testing testing

I Tried the New ‘Smart’ Fitness Machines (and Mirror) to Find Out What’s Worth It

Photo: Courtesy Mirror

If the early 2010s ushered in the boutique fitness boom (think $36 spinning classes, studio locker rooms stocked with high-end skincare products, and the rise of ClassPass), thanks to advancements in technology, the latter half of the decade is shaping up to be all about smart home workout equipment. In fact, at the end of last year it was reported that Peloton’s primarily at-home bike membership had more customers than SoulCycle and a higher retention rate than Equinox — and Peloton is only the tip of the iceberg. In the past few years, a handful of new fitness brands have launched promising at-home workouts with all of the energy and community of studio classes, plus the ability to track your performance and even adapt to keep up with your fitness gains.

Since nearly all of these machines will set you back at least a thousand dollars, we tested out some of the most exciting options to see which ones are worth the cost. Whether you want to cycle, lift weights, or even row with a world-class trainer in your living room, there’s something out there for all kinds of exercisers.

Peloton Bike

Who’s It For: Spinning-class devotees who love the community aspect but would rather not schlep to the studio.

What You Get: For the basics package? Just the bike, which is fine if you already have your own spin shoes and weights. You’ll have to upgrade to the essentials package for those. Shipping ($250) includes in-home delivery and assembly so you’ll be all ready to go. For $39 per month you get access to new workouts livestreaming every day from the New York studio, and thousands of prerecorded on-demand ones including yoga, stretching, and more.

What It’s Like: With the large HD display and bike that’s identical to the one you’ll find in the studio, an at-home Peloton workout is probably the closest you’re going to get to an in-person workout with one of these machines. Based on your cadence and resistance level, you’ll get a power output score to compare and compete with other riders who’ve taken the same class (or are currently taking a live class) and you’ll see where you rank on the leaderboard. New rides with live DJs and themed playlists are added all the time so there’s never any lack of variety. If you hit a milestone (like your 500th workout — and no, that’s not an unheard-of number among the Peloton obsessed) during a live ride, there’s a good chance the instructor will give you a shout out.

The culty feel of the online community — Peloton riders maintain lively private Facebook groups and feel like they’re on a first name basis with instructors — echoes the early 2010s SoulCycle scene in New York, but this time it’s digital and worldwide. Peloton recently introduced a treadmill that’ll likely become a phenomenon in its own right. If you’re a competitive person, the leaderboard can be a little discouraging as experienced riders put up some big numbers. Even though I consider myself reasonably fit, I was nowhere close to the top, but that didn’t make the class any less fun.

TL; DR: With the biggest community (which is really the whole point of taking it online) and the most energetic instructors, if you love indoor cycling, you’ll likely get hooked on Peloton.


Who’s It For: Exercisers who like variety, tracking their metrics, and don’t want their living room to look like a gym.

What You Get: The Mirror itself, which looks like a normal wall mirror when not in use, but transforms into a screen during workouts, along with a wall mount and stand, resistance bands, and a heart rate monitor. For a flat fee of $250, you’ll get in-home delivery and assembly. You’ll also have to pay $39 per month for access to live and on-demand workouts including cardio, kettlebell and resistance band training, yoga, boxing, pilates, and more. At least 50 new classes are added each week. Plus, the company just announced a partnership with celebrity trainer Tracy Anderson, so you can train like Gwyneth from the comfort of home.

What It’s Like: Because you’re looking at an instructor, and also your own reflection, it takes a few seconds to adjust to working out with the Mirror, but once you do, the classes are a lot of fun. In a kettlebell class, it was helpful to watch the instructor demo the moves and then check my own form in the mirror. Mirror will also personalize workouts if you have any injuries or limitations. Just enter those in the accompanying app (iPhone only) and, when applicable, a modification of a move will pop up on the screen for you to perform. A running clock lets you know how long you’ll be performing each move before moving on. Like Peloton, Mirror tracks your metrics but since it’s over a wide variety of workouts, you’re given a score based on staying in heart rate zones. Sticking in the correct effort zone will earn you points — and if you’re repeating a workout you’ll be able to see how your performance measures up against your previous scores.

At first, I felt that I’d miss the communal aspect of a group class, since this is just you and the instructor, but I found that the instructors were motivating enough to keep the workout exciting. Mirror plans to add a personal training feature in the future (a front-facing camera, which can be covered up with a privacy cap, will let your trainer coach you virtually).

TL; DR: The most design-minded option, Mirror looks very cool hanging on the wall for anyone embarrassed by gym equipment. The online community is just starting to grow, but the wide variety of workout styles can handle almost all of your fitness needs.


Who’s It For: Anyone who knows they should incorporate strength training into their routine but isn’t quite sure how to start.

What You Get: The wall-mounted Tonal screen with built-in electromagnetic arms that offer up to 200 pounds of resistance. There’s also a $495 accessory package that includes smart handles and a smart bar — both of which attach to the resistance arms and allow you to change the weight at the touch of a button — an attachable rope, a bench, a mat, and a foam roller. Delivery and installation costs $250, and a subscription to the workouts will run you $49 monthly. New workouts are added daily.

What It’s Like: Before your first workout on Tonal, you’ll complete a fitness assessment and choose your goals (like “build muscle” or “tone up”) and the machine will recommend a workout program for you and determine how much weight you should be using for each exercise. As someone who runs most days of the week, I know I should be doing strength training but find the whole weightroom thing a little intimidating. Tonal offers the perfect alternative with guided workouts from expert coaches, detailed instructions, and weight recommendations for each exercise. It keeps track of the weight you use and will automatically bump it up as you get stronger. With all of the accessories, you can do pretty much any exercise you would at the gym — from arm and legwork to core toning moves — with Tonal.

