David Notis, who included it in a list of everything he used to groom his (now shaved) beard, also notes it’s great to travel with, because it’s not a liquid shampoo but a “small cubic soap bar.”

Beard wash

If you’re more likely to clean your beard with something from a tube than a bar of soap, this Jack Black wash comes recommended by roughly half the salon owners, dermatologists, and beard-ologists we asked about the best beard washes. Everyone we spoke to warned against products with harsh detergents that can dry out your face and facial hair; instead, the best beard products “incorporate rich, moisturizing ingredients such as aloe, camelina oil, and shea butter,” according to Eliut Salon owner Eliut Rivera — and this has all three.

Beard conditioner

The pros we talked to say those in need of something to soften and moisturize their beard after a wash should consider a beard conditioner. This rinse-out conditioner, formulated with argan, jojoba, and apricot-kernel oils, is super-easy to integrate into your morning routine — simply apply it after washing your beard in the shower, leave it in for five minutes while you scrub the rest of your body, then rinse, and you’ll have an “extra-smooth and soft” beard without any residue, according to owner Annette Moore.

Beard oil

Another way to soften beard hair and give it a nice shine is with a beard oil. Superior beard oils will contain jojoba oil, argan oil, grape-seed oil, avocado oil, or some combination of the four, according to the experts we surveyed about the best beard oils you can buy. Grave Before Shave’s oil has jojoba oil, which Beightol told us “is closest to the oil in your skin, and therefore doesn’t clog your pores,” as well as tea-tree oil, which helps soothe skin, clear clogging pores, and prevent beardruff. Our full list of beard oils includes less expensive, fast-absorbing, exfoliating, and growth-enhancing options, meaning there’s something for everybody.

Beard balm

Like beard conditioners and beard oils, beard balms add moisture and soften your facial hair. They also keep stray whiskers from springing out of place and, in turn, keep your beard nice and tidy between trims. Three experts we spoke with recommended this buttery one as the best for softening coarse beard hairs (among its all-natural ingredients are nourishing shea butter and moisturizing coconut, argan, and jojoba oils). Madeline Ferrer, senior merchant at Birchbox Grooming, is one of its fans and tells us this balm “leaves beards soft and shiny while keeping dandruff away.” For specific balms to style, tame frizz, use on new beards, and more, consult our full expert-recommended list.

Mustache wax

Barbers told us Woody’s Stache Wax is among the best you can buy because it’s lighter than beeswax and has a medium hold for a more natural look. Experts also like Woody’s because it’s comfortable and easy to wash out. But they also recommend other worthy mustache waxes, including more medium-hold waxes, high-hold options, and even some hair products you can use on your ’stache.

Razor bump remedy

If you’re looking for a product to get rid of razor bumps and the ingrown hairs that cause them, experts told us that a good exfoliating scrub is among the best products you can use. This Anthony cleanser is a solid option, according to the grooming pros we talked to, because it contains glycolic acid, which dermatologist Dr. Samer Jaber says is “good for gentle exfoliation,” and cetyl alcohol, a fatty alcohol that is less irritating than other alcohols but “still has the effect of contracting the skin,” according to barber David Rodriguez. Our full list of things to get rid of razor bumps includes less expensive exfoliating cleansers as well as spot treatments in both cream and liquid forms.


To refresh dry, sensitive skin post-shave, dermatologists and professional groomers point to this moisturizing Nivea aftershave that’s light on fragrance and contains no chemicals or alcohol. It is one of eight expert-recommended aftershaves on our list that also includes options for acne-prone and oily skin.

Another expert-recommended aftershave, Tend Skin is a great choice if you’re looking for a product to treat razor bumps and burn, Jaber says. Dazed editorial director Bunny Kinney agrees, telling us that he now absolutely swears by this stuff to alleviate razor burn. “Literally overnight, shaving went from being the bane of my existence; painful, messy, traumatic — like a perpetual breakup lived out daily across my lower jaw — to baby smooth. Neck rash, begone,” Kinney writes.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

The Best Strategist-Approved Men’s Shaving Products