Just as the moisturizer you used in your 20s and 30s likely needs an upgrade once you hit your 40s and beyond, the same is true of foundation. “As we age, our skin becomes drier and thinner while also losing collagen and elasticity,” explains makeup artist Gita Bass (her clients include Toni Collette, Laura Dern, and Debra Messing). “That, combined with the long-term effects of gravity and sun exposure, causes sagging, fine lines, as well as hyperpigmentation.” Makeup artist Sandy Linter adds that in light skin colors, the complexion may become sallow due to changing undertones and loss of color.
Luckily, though, a plethora of foundation options exists to accommodate these mature-skin needs, as is evidenced by the following recommendations from nine makeup artists, which include a charmeuse-like liquid, a cushion compact, and a creamy stick. (Most of these run above $50, it should be noted, but our experts emphasized the quality ingredients in their picks, which they say are more important to invest in as we age.) While how you apply your chosen one — whether with fingers, brush, Beautyblender, or what have you — really comes down to personal preference (and, frankly, time), there are, according to makeup artist Tamah Krinsky (whose clients include Gillian Anderson and Keri Russell), a few cardinal foundation rules to keep in mind. First: “No matter how you apply it, keep the product sheer and blend, blend, blend, making sure you get into the folds around the nose, under your eyes, and between the brows,” she says. And, start small: “A dime-size amount is usually more than enough for the whole face … you’re not trying to cover your face in makeup; you’re evening out your skin tone.” Finally, every expert we consulted here stressed that it’s key to start with a well-moisturized face: “If your skin is dry underneath,” says makeup artist Fulvia Farolfi, “there is no foundation that will work.”
Best overall foundation for mature skin
Designed to mimic the feel of silk charmeuse, Bass says this is the “holy grail of foundations for all skin types, but particularly for mature skin.” That’s because it hits all the foundation marks: “It has a gorgeous lightweight feel, it’s easily buildable where you need more coverage, and it creates a radiant glow without a greasy finish,” she explains. Makeup artist Lucky Bromhead (the personal makeup artist to Catherine O’Hara) calls out its weightless texture and ability to never settle into fine lines, and makeup artist Fiona Stiles (her clients include Gabrielle Union and Elizabeth Banks) loves that the luminosity draws attention away from any wrinkles or imperfections.
Best drugstore foundation for mature skin
In the affordable realm, makeup artist Nick Barose (his clients include Jane Fonda, Angela Bassett, and Kim Cattrall) favors this “super-hydrating serum formula.” In addition to the hydration, he says, “it covers imperfections, and your skin always looks lit from within.” It also has the addition of a mild retinol ingredient and vitamin C to help it improve the appearance of skin at a deeper level. Barose likes to use a foundation brush, then blend it all in with a dampened sponge (like the Juno microfiber). “Blending over with the sponge helps you pick up excess foundation to avoid buildup and gives a flawless result,” he says.
Another affordable formula — this drugstore foundation is a favorite of makeup artist Oseremi Egure (Lynn Whitfield is a client). In addition to being super-hydrating, it also comes in 45 true-to-skin shades. Oseremi likes the buildable, blendable coverage. “It’s really smooth,” she says.
Best foundation stick for mature skin
For those who prefer the ease of application that comes with a nonliquid formula, both makeup artist Sarah Uslan (her clients include Olivia Colman and Michelle Monaghan) and makeup artist Lucy Halperin are fans of Tom Ford’s Traceless Foundation Stick. “It’s so creamy, easy to apply, and has a great shade range,” says Halperin. Uslan loves the way it “glides” on and that you can use it sparingly (which is generally good advice for mature skin). “You can just spot-treat areas with redness or discoloration if you don’t want to wear foundation over your entire face.”
Best full-coverage foundations for mature skin
Proof that appearances can be deceiving, Linter says: “You’ll take one look at this foundation and think it’s too heavy, but it’s not! When you blend it onto the skin, it’s beautiful and you can keep building it for more coverage.” That the formula also delivers a glow, hydration, SPF, and is packed with ingredients like peptides, hyaluronic acid, and hydrolyzed collagen — all of which become that much more beneficial with age — makes it a real beauty workhorse.