What struck me at first about using Tonal was that, unlike any other workout video I’ve done, there’s no running clock dictating how long to do each exercise and when to move on. Instead, it’s all about reps. Tonal recognizes when you start and finish each rep and only then do you proceed to the next move. If you’re feeling extra ambitious and want to try lifting more on a particular exercise, you can go into “spotter mode” and Tonal will detect when you’re fatiguing and reduce the weight.

TL; DR: Probably the best at-home “smart” option for resistance training, Tonal will definitely make you stronger if you stick to the workouts. It’s like having a trainer keeping tabs on you.

Hydrow Rower

Who’s It For: Anyone who dreamed of being a collegiate crew star, or Crossfitters who wish the whole workout of the day was rowing.

What You Get: A commercial-gym-grade rower with adjustable resistance levels and a 22” touchscreen for viewing prerecorded workouts (nearly 500 and counting) or a “just row” mode where you’ll get a view of the water without any instruction. When Hydrow officially launches later this spring, they’ll be adding 15–20 live rides per week. Along with rowing workouts, you can also take yoga, pilates, and stretching classes to complement your cardio. Just tilt the screen off-center so you can be on a mat alongside your rower. The monthly subscription rate is $38. Delivery is included in the purchase price.

What It’s Like: If you haven’t rowed before, jumping into a Hydrow workout can feel a little awkward. Fortunately, there’s a short “Rowing 101” tutorial video breaking down the rowing movement. I watched this a few times before my first row, and then the stroke felt more natural. Workouts are also broken down into categories (from easier “Breathe” to higher intensity “Push” workouts) and most are comprised of interval rowing.

While the trainers are all expert rowers (like Olympian Grace Luczak and US National team member Christine Cavallo), I felt like they were still getting the hang of being fitness instructors as the classes didn’t feel as high energy as others. My favorites were the ones with two instructors in a double boat as their back-and-forth felt more motivational. Hydrow does have the best visual experience of all these devices: Instead of watching an instructor in a blank space or inside a studio, they’re all out on the open water (the classes I took were filmed in Miami), which made me feel less cooped up even though I was inside my apartment on a cold winter day.

TL; DR: If you’re ready to make rowing your main form of cardio, Hydrow offers a lot of variety in an easy-to-use machine. The instructors are not quite there yet, but the scenery is a nice change of pace.

FightCamp Gym

Who’s It For: Anyone who wants to go to Shadowbox because it’s every model’s favorite workout, but might be too intimidated to actually go to Shadowbox … because it’s every model’s favorite workout.

What You Get: Four foam mats that you can configure to fit your space, a free-standing punching bag that you’ll have to fill with sand or water, hand wraps, and gloves. The smart component comes in with the little punch trackers you slip into your hand wraps that measure your punch count and speed as you pound the bag. There’s no screen so you’ll have to download the app and watch classes either via Apple TV or on an iPhone or iPad (There’s no Android app as of now). A subscription to access the classes costs $39 monthly, and shipping is free.

What It’s Like: Like rowing, boxing requires a little bit more preamble for learning proper technique. The app has a “Prospect Path” beginner program that includes tutorials on specific punches and then workouts that only include the moves you’ve learned up to that point. Filmed in a boxing studio, videos show the instructor demonstrating the moves and fit class members working out at their own punching bags.

The workouts are fun — and seriously hard. They’re broken down into “rounds,” which usually consist of a punching routine and bodyweight exercises like burpees, squats, or lunges that keep your heart rate up between punching. During each round, there’s a punch goal to hit that gives you an idea of how you’re doing. FightCamp currently offers nearly 200 workouts and adds four each week. You can also retake classes to see if you can beat your previous score.

TL; DR: Totally fun workouts with enthusiastic coaches that’ll definitely get your heart rate up. If you do like to mix it up, though, you might feel limited by only boxing workouts — it’s a very specific movement.

Bowflex SelectTech 560 Dumbbells

Who’s It For: Weightlifters who don’t want to alternate sets with other gym goers or keep track of their progress by hand.

What You Get: A set of space-saving, adjustable dumbbells that can weigh anywhere from 10 to 60 pounds each. We’ve written before about how trainers love the original version, and the new one offers you just as much flexibility plus the dumbbells connect to an app that’ll automatically track how much weight you’re using for each exercise. The app features a handful of full-body workouts as well as ones targeting specific body parts, and a quickstart six-week challenge with three workouts per week. Access to the app is free and not subscription-based, but it also doesn’t look like new workouts are frequently added.

What It’s Like: Because the dumbells are connected to the app, the app will recognize how much weight is loaded onto each dumbbell as you perform the exercises so you can track your progress. It also automatically counts reps and sets as you lift. These dumbbells are a great alternative to Tonal if you’re not ready to spend three grand on a piece of workout equipment. You’ll still be able to do many of the exercises you’d find in a gym (without needing tons of weights) and the videos on the app will guide you through the moves.

TL; DR: The most affordable “smart” option, they’re basically better, savvier dumbbells that take the guesswork out of your reps. They’re not groundbreaking, but hardcore lifters will appreciate the ease of this kind of strength training at home.

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best acne treatments, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, natural anxiety remedies, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

I Tried the New ‘Smart’ Fitness Machines (and Mirror)