people's choice

The Best Smartwatch on Amazon, According to Hyperenthusiastic Reviewers

Photo: Paramount Pictures

Here at the Strategist, we like to think of ourselves as crazy (in the good way) about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed (that’s four-to-five-star reviews and lots of ‘em) products and single out the most convincing. While we’ve written about the best fitness trackers, GPS running watches, and watches for men, here we rounded up the best smartwatches on Amazon. (Note that reviews have been edited for length and clarity.)

The Best Lightweight Smartwatch

Apple Watch Sport 7000 Series 38 mm Aluminum Case

“OMG! I love this watch. Really was not planning to buy a smartwatch but when my very good watch stopped working, checked it out. Actually considered the Pebble for its streamlined appearance. But a reviewer rightly called it ‘a watch that’s a little smart.’ So I got the apple sport; all the same features as the more expensive models but an aluminum case. For me that is perfect because it’s lighter and I have a small wrist. Replaced the band with a nice leather one. Love every feature. The activity tracker definitely makes me be more active! If you are looking for a smartwatch, this is IT.”

The Best Cheap Smartwatch

Pebble 2 se

“This is the best smartwatch ever. Has everything I want in a smart watch. Lasts about five days on one charge sometimes longer. What I want from my watch is notifications to see if it is even worth my time checking my phone or continue doing what I was doing and ignore it. One thing I wasn’t expecting is to be able to reply to emails and texts with my voice. It works perfectly. I am very happy with this purchase. I love the retro-looking display. Takes me back to the 80’s..”

The Smartwatch with the Best Features

Samsung Gear S3 Frontier Smart Watch

“Just plain, simply, absolutely love it. Samsung nailed it this time. The machine is nothing short of breathtaking. The customization is really rich, more options as to faces and apps than I really need. I appreciate the gentle nudges to stand up and stretch, and drink more water and less caffeine, The map and navigation apps are simple yet functional. The small screen limitation makes it obvious you are not going to get the full features of a larger phone display, but it certainly does its job. Now I do not need to pick up the phone but a quick glance to the S3 tells me what has just come in. Battery life so far has been very good. In summary, yes, 5 stars.”

The Best Android Smartwatch

Huawei Watch 2 Sport Smartwatch

“This really is the best Android watch on the market. The black leather strap that comes with the watch is great quality and feels fantastic. The watch is loaded with features like the heart rate monitor and the included speaker. I love that I can answer phone calls on my watch. Makes me feel like a spy. It’s also super useful when you’re carrying a load of grocery bags and need to answer a call. I am a huge fan of traditional watches, but the fact that I can switch watch faces at will and get a new look in an instant is awesome.”

The Best Sport Smartwatch

Garmin Fenix 3 HR

“I love sport watches and have had the Apple Watch, Fitbit Surge, and both Microsoft Bands. This watch is light-years beyond all of those. First, this is a beautiful, manly watch that looks classy. The watch has a crazy week-plus battery life (even with frequent use of GPS for workouts). It tracks every metric you can think of: running, cycling, weight training, snowboarding/skiing, paddle boarding, etc. Each has its own metric view. The lack of a touchscreen is a blessing, since they aren’t beneficial on such a small device. The buttons work better and navigation is fast. Smart watch features (mail, texts, calendar, etc.) are everything you need.”

The Best Sport Smartwatch for $200 and Under

Fitbit Versa Smartwatch

“I love this watch! It is awesomely intuitive with exercise. It doesn’t have all the bells and whistles that the Apple Watch does; it’s a fitness smartwatch, not an entertainment watch. But people mistake the design for an Apple Watch. It has a nice look! You can see texts (but cannot answer them) and you can see and answer (if you have Bluetooth) incoming calls. Guided breathing and coaching sessions. Timer (stop and countdown) and alarm. Weather, including extended forecasts. Reminders to move if you aren’t on target to hit your goal. Calories burned. Miles and of course steps. You can also download songs onto it. It’s like a power packed motivator on your wrist!!!!”

The Best Customizable Smartwatch

Samsung Gear S2 Smartwatch

“This watch is great. I use it to read and reply to texts and to keep track of my daily steps, since it syncs with my Health app on my phone. One feature I really enjoy is the bevel. With big fingers, it can be difficult selecting the proper application on such a small screen. But with the bevel I can just turn it to the desired selection and press the middle of the screen. I also really enjoy that i can change the face on the watch. There is a huge selection of faces you can choose from to fit your needs and style. I never have to turn the brightness up too high. I keep it at 5, which is halfway, and I have no problem seeing the displays on the watch inside or outside.”

The Most Stylish Smartwatch

Motorola Moto 360 Smartwatch

“I absolutely love this watch. I’m not a ‘watch person,’ but since I purchased this, I have been wearing it every day without fail. It is very light, looks stylish, feels comfortable in my wrist, and is very easy to use. The charging port is stylish as well. The watch always lasts the entire day, and yes, I do have to charge it everyday. I love how easy it is to reply to email by just clicking on my watch and speaking to it. I also love getting notifications on my wrist when I receive texts, emails, phone calls, and even whatsapp messages. I really enjoy being able to see my steps during the day and even see a chart of my weekly steps. I can see myself using this device for a very long time to come.”

The Best Smartwatch for Kids

VTech Kidizoom Smartwatch DX2 Purple

“This watch is seriously cool! I really just needed an alarm for my 8-year-old son to get him up in the morning, but this is so much more! He just got it yesterday and was so grateful that he helped out willingly on cleaning the house! I like that there isn’t any internet and such … It’s a safe gadget that is a good intro to technology. The two cameras are pretty cool and he LOVES having something to take his OWN pictures and video on! Yesterday he was taking selfies with his chickens! I’m impressed with the clock faces, filters, pic stickers, games, says time for you, learning activities too. We love it so much I just bought another for our almost 5-year-old son.”

The Strategist is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Some of our latest conquests include the best women’s jeans, rolling luggage, pillows for side sleepers, ultra-flattering pants, and bath towels. We update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.

Every editorial product is independently selected. If you buy something through our links, New York may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Smartwatches, According to Amazon Reviews