For a daily foundation that gives skin a lightweight, natural finish, Egure recommends Estée Lauder’s iconic Double Wear. The classic formula has an expansive shade range (56 and counting), is oil free, and dries down to a skinlike, matte finish. “I would use this for an everyday look,” says Egure.
Best foundation with a velvety finish for mature skin
If you’re after a finish that’s more velvety — meaning less glow-y or dewy — Barose is all about this liquid formula by Armani. “It blends like a second skin, blurs lines, and sets to a nice velvety finish, which helps avoid creasing,” he says. A bonus: It also has a subtle lifting and firming effect.
Best hydrating foundation for mature skin
A longtime under-the-radar favorite among beauty-world insiders, Krinsky loves Koh Gen Do’s creamy formula — especially for mature skin that can often skew drier. “If your foundation dries you out even more, it will just bring out lines and wrinkles,” explains Barose. “The hydration and moisture of this formula keep skin looking fresh.” To help foundation look even better, Krinsky suggests spending extra time on your skin-care prep: “Give yourself a little facial massage. It feels great, wakes your skin up, and gives your products time to absorb before you start your makeup.” If you want to go a step further still, invest in a great primer like Tatcha’s Silk Canvas Protective Primer — according to Bromhead, it “blurs fine lines, fills any large pores, and gives the foundation something to hang on to.”
Krinsky also loves this foundation from Exa Beauty, which she says “has major payoff but moves like a moisturizer.” Its lightweight feel makes it buildable, so you’re able to blend it in and make it sheer without sacrificing coverage. Ingredients like hyaluronic acid, maqui berry, and microalgae deliver skin-care benefits too and help to protect skin from environmental pollutants, which can accelerate skin’s aging. “The color range is wonderful too,” says Krinsky, “and the texture is a dream.” It also comes in 43 shades and is made with a pigment that won’t oxidize and dry darker or orange on skin.
Best long-wear foundation for mature skin
If you’re feeling overwhelmed by foundation choices, Bass’s advice is to look for key words like “hydrating” or “luminous,” which are a boon for skin at any age, but especially when you’re older. “Formulas with words like these tend to help bring back the glow that we lose over time,” says Bass. But to nail the illuminating effect can mean sacrificing longevity, which makes NARS’s Radiant Longwear Foundation a real unicorn. “It has the most amazing staying power and gives a gorgeous radiant finish,” adds Bass. To even further seal the deal, you might want to consider dusting on a powder for the final touch, ideally with a fluffy brush to help disperse the particles evenly. (Uslan is partial to Laura Mercier Shine Control Pressed Powder “because it’s transparent and very soft and light.”)
Best lightweight foundation for mature skin
For anyone with mature skin, Stiles steers clear of foundations with too much pigment: “They just sink into lines and accentuate pore size, making the skin look even more mature.” Her favorite feather-light option is Make Up for Ever’s Water Blend because “it’s thin but still has just the right amount of coverage.” To allow the foundation to look that much more skinlike, Stiles says it’s all about choosing the right moisturizer as a base. “If someone has oily skin, I recommend a very light, or even matte, moisturizer (like Matte Moisturizer from Ernest Supplies), so you aren’t adding oil to the skin. And if someone is dry, I’ll use an oil (like Serum No. 1 from Vanderohe) to give a luminous, glow-y base,” she says.
Best concealer-as-foundation for mature skin
“I use concealer in lieu of foundation all the time,” says Farolfi. “I’m European, so foundation is like a five-times-a-year thing, but concealer is a must every day.” For those less-is-more days — and less is often more for mature skin, since, as we said, heavier makeup tends to settle into fine lines — Halperin loves this long-wearing concealer with an easy wand application. “Apply it under the eyes and the T-zone, and blend it out to even the skin tone without using too much coverage,” she says. Halperin also gives Dior high marks for its extensive shade range